Show 4 California a in Wins Wins' ins Opera Star tar Honors NEW YORK YOm Jan 23 2 AP AP- AP Lawrence Tibbett first American opera Olera star atar to receive all II his train train- lag n In n this Is country U hits has b been re received received re- re as a an established ilI ll favorite i at the Metro Metropolitan house Last night Mr tt made his first appearance this II in a leadIng role since his brilliant reception re reception reception re- re last year when he received an ovation that thit was wa as dramatic as It was unexpected el At that time he astounded both critics and end audience by the tho excellency excellency excel- excel lency ency of his his- performance ni as Ford tord In n Falstaff His s reception g last night I t did l not te rival tI that triumph P but it w was 8 euf- euf 1 to mark him as III among amon the favorites Mr Tb ett Is s but 28 23 and comes from Call Cali fornia Mr Tibbett sang sane the role of or Nerl In la ta Cena Cepa delta leUa Deft Deft-an an ad adaptation from The Jest |