OCR Text |
Show " I "the parsons scandal I ConmtccenUt ol tbe iDmtlgtllon I Before Commljslontr Pratt. I ww ritiMii i.'t .rstnioM. llcr illrnallnni tr .llUronelnct Afilml Tlio Jlaralm!. Ilin Wllnm I ( rotf I amlnrJ. Thrso o'clock jrCTlerJiy Bfttrnoon waattta hour let for llm IutmUkIIii ly U. H Coinmlulanrr I'raU Into 111 tliari(M preferred ltjr 0. H. Dlaltfct Attorney At-torney Varlau (at tlio rrqiiMt of t-'lilef Jualica Ymh) axalnit U. B. Maralial l'tlsoni. Tlio cuin lalnt, n filed, up trJ In full In jrtvrJy' -S'lub. Tno lunilnj la taalu lace In tlio Commit"! incr't Court room, In the oor block. Among tlio flrat toar rise, on lli sceun yesterday afier nouu wero District Attorney Varlau anil lila (mltlant, Mr. 1'. II. Hie lieua, liy whuin tha prosecution la being conducted. Seit cmo I Martha) i'arstms, tlia defendant, who until lilialloroeyautiu au aputr. ancc, aoma twenty rulnulea later, 1 asacd tlio lima lii walking reatleaaly to and fru, and occailoually contcralnK with otlicra present. Ilia maimer allowed inmlataVally tha anilely wliich ho (Vol In tlio irtit-ettdlnir;a lu whUli lio la callod upon to playact tromloenlis part It wa netrly 3l) when thv dtfciidant'a counsel, Meran. Jtawlltia nnit Orttrliluw anJ Juilgo Htu li.rwiii ranio In. fliey at onctt exirtand rtdiBlrttoiruittitio deianl tlunaof Hit. twn women, rrliutlit and aulaner, which had been lakrii Unrlnt llio uiorulnrf, u reuet U which tho commissioner at oaco acuvded. Accompanied byllm niarahul, tlio threw alturue'a rii-cbdcd to a rival, tiiartmviit to ttciaci thim, an I weroalmeut luarly half an hour. Uou their rttiiru the Iwiutry Leifan, It be Inir now ufter t o'clock. Ilia witness Annie I'rlndlt, waa then called to the stand. Blit waa extremely ale and ervoua. t ut Rave her answers, on the whole, ltiatieuranl straightforward luamer, though lier voice wai so low at thnea na to l aluioat liuudlhle, iiecrultallii); tha cull fur lur to "apeak UK" .Mr. Itawlliu lint allied that nil wit. I esaea Lu excluded froui tlio court room, and tlio rommlnaloner ao or clereil. ' MIm I'rlndle waa then called by Mr Varlau. (in being aw orn elm ral I her ante WMlwuiiy-four, audahuwis lioru lu Minnesota, rlhct waa at trained nurio 1 y rufeti ton and had been so enzaimt about f mr 3 ears, rjho came to Ulan a jcarajo Kt May. Hlie had been In the enllentlaO sllicerlltliib;f ...'nd, I avlui; lietn lentencid by Ju Ju ant, aault with it deadly weuHjn, to which stittleidetlculll). On lhudy,ofttii tenceahe waa taken to the ,-ttulieiitlary Ivte In tba nfternooii. 1 r mi thu court room stir went b Ju Ice Power's olllc and from thence was taken Into Mar lial rarajiia' pilvale lllce, where sbe la n convctattloi Willi Ibe marshal, having Ueil Introduced to him by Warden Vandirrook. Hhei remilnel In the maishal' clllcei uluutanhour hnd u half. The inarahal rtniatked (coullnueil the wltLcra) that he waa e.rry loetetno ro lollietulUntUr, I ut roiiilaU lie would do what liu could tolualv tint confinement there llcwaiit, lie alao aU he wishid It va o tlonal for blin to ecud mo to the tiuUentlary or I . me In limn, w hero lie could look nfler me. 1 le tin u ordiretl liu licreoand tuicy aui atart eltodrlTomeuul. He smd that ho had rolatlvta 1 1 v i la ic luarthe penllen tlary, ai d my atlornry haelnK nuked lllui to do what ho cuull far me, he would ht me alay Willi tin in. liu elated that he wauled to be a friend to mo allir m term had ixlted, and iuoim Ihan n frlen I lo mo uurliu my lini rlaoiiruent. Ilotliiii took llbertlea with met which I regarded u vary 1m irotr Mr. Varlan-Wcll, what did ho do? Wltrirra -lio klfffed mo and cm tractd me. Mr. Varlan-What dl 1 you di? Wltntiw I u.hi.l hlniaway. He took mo lo Mr. Uoyae'a Iioum, that I I Jilt and the neat day I weut to Iho Jvultentlary. Ou tlio tiintday follou ml lie camu to the punitintlary and rtuniil mo ai 1 waacomhitf outuftho warden' cilice Heaatd hohail wanted to tee me I ut waa toobtlpy to come out. lie then klaaed me and embraced me, acted rudely, nud eald he wanted lo tat at mo aa eonn aa fio-fll le. The next tlimi I aaw him he mine to Mr. (ley aey'a houae, 1 u aa In the kitchen, and he nerved me In the tame manner ai atilie4tilteiitlar). Ho aaldhoknew wheuiho Qeymy'a wire away from home, aud hn Intended to come out on luth nn occaalon and have me ktay with lllui I to I him net to tin It or there would 'allTu bo trouble." A week ortwpluUr I came to town with the luaralial'a leruilaalon toieomymolher mi lliavoaome work done tiy my drntlat. After altendliiK to thla, I went lo the iiiaraliarapilvatenflUe, riierowiroa numler of voplo Kolng In and out. Whin tliero waa no one there ho took me pn Ida kneu and hoi 1 mo to him, kbatd and enreaaed me, and again acted rudely, Mrt(Jeeycamelnnnl the manual K-ut hlmoutou an errand, lhen I went acrona the room and eat on the louiti!. He thin came up to rue, uxpoeed hlmaelf, dtaarranifed iny clotlilo((andmadeKroailyJudiri.nt ro Iialj. A anon ai I coll I J, I loftlila blllce,aud wiutotitlnti llm uorrldor, where 1 remained for toniutlnu, and lhen wont nut to the ultintlarj Ith Mr. (Jeyaey, Afterwnrde I told tint warden of the niiaulta made upon mo ly tlio inarahal. Later thewardui tollmuthatliohalioallle order for mo to no to (!. y' I raid tint ralherlhan Kolherol would be locked up, nud I went Into ncellanlwaa licked 1 . About a week later, I wa taken iultealck, and waa confined to my bed fur a week. Dmlnir that time the maMial came lu with Dr. Hmltli nod rimnlmd In my cell until thu doctor, weut but. lhen he (utlila hand undir the bed clolhta, kl.se U me aud laid he waaaorry to aet, inn alck. "! fil repeated inhtouduct of Marahal Varioni, alio nddel. aflrcled her men tally cry much. Ilerreaanu for not carlmrtodlvuUo what took line lu. lore alio did, waa fear, 1 ecaueo alio waa h prliomr under the Maratial'a ton trol. After telling the wardm what had ha p. neil ahe mado tome atate-nitnta atate-nitnta to miiilttra of tie uraud Jury who vlaltid the euitentiary. Him aftirwardatold rroatcutlnir Attorney flteplllua what liadoccurud. Croat ixamlutd by Mr. Itawllna, wltmaaaad, hrr parmta realded In lila cliy Mt ha la te I aa ii nurae lu Mlnneo!l'anit Inthlarlly an I Kane Hits nami f Mierral ramll.ia where to mini ijrrd Id halt Lake 8lie waa en KigoJ for tomu two montlit at r IhmMIuh home here, uccaalunally nuralnc durliu- that tiroo at other rlacia. (uutloiir.l a to herai. oclatlona with Ham Maiteraou, llm man whom abeatlimi till toahiiol, and for which ufrene alio la now mi ler folin Iruj rlrntnent, the wit km aald the committed the act throuRh Jealuuaj lcaun Muterwn "cnt with oilier kIMi" At the time the did It ahewat under the Influence of lli nor. but had not been In the titbit ofilrlnVIni, cither with Maauraor. or other men Mr Hteheli4 waaabutto oljnct to piectloni on thla head, when the Coin mlulnlitr tald he waadlapmed to allow coiialderablo latitude In a caae of thla kind. Atknl na to whether the hail not been criminally Inllmalowitli Maatei on ho dinted thla ni)t tniphallintlj. Maateraon had Urn a Irlend to hi r. Ho mUht have been a marrlej man, tut ahe waa not aure of thla at the lime the wint out with him. Hhe al mlttetl lint the livl amokni clra when nuratnKi aa a irevcntatlvu lit caaet of l olitaif lout dbeate, but I'lO had not habitually done to. Homo bran ly waa brought lo her Inher tell on one occaalon by I)r Bmllh, theiwnllcntlary phjalclatl, when the waa tick. Iltyond mcntlonliiKtoMr. Vanderoook, about Die SJnd of OctoWr, tho Cutlluctbf Maithal Partona, etieapoke to no ouo tlio upon the aubject until In convcr ration with Aaalttant Ulatrlct Attorney Htcrlione, about a week ago, when thu went befoio the iirand Jury. Hhe waa ou the way down to the city In the enitentlary wagon, with other pru onera, when the related the arllcultia lo Warden Vandenvok. Hhe gave Marahnl I'artoni conduct towarda her aa the only reaaou why the did nut want to work In the (Jeyaey household. The warden then tald be hliniidf woull not Inalat upon her going there again, and that the coul I atny at lilt houae, aa the uiarahal'a behavior had I een In Irceut and a-utrageoua. During thu time alio waa at (leyaey'a home, twngiulltinen, Mr. Daniel and aMr. Wllllama, called uu her. Theformrr -a liartender aho ha 1 nut prevloualy atafrlend'alioute. The olject of lit a vl.it au lo aak her If ho ahuuld atari h petition to I lain hi r l trdou. Wll IKma waa "n mlnlug man," an J thca had known him over tlntu tho camo to Ihn tiwn. Ilulh called In Hie day time, and tlio latter had a lady with him. cllhir of them bruusht her elth) r ilitoia or (Utrt ttet. Hliedld not till Mrt. Vanderouuk hy the lift the (liytt)t, but to othert. Including u fellow prlMiuer, named Maggie Taulk ni-r, alieh.l wuk, after going before thegraiidjury, related what tnd oc curred not U-fuii. Mr. Itairlliin hn cnllel on you In your fill Uforv ou camu down to teatlfy before the grand ury? WitueaaMy mother and titter, and I ha I alaoeiill tliem at (lejiuy'a, Mr. Ilwllnt Aml you nt vermin tlonela word of what had occurred to tliiui7 Wltnoit No, air. Mr. Hawllui Vuii were not afraid to tell Hum: werojouf Wltnect o,Hlr. Mr. Itawllna Who callel at jour cell Iwforu you came to town on luea da) inorulngT Wllueu Noone but the guard. Mr. Ilawllna-Who culled at your cell and remained a conalderabte tlmo the day lichire you came lforu Ihu grind Jtirj Wllneta I don't remember that any one called. Jlr. Itawllna Now, If a gentleman waawlthyou for ah hour or over on that day, you would remember It? Wltueir . ta, air. Mr Itawllna And you lay no one called? Hue Vet, tlr Mr. Itawllna Do you know Mr. Htaik? Wltnete Ytt, tlr. Mr. IUwIIui liu hat been to jour cell, ha.n't he? Wltnrat Via, tlr. Mr. Itiwllna aa ho there on tho day I mention? Wllnce NutthatI rrmimlr. Mr. ltiwllua-uid Mr.Htark uv-r couiulo your cell and ttay any leiiKth of lime? Wltnawa X.elr. Mr. llawllna-Dld Mr. l'lelda ever call ou you? WltneM-Vrmilr. Mr. Varlvn heruoljectnl to thla line of cirtvaexamluatloii rolnif mi further. Wltnrat, In nntwor to otticrquet. tloua, a eld that the till not even men Hon the matter of Iho marahal'a behavior be-havior lo her mother or titter, though thu aaw them tevrral times. Mr. ltawllnt Von felt that jour feellui,a had hoeu outraged by n man whohaljuu In lila cualodj-, who ha I control of j ou aud yel, aa I underfuiud, you did not complain to any of the olllcert I ecauao you thought ho inlfh t do vou harm? Wltliitn-Yea. Mr. Itawllna And jou did not mention the matter to your mother or ilaler, though you had Ilia o portunlly to do to? WltneM-No.Idldnot. Mr. Itawllna Hut )ou worn not afraid that they would glvo you away If jou lol I them that Marahal I'araoua, while jou were In hit charge, had commuted uu Judeevnt aaaault uion your rtoii you weru not alrahl lo dlicloao (hat Information to Ihem? Wltueaa I would not liavn been afruU In trll Ihoin, but I did not do to. Mr. Itawllna- n I jou k t all thla to jouiaelf for wrekt, an I montha, wlttih'ildlng It even from your mother and thtti? WltuiM Ytt Mr. Itawllna Thla matter waa not brought up at all until Wardou Van dercook had been dlacharged trom the iienlloutlary, waa II? You did not ill., t loan II ti Mr. Htepheiw (awMant rroncutlng attorney) until after that, dldjou? WHni..-I did not know whether Mr. Vandereook had gone or not. Mr. Varlau at thla iwlnt luterjioaed another oljectlonlo thla form of iroaa examination. Mr. Itawllna We aliall bo able to ahow a eouaplracy Ittwetll certain perron who make thla ncruailloti agalntt Marahal I'artona, nud I there fore aak ermlailon to havu u largo latl. ludn ill iroaa a lamination, and at at feeling till worn in' credlblllt)'. Mr Varlau We havenonljeuilon lo that If Iho dti'eniticau ahow a con-tplraiy, con-tplraiy, but we do olject lu iiittlont being nked over an I ovcrugaiu. The oomtnlatloucr repeated what he ha I before tal 1, that under tho piou llarclrctiniatancet of lhlacao lie waa dlapoaed to allow tho defrUlo uverj lMtble latitude. Aoawrrlng vounaelthe witucta tald Mr, Ilell neer vlalted mo In my cell, lit km Leuu lu there, but not lu vltllnir. I couli not tell how many time ht tit attf prd Into my cell. Mr Itawllna .DliI you tver havn any lUlui-tilty with tha Iluikt girl? The wit nuatYm, air. Mr Iltwllna What wiu thee cuio of 117 rhowilliiMi She told uiit.ulhanu.mt Mr newllna Wh miri Ihey? Hie wiluuu Maggie I aulknir iol I me that Mlat llankt hi I told Iho war den that I ha I been criminally Intimate with Ihe guard. Thla waa oljrttr.l to aa hrartay an I tlrlckeu out ly dlrmtlouof tht com mlttloner. Mr. Ittwlln Did you or did you not have Ihn reputation among tho triaineraof telng criminally Intlmnte with cenalnof the guardaat the lnl tcnttarj? Tlila brought Mr. Vnrlan promitly lo hi feet with tho remark Wo nlject to thai ipieatlou aa luiiierlliienl, tcan dalout, and not proper in any way. Mr Hiwllua Ountel ha made a dlallnrt charge, vlnuallj aciutmg tho marahal of, at any rate, committing an Indecent a criminal aaaault ill-oil thla wllueaa, airalnat lur will an I lawful coiimiiI. Now I any that upon audi n chargo a that, Involving the chaatlly of tlio erton, wti havo tho right, aa reflecting utiuu Hie tiuvalloil a to whither the It lo thuw her general rtrulatlou. Mr. ailau replied that thla wti a charge of oppteetlon and Inhumanity towards a i rlaoner, and even If thla were n tiwclfli! charge of teductlou, for uliTitlon, orravlahlng, auoh a tiucatlou would be lmproiier. In no caauouult aucrt a queatlou aa that be allow ed to bo ut lu a court of Juttlee. "Dl I yoic not," countel for tin defeiidint atked, "have thu n puta Hon among tho guard and lhatllttle community of belug m and o7" The onlj held open to cuuntel waa loahow the woman' general reputation, and that mutt b In llil commuuliy, not in a i-ruln houao. fhla. tall .Mr. Varlau, waa a "flailing" luuulry of oounael Into the lOnaclouanMi of thla woman. Iteobltcted tlrongly to ler belngaakullf alia did not know that her repu'atlon among the guarda nnd couvlt la at tho ieiiltoiittary waa to and au? Aafarnacounacl for thudefenao lould go waa to aak lur If the wan guilty of theleofleliioii, Ihu cummlaaloner aiiitalued Mr. Varlan'ulJectfon. Two further iiueallona tut by Mr. lUwlina, the witnea deuicd having I ld Hie girl Itinka that tho riaiou tho lid not like lo ttay nt Hie Ueyrey huuac waa 1 cauae lite miatreaa objeil ed to her "tportlng frlenda" vlalllng her Hun. At thla stage of tho linpilry It 1 IngA w au adjiurnmiut waa takin until len o'clock this moriilng. this MunNiNii'd liiucMiiiMnj. At In IS thla morning the 1'arson lnvettlgatlun waa agalu taken up lu Coniuiiialonvr Trail's lourt, Hie tamu COllnael being reaenl to r rttrnt the putecutlon and deli lite aa aparud jettirday. Marahal I'artona, the Ue leniUul, na before, nt cuj led n teat near III nlltrneyt and llttened with tho LfcLtiifct tulrfct tit tin. rurlliKP alitti,. menu mado I y the wilueti I'rindlr. Auule Trlndle was re called and her croat txamliiallou reeumed by Mr. ltawllnt. Die marahal told her, shu talJ, that It Wat at Judge Tower' tug Station he Intendod to take her to the llryary retldellte. Hhe did not know whether or not her attorney did make that tuggtatluli to lilni. Wlillo the wa III MalllialTanioni' onlce,oti the alter noou of her tentfiice, raon weru I attlng In nnd out much of the time, llm door waa not locked. All tho marahal' converratlon with her on thu tulject Of Ilia wlahlng lo 10 her frleut waa lu auaudlblntoueof vole; aujouenear could have heard what lie aald. When liu attempted lo kla her outlo way to tho penitentiary, while In lila carriage, the became angry and sla lied hla face. Hodld nil erein to treat It, howuver, very terloutly, Un their reaching thu Utyicy houao thu marahal rxreaol a wlah that .Mrt (leyaey ahuuld itccomuodatu her and mako her com'ottable. Hhe was lu alecp at the lielilleullary. Wllutni wasnixtiiueatluneil astolitrrtceplion al thai llitllulluu)w here the marilial bade her "good nlghl"ou leaving) and her dally llfulu Hie Uytey houachold, O l the llrat ot-Latloil of the uiarahal'a vl.lt to thu house after taking her there liu tamo Into thu kitchen, talku.1 with her foraomc live minute and mado retcatcd Indeieut projijealt. Home of Iho memtwra of tho aoilly were Hull In au aljclulng room. Ha ixprcaani his regret thai thu"io) tewerearound,"a lie wanted toboalonuwlth her, and tald lni low tunoufvulco tint aa toon as ho coul I arrange It, ho wuullcomo andaeu hur aloni. He kluid and earetseU her,aud laid hold of hi r limb. Hhe rerlaleU and "Hiked" from Ihu very Hut. Mr. iUwilu.-lIu T.l.ud lu this noniliiet for rlvu lllillUtta. tr.ll ant. tliougli there wero people In tho ad Joining room? Wltueat Yet, I tclieveionie of the family wero there, The door waa ilotud. .Mr. ltawllnt Why didn't jou, when the marahsl itmu and mado In decent) ropotala, step to that door and open II, II II werolluacd? Wllueaa 1 don't know that 1 thought nuy thing alout II, I onlj tried tit lirnl.rt lit vat Ir. Mr, llawllua Now, hu dllu'lcomu there wlitn jou wero alono on any ollu r occsalou, did he,' WIHitis No, air. To other nues Hon tho tald thu did not think the manual would como lo thudeytey 'houte and make ludfiut proimsal lu her, nolwllhstandlt g hla revltma behavior, be-havior, or she would have oljeoteil lu KOthero In the first Intlanet, Hhu I rorerred to go to Uey tvj s rather than jeinalu lu iho onltcutlnry Uto gellur. Hhe otjeeicd to lilt enr-ease enr-ease In Hut private nnlcu at Iho ; enllentlsry on a subteiiuunl oe caalon. lie then had hold of in raruia an I klitc-d her. hue rcuutttcd him, augrlly, to let her go and tried to break away from him, A ton uf Mr, (lej rey tntertid the room Ju.t ul thla time, ami tho marahal dcsl-ictl on Ihe opening ol tho door, which had not bcou locked. On another oeeaslon when Iho mar shal won ni Hug liiiproiwrly towards her In hla i Mice In tho Wasatch lullJIni", Mr. (Icjteycamein, aud ho drained, Hhe hail vlgoroualy nal.tvd hla rarras l all the time. Hu ixpused lilunelf to her an I uhrrwlau acted ludreently. Ihu door leading Into the liiiln hall waalheujuat ajar, Hho forced her self nway from film an I wont out of the room Into tho corridor, I ut did not ery out or lellaujonu what had trans Ired. Till wat ultout i u'cloek In Hu afternoon. On another occasion, wl en lick, the marshal arcoiui aided tbe doctor Into her coll but the had nu reiollictlou whauvcr of having tent lor Mr, Taraont. Mr. lUivllne- 1)1 In't jou lend for Marahal Taraona tlulniorulng, b Mr. lOjiUlnucd on J ujt 8,) (tbliffnu'rf front J'aet 0 1 THE l'AUSO.NS' bCANDAIa. Ward, Willi Hie Intention of roklnir lilui to jrmlt Sim Mal r.on to come and ate you1 Wltnn N, t did nr.t I lol I Warden War-den Vandeti mk that I altouM like to mi the niarnhal The rea n waa tba I I wanted to oak lilm not bi krep m locked up Wltnma raid aha ill I once wrllelo Waitcriu from the eiillei. tlary. When tliu maralial acted lm roterly luwarda Iter In tlm cell, durinlieraiekiiiv, ehe held him oil aa well a alio cotil 1. Tiioinraliallial orderid lier to bu looked up lu the till. Mr. Ilawllni Who told you llia.tr WltiiMii Mr, Vabderrook I"1J tun It wont I be well for tnetoatopln the cell until I could aeo the nmilii!. Mr. Ibiwllii Did bo ever tell you that the material bad ordered you lo te locked up In tba cell? Wllne.i-At thla tint.? Mr. Itawllna At auylntri Wltneat Vr, air. Mr. lliwllr,.-When? Wltneat About n week after that, I think, when I weal outaldu. Mr. Itawllna Dhlyuu itotaay In the preaencaof Mr. Htark that you would like to tee that old a of n b of a ntarthal out of ItlaollloV Wlllieaa (vmihallcall)-No, I did uot. Mr. llv.!lr,.-A.od did not Mr. Htarkaty, "Well, If you will ttlck to )ourlory llntcail la iljne?" Wllneea Xoaucb IIiIiik. In further Lroaa-riaiulnatlon the moat positively denied tiav neapneed heraolf InileirDtly to any of me fcuarde or i rui intra at the iieiutentlary. Mr. Itiwllnt-Didii't you ur beforo you taiuouowllMtlioKrand Jury lat riittJay that ou were roIiiii to have Ilia marrhal ludlclcd, If awtarlng bard eiiottjli ciuld do any goo-J.or wurda to thaterr.tt? Wllna-No, air, I did not. Mr. Iliwllna waa procredln further lo Inttrroiiate the wllue-i nn the iu. tlon uf her ritnllou at the poulteu-tlary, poulteu-tlary, aheu the Ctmniloluner Inter. w I, aa he did ycalorday alterifjou. Mr. Iltwlht. (Willi tome wanuth)-I wanuth)-I tln.uld think tha itovernmcnt, In thla Imiulry, would otiiiit tho lariieal latl-time latl-time nl lnvetlalloli, and I Iml.l that wo are eutlllod lo It, Mr. Varlan nniwrred Mr. Itawllna byamylnKtliat lie considered the wltneat wlt-neat It ail alretdy been tulllcieutly tiicitlund on the point uf Iter reputation. reputa-tion. Him waa livru n heliileu crcilure and ointht to lie protected, Mr. ltawllnn Hbeltliot btlp'cat at all. Hhe lil-fought here at neword ti attack the lira eu I character pf tliu il. lendant. Hho lit rounht hero and per-milted per-milted to aay, In various farmi, that on certain occatlona Indecent rotioaala acre niaJe to Iter tuch aa no man would nuke unleaan brute In human fiirm, knit aeltnva to meet llilr We liavo n rUtit to teat her reputation, I any, even uurluit the time the waa a prltouer at the lenlteiillary. The C'otiiml lon.-r I coitaldcr the ohjettlon by Mr. Varlan well taken and ahould lie ludalnH. The rule of law It tlut when the neutral ripuuf. lion of n wltutM for chaitlty la In volveJItmuttbemetby Ifcueral evN deuceand not ilKcllloacta of iinchae. til)? That It tho rule, at I uudertland It. Mr. Itawllna (ait teveral other elml lar iiuisatlitta to the wltneat all of which were overruled. Tlirie Included the aliened provldlne of a went key admlttliiK other prltouera Into tier oell, and there alto came an Inalnti atlon totheeirectthatthewllueaauHnl to tit In Iter cell In an Indecvut pottiire and amoke tluarrttea. Thla latter elicited an Indlnnitit look from the wllneM and a warm rttort from the 1 roiecullnir; attorney, who raid he now thought It quite time the wltniaa waa prolicted. Tho Commlatloner tald lie hail over ruled the putltlia: uf cettalll iiieatloua aln ady. and would now do tu attain. Mr. itawllna, with a proleat, then look tip another lino of crott eiamliiatiou deallittf Willi Mlit I'rln. illu'a convoraullona with Maggie raiilkuer, aa to tho nmra'ial'a in-decent in-decent j-opoal. Hhe did not nt ull appreciate, the aald, tho mtlonot Mar. thai l'araolia In ordering her to be licked up lu Iter nil, but liecauie of thla the entertained no lll-wlll low ardi him. raulkmr.oueday InKovembtr, aald to wilnett, "What do you think ut the marahal? ritaold wreich wanted meto Hay with lilm rllit In hit ultlte, and be irled It on before that." Mr. Vurlau again ol.Jtclctl; but Mr. ltawllua anaaeretl that tho aoleiurH.e of Itla croe-v-taarulnallou waa to ehow a conrplrary. Mr. Varlan-Well, go ahead. Wllneira thin ttated that Macule Faulkner tntd her that Mr. Hilton, at Ihu ItelorniHvhoiil, commlltul an ln dicuntruuaullupon her. Wltueia wai not awaru that an t flirt waa tivluu; ma le all alonic tu Ket Marahal l'araone outiif ttllce. Hhe could not remember whether or not the riad the Unbuilt editorial accuiluif tho marahal of boatlallty aud ether ufTtnaea. Mr. lUnllni-Dldnottheieadlntiof that ndllorlal tluully Induie )ou to limkntheaucharKee, to Mr. Hlehellt, ajtelntt Marahal Taraona? WIlma-.No. ali; 1 malt up my mini, after itulmr lieforo the grind Jury, that II waa .Imply a matter of Ju.ili-o and right that 1 ahould tell all lliatliadhtllml. (loutt then took a rtcrra until S o'clock. ML. i'rlndla anawered all the qtlea. tlone put by tliedurainlaut'a nauneel clearly ami Willi ut Imitation, and never onco lllnclioil unler the nciaa-lonalty nciaa-lonalty auttrii tire uf croaa-vxamlnallon by AttorLey Uawllna, AMiLUMkJN Brfiaio.v, Uon llierenunibtlijuof the Intjulry tbla aflernoon Annie l'rlhdle vtui again placed tiuiJer croaa examination by Alloruey Uawllna. Ilcfore thla at prwevdetl with, tiuwevor, and auu. mtnt entued t-ttareou cuuntcl on elllter aldo aa to tho edmUaaulllly tf crttaln cv! tonne lu ruird to the wltneaa lepillatloil, oil Ibu point raited by Mr. Ilrtwlina. and overruled by lliecomnilatlouer thiimornlngt It waituw argued nn nrringument be twien couiieel anil waa In ptoxreta when the Xkw'ii went to Itai. |