| OCR Text |
Show AFTER GAMBLING HOUSES. The Grasd Joty Seek loslractlons From kin hit. inhinc. mxiihuit io imiict. ltelaltrra of lliimir Million! a I Irrntp Ma; !. k (I il.-llou.ri or lll.r.ne, tie. A t.rtrf account uf tlio grant Jury'a Irjlrrtlnw tllll Chirr J ml lie aim Jtilerday afternoon, In the riilrj Die tllct culitt, waa given In Hut day'. ISywt. When our ri ott cloeaal tho t-tuifereiira Utactn Julga and Jury atlll lnruKr Jltlowwlll to founiiavetliillm account of the. ro-ctedlllKS ro-ctedlllKS which will doubtliia La rrJ with gnxtt lulerett: Uentlemen nf tlio grand Jury, I mi-tlcraluod mi-tlcraluod thla morning from tho Hate, nieutct tho fori man that joii wliheil for a further cliaritu vr 111 t rrct to the, law i.ri-eclll lm and ilcflulriK jour tlutle., and alao with rreriect to the diameter of r-tllcti autliorlieil In aiardflccaata, and Hieili-mie of rouf. lniirittr that tlm mutt may lu In formed aa 1 1 tli. UMIcultlci which )ou !t Iiavr, 1 will ak you Mlrwijllotia I uiitlerelan I that then le aonin illflliiil. ty In III mllida of eomn uf ou at leait, i ril iutt.ua to your duly with ruct tulullrllngfor i;auiliiK. l)u 1 under eland vim ill; froremaii lieelne I will itati, your honor liireirardtothal, at ti the na tun-of lliu ejtldeu that will I. roi,. atdtreJ nialetlal In a court, which no kii aupi vnl to lnvi. in rder tu Indltt.' rh Court That la aa to Karulnit? Foreman llcYliu m, air, that la Dli.cf thfioliiK rh.Cuiil-Wr.il, la there, any Juror Ihaltielielia that a higher ileurru ut j roof ahould Im rniulrel In tin caae. of (.aintUliorcouduttlnie a rune, than In t uritlary or luuarl realilnit, or uii. lawful rohati tallun, or eilch crime aa thai? la thiii) any Juror tlal thiol, that; UlmtUoimi ety, Mr. Huatun; Juror llu.lon-No, fir, Idon'u The ( ourt on am aware, I enp. wr, that thete. aril orUlnauii-a of tlir. illy irolilMtliuiKanilinr, mid kerlnt-I kerlnt-I awdy houat, an I arllini; II Uor with, t ut a llrnuae, mil that In miiio ca.ee theipartlraliav.iieeii t until eJ under llnattordlnaiiree la there any luror that thlnka that lecaii.o Hie rlty liaa tlm .iwer to unlali for thiw ulfellaea, you niijiht not In Indict mid Inn. tlm jarllrt4iiil!hfd lii IhUnmrl Mr.Anmtl -Onripi, iietrhilhrr w hat to tali luarri .tltuiue; a WltllfM inillllN III, Htid I4trt KlTI H nameIt wi nl 1 tu liiareajr; havu wi to take, tvldeuee of that km I? riiv Couit-. oil lioulj lair liouebut legitimate.! el lewe. Mr. Alilii llrVrll, linratr Iho Court Hlmiljr heatetiy would not ! rotii'iteiit. Mr. Aiinott Well, that U one ouc Hon. ft e Cimrl Vou liavo n rliht. of ci urte, to luiiuir Into the clriutnitau-ivaanl clriutnitau-ivaanl Uketutoiotialderatluu theilr runivtanct-a latheruau) luaiiuuthe Jury tint vault lea for tii'inii,or tiaa 1 eeu a (.anil ler fur motie7 (No re ronr ) 1 -l!liit Hut thereare noln, from the fact that yt ti do not anawer. la there any Juror that Mill not ludlct for iiauil lllnif .NorrDli ) Mr. I Ira J ley-In thla coiinrclluu, may It lrie jour honor, tliouicli 1 uui not h itanitler, nut never havo Kaintled, l ttill k one troutle uuuld lie, Ufolutheurand Jul) -II u firlllii la that If them la not uvidvuco auttl iltnttoullfyitmiii na n ttlt Juror tocouvlittue. artlea on trial, there la k field x III the irratid Jury that Him aaniekln I of i l lence, mil the aunu nuiuler, lantulred toiudutaa wuull hu ltiUlred tu ronfhli an I while I don't II Ink io, I think there rroul 1 1 4rlm 4 a couailentloua fivlluir on Hie iailtfeonie that they would U will. IliK tu llldht only utKlll the miiiu evldiuce that they noull ubvUt I think that lnt la one lliit. rhet'jurt Well, In the lrliltfore a ftlt Jur the evldenco mukt t auttlrletit to convince JOII lejond n reuonaole doul t. If Hie evidence lie. fire the Eraiidjur) laruftlclent ti In illicelnyoll n hellef that the difendaut, nrttie train wliow ivnJuct you mi lliveathlatlnl, la kullly, mid that he would rot Ally te convicted, that It aufllctent Mr. llralley I null Imiulre fiirlher, nmy It Un-e jour Imiur, win ther In Hie trial, or Hie reeenta tlonof i lane tor lu liitnieut Mtnlitit a I f'amllliu liltltiitluu one that the uvl li in e la i lear eunuch, la a t oniinon In.tltiillou for Ktitiililliiir It not Ih Ini; very oMltlely Htlhd that lerUlu Hirileaaro theonta who run that ea tatllahmnit whiihir that e.ul ll.h. ment colli 1 tie 111 Hi le I 111 the natilu of ruth alt Ire wlioiuueiult.ht take from thi reluitunt wltiu.aliin rather looae nnddWilntidorJlir 1 frrl Hlu. there woullUiafiilliiKoii the I art of the Jurora lu that now Hut the vllrluv lielngai reluihinlly drawn from llio.e that are Iroukht h(ri,litlniariuU.ceil In ly the iiit Ha aintluiiiil, Ulnu, In luct, ulii)J to a lertaln ixlenl hj ill liomitliliint, the ttotlll frel nil. der the clrcuuiataiiiia that liny were not liiind to no iiiialmt nl,lia enthneiit,and aitaliiittoiiiiiion uiaee, you may my, and a deling of that kllid, aalhey would lie In reUtlou to the linn that I aa Urn convhled. or Urn I n uhl up to u tried iion a i rime that ul lln aelilhuent a well aa their nun. an I the law la aualiut I think that there wi uld he a feeling- on the ntt of many Hint llmt noull ho a iwefortlieilljr Huthorltlea, and not forua tu Interfere. riiet'ourl lalhire any Juror that vroull bHifinerned tu any extent ly laibllo 0 luloii, or iul llo aentlnient, lu a.nor i row uit Ion for Kamblluir, for ili.taim; N i reui ae ) Mr. DovIiil Vourliinor, lieliiir that theiue.Umi I aa Ikii ral.Hl In revirl to evldinie and In or, ay evident! 1 liavelctiiwiltlnitlir aomoot the !u. rora who haven little loniclunlliii i tuple In that .irtli ular 1 1 nate tin Ir laialtlo , htltaeelmtlmltheyhaeiiit, 1 Moulldenlri to aay that aomoof the J iron, on uctounl of dui toattmony that liaa Wen Mlered, which I lilluht ileitrlhe In the foltowlmr uayt A cer. lalnwitniM la iieillounl ut to who i wiiauriuiia a certain etalill.hnutit liol.ll. vinMr Jon. .dm "Do you know hedoe.?" Hn, 1 don t know lie dm a, I ut he la the r lllrd ro, rletr r uf thla lata! Ilnhiui lit " Nun, It hna lietu ery illlllcult for the Jury, an I In Hint lartkutar thilr diiilta have In en overlom, to aHLeilaln any ioaltle knoMleilite, wture a mUiiimi mIIIvoI unarll) lemlfy jr ir in lie will ( ri euini , or ii ioc, i r allri(e, that the rep.ilt I trorlrtor UHnatidm ow, J tohatlj uu that iiurtlcular line of evl i ilelico iiiort, Irian , othir doc till Jurydnlieiuitructiou i'i ?.''.' '"' ''"'"'Iteof the lailld-ng, lailld-ng, or of the riwni, an 1 na to hat ad-'l'"laail ad-'l'"laail ih. buihraa, an I aali anylhlint lie hliiueii IimiuI I about It and any clroini.lance that leuda to how who It la that I, conluctlnf the anil, or hav the .e..lon an I con. IrolnfiheKame. ortheroom.t)fcouri awltneia coull not U urmlltel to come In an I give It aa Ida oi Inlnii that jonierme warorltor without itlr Ine the clrniratlaiicia He ahoull Itlvelheclrciiiii.tano-i uiwn whkh he ik hi. oilnlon an I notiilvehla 0 Inlou alut It ou have a rljhl lo uuulre who lean the room ou have right lo Inn, lire Inti any clr-cuniitanciM, clr-cuniitanciM, an I Imm that you hare a riRhtiolnhr who coulurl. the bu.l Ua And If you diuu It auniclelit, m ho, that la nil that la tiiiulled oil hareriorlht to take mere oilnloii'. aimillt,n ti who lt c n luctlnjt the btiMtitM. ou have a rljht lo call upon any wlineea who liu lnu In then, In any KimUInx li'me aa ti whom he aaw la) lug, aa 1 1 n how hi kaw lakliiK art In any name, anJ he la not irlvllenel UIMII the (t"""1' . H'l It miy crlmlliMe hlniielf,Ucauie the atatule rovl (e. that that la not a gt uu I of ol Jecllon He cannot l lndlrtl, hueever, and I lofciutid, upon any ivldeiice that he Rlvea in the olleua,. Ale there any ether utlolia you wMi tu a-k In-itructlotiaon In-itructlotiaon Mr. (IJcll-lf tdo am atory, Mr. ane la Rlten by two or more w. The Court (Internii tins ) That I. not a pmir way to tut. In court mi niu.l allium the court That la a matter of contemjt. Mr. I) lcll-1 ant n t familiar with It. The Court An liitillltent man on the grand Jury omthl to know lie Her than tu iiek that way. Mr. (Hell-May I auto IhoipicatlonT 1 lie Court Vou liny atatn the iiuia tlon now. Mr.OJell-tf the evIJeme of two irtujle wltii teiida tl the Mine faila, would tint be ronaldrre.1 ajf. flclent he Cuutt Well that would depoll I upon the nature of the evl leiici. Mr. I UUI-Well, Kite the aame liaiuea, the ame (nrtlea, the aimo li nllty, the actio! a the Mine, the evidence evi-dence referring to date lluee blether. Hie Couit Two Wltuerac. would lie auniilent tiany rur fact, or one wltiima, ilalaraa that l concerneil. If lie wai in t cotilradUle.1. If lime wai any rontrjJIcllou why then )ou wi uld have a right t) weigh the evidence evi-dence an I determine whom lo believe. ( the ( ourt then real Irom the com I Wed lawa the aecllona nferrlng tu trundling ) Thla l the law In re-peii 1 1 p-ambl lug a i fir na 1 dreulltliicetwirytiread li. mil I would iy with naiect In that uirento that the grin I Jury ahiuld triwt It the .Tin. aaany other olTVn , and ahuuld llidht llin the aame de. grrenf f roof, au I the party ahoul I be convluled iikii the aame degree of I roof. If tin. riruf U autllrluil lulu. dine a belief that the ram lrm conduit you nre lii viKtlgtllngligullty, au I the rot al lllllea are that he will be founded If Hie Clan la fairly reeelited au I tried, whe uu ah uld tu llrt. Vou , have no right to tnkeintocutnl leratlon the fait that there may he gambling , nirrlidon In vailom Him. mi have i no right to take Into uimddrmtl m the , fact that you have gambled. If any of you have, for money, Voti have uu right tu laku llit, (uualdera. Hon the fact that the city hu authority to unUh for Kambllug. uu have nu light to take Into coualdera Hon any thli g that la not roper evl lence, am your only motive ahoul 1 te the truth Heroine laaa ulat ngalnit gimlillng mi I the kce lug uf liawdy houae. ai d other olltnaia, au I It may be lmiioa.ll le to relent gniui ling mi I ki e I ng of I a wdy Iioum a allogitlar, that lauo reaagti why you eh Hill not Indict If the rvllcucnW aufllclent, nor la lt any reason why you ahoul I In Met If the cvldi nee la not turtklrut.' There have Uell laMa agaluat murder, nndlirt-eiiy, an I rob Ury, and vailoua other crlmea for IhouMiule ff viara aut allll Ililae irlllieaeaUt. lour unai.e ahoul 1 be to l rotect anilely from the i vll elteita orihtae criiuee, ly lujiiting whtre the tvlieni.i la aulllilelit. ri.) Willi gimliu or any other otleuie of that chaiadtr, It la your duty lu Indict though you in iv Ihlnk that It miy not ireient gaud line altogether. If bo. lauMlldoea not atop gambling altu gulheryoiiehouU not Indict, then all tlieirlnilnal lawa ahoul 1 lie itjualetl. Iheotje I lain J talent crime, lo ro-tict ro-tict auclrty front the evil ellettaof gamlllnt: IIicmi lana li to which men aieluvilghd, and Indui-erl tu go, and de rived of their prorty under clnuiiiitiiiieaiiflhat klu I, are aa la I (not unite ao I ad in tlm ritlmatloii of tleublll)aiatekllng, butlu Hie iye of aiiliourntmaii,Juit na lad, Juit aa linuioral, an 1 Juat aa wronif. 1 make there remarka Incline! hear liitlnialluuainital le that eorue men nn thla grand Jury have elate I outil le that they m mil J nut Indht tinier any clr cunibtanieaamalitjri.aml ling UiaiLe they I ad glint led thtuiftehea and ill I lii t lielleio lu Indkliiig ml era 1 do not kn iw how true It la, but If Hiiro li any man of that charatter on thlt grand Jury I Mould like to know II. our oath la plain, au I II l aa folio . Ileal. The court ala real eictlon II tomrlle I I.aM a i f Utah 1 Ho that your duty la plain. our only mollve ahoul 1 he to a.ctrtatn the trulh aiiord. lu to Um, aul whenever you fouiil aiilllclent evidence to Indict n man, InJht lilm, no matter win he I., mi matter thoiigli the hw may lealaw that yiiiilotiitlmllevolli, Inllcl. Vou haieiinillicritlou about It A grant J iry, like a court luillzjtlng fail, when lleivlleucela rulllrleuk there la nodl.crotlou If liny Wlleie from Iheevllenre that the fait lllilt, they lialouodlairetlon toaaythat It do. not It li true that a court aud Jury might ay to, but In aaylng It I lie wuull trjiiretlienitlve Mr. lira Ih) One oilier iUeitlou, your honor, la thli Whether In In. 'I ilrluic lnti theowueratif tluaehouiiea luutare routed for unlawful uriif, it la nereaiary ft r the.e Jur ire to know, where tin re are co dm una and there la evllelice of one of Hvae coownira agreeing to rent thatfir a ctrtaln aum wlitlhtr It la leceaairyfirthla Jury to kiMWthat all the c Miwnira have et.red with him li rent that Ihi, Mheiher In n.titaliiliig who la rt-ipon.lule rt-ipon.lule for thla, and lln ro la evldi lice to how that one of the coom nt ra, with thetouainlapiarintlyi aa far aa the evl lence got a, of the real M hether he tan la- In lined without In llctlng all the oonwnera that that tvldence re latoeto? And anotherlhlng I Mould like fur my uwn Information-! don't kluw whether I apeak for therlhir Jurora tu kuuw when Hie liwa of the lirrlluryoro violated, with tin knowl. tnlae and ooiiaet;t a ir idly of the Imllle firce the exmullle f rce of thla city whether with tint before ui lu Iheivilen j r II irli nece .ary U B ) to the auljr mat. iilllciraof that exr utivo fortt r to the aupiri r i 111 ci ri, where there are violation! i f law with the conmvani e au I ronaent o the ltlnriniirof the law lu the city or the county aa the caw may lie whom ahull m ,Cn wimt mn we reach? rho Court Well, 1 turn.lo the law onthoauljeit. (The court here real from the ait of CongrcM of Juno .H I'll, alio from torn, lied l.aw 01 Ulan ) It la male the duty, y on will ,, ij thla aectl in, not only of otlieroftlceip, tut h lice mlliera, tu inform agalnat aiiJdlllgintlyrKieculerKna whom they I aveliaaonable caiiM to Ullove are oirenJcn agaluit Hie i rovlaluna of Ihlaait irihillting gaming Now, If any .ilicei nicer r other nillcer, no diilereuce who he I. hai any reaaon atleciutito belli ve that ai y erajn liaa commute I an cfl.me agalnat Ihla Itw rolilbllliig gaming, nut lie doea hot diligently lliillre lull II, lie la guilty id a vldatloii of the law. a nl la guilty ol a inlideiueanor. If any lullcemail goif luio a hanibllii; hniiae anlieiaiiiengaiuliilng Ihrre, and he d .en not hive It Invcetlgaled ami I roaecule theiu, or do II i btalhecau townrd Hut end. ho la kullt) if a mla dimeauoi,lii la n criminal, mil lie ought tol Uilihei more aevtrely, really, than Mine men who may lai Inveigled Into the gambling hollo and conimelicelo gamble. Public cfflicra who knowlugly vlolato the I tw ah ml 1 Iw rigidly dealt m Itli and uulilinl, no dltrercnce who they are. Mr Urn Hi y Subordinate aa well aa turlor oIllcer, Tlio Court- llof them, aulnrdluatt, and eui-rrlnr. A tuirlor olllctr haa n i right to lira ne tuWdlnatea to com. mil crime Ate tlieto any rurllirr In. airurlloiiayoii Ml.li on thla nutter; (Nn ea4 llae ) There waa a fiucitloli naked thla morning wllli reept 1 1 tu the evllcote rclatl Ktoforgtty, Mr. Devlni-I would like to make one further rimaik on llil, your honor. I doii'ikmw that you exaitly un h rtliHnl me when I tUUd my tuai. Hon on It Ufole, ir thellloiiof tome of the Jurura, rather, Ihatle, aa to therorlriorof a nrtaln lace. A Mlluwa will teatlfy that he li llovee tu, when any rain llitt nlng to thai Mltnwa kliowalhat he knowa ti, I r trial he lln it ritanda that Mr. H" and rio la the rurlilor, heknowa him lobe Hie re tailed roj rlebir. Nom, whether that la mati rial i vldinit, without that wit neei laialllvel; liilllylng Hint he kll malt tide the (at Aa one wit net. who ii e h 1 1 W ire ui ttated that hedllu't kiuw aiiylhlng-he dl lu't knoM anything exce t aa he taw II, he didn't kiuw that Mr. Auerhaeli ktt thla t ire of Auerbacu lirothert, and tlmllari-ateaoftheklnl. OfcoiirteHe don't know thoi thlngt, any ol ut. N ,ii, aa to the reaitrd A I rlelor of a Uce.ll that ulldence tulllilelit to mif vlct atertalit mtii aa the proprhtor of a ctrtaln i lace la the point that I moiiII le. (leiueil to have the Jury thoroughly iitidirttahd The Co Itt TI... ipicatloil la na lo w he her you have n right toretelve eildtnce of geniral rtUtatlou aa tu whM keel Ihelir u.i? Mr. Devlne Via, ilr. The Court ho con lucli Hie I utl. neei. a 1 elated before, while geli- ral ri iUtatlon la comitelit evldmte whete u rton la Indltletl for kct lug a hoote of 111 fame, or keeling a ilia orderly home, unler thla tUtute Hi It frrnice lo kambllug I do not tu lai.e gi niral repuiatl u would 1 comiti nt evIJiuce ou haie a rli,ht, ai I ttalnl lafort, to elicit from the Mllneaa the facia fr uu whlrh he Infera Hint the man ion lucta the gamb lug home, not to allow him lodraw luferencca, lot you ahoul I luiilro of him aa lathe facta, why he thlnka tu, and If the laitlllpuu which ho lateallll oluloli la toiuiHuut ivldeiice tu gu liefirr you, why Hun you have a right to firm j our o In! in upon It. Vou have a right to aciutlnlie tlio evidence, f wltiiHte can fully, an I to crotaxam. Ine tlitm, and reexamine, II you Ihlnk they are unwilling wllnenea, au I are l II leal otlng lo c lnt al and eva le what they do know. Itlayujr duty t ex. auilnetlieiniarrfully. With re.ctbitlie evldiuce aa to forgery, I uiideiatand that Hu dlilUully y on haJ waa aa lo whether the ttttf. monynlexarta could lairicilvcd Mr. Devlne-That waa thoiiuietlotl. The Court-! f you havu Iho haul, writing of a man whoau tonduct you aicluvettlgatlug lieloreyou, which he almlla to be h(a handwriting, you Moulllniearlghtlhento tall In an exartanllethlniiMiniaire thai with the handwriting lu dliito and ix. ireahlaoplnloi,liut you woulj mt hivearlghtniirilytoluiiatlL.ato ami iruve hit handwriting from uthir I ir lliau the one yuu have undir coiulliratloii, merely for the t uf liote of lotting au ixit lu.ll. tule a ( omi arlaon, to ex n ta Ida i r In. Ion aa to whither II la Ihn tame or ill Ih rent. I hi geueial rule tifovldi nee la, In a court, that whin tin re l a paiicralrcalylu evl lence, wrlllen ly therly whoae han iMrllliig la IndlJ. lte, or If there laa I a vr that he con-ccliaandaliiillato con-ccliaandaliiillato bo lilt liaiidnrlt Inc. Ihinaiiixrtmay comparu that with the hau Iwrlllng IndlFiuteiind e ri ta hit n Inlou about It. rhat liaa u! " ,.'.'.1 ' !f lhl" l,,url '"' 'hi". I wlllinllyouratteiitluu to unither matter. It lireporlol that there la a thiamin thla town where llnuor li aol I lu the au murium, r In the build, lug, dying the lerfurmancc. riieliw mikialhat a ml lemiaiu r, an I It . your duty to Investigate aa l a ich dla. pnli rly iliceaaalhatMhirolhelaw la being Tlolitcd I wlllelalofutlliirlo the grand Jury that they will I e very careful not li talkMitli ivitonauuullt. Vou have nu right to 1,0 tu lauyera who may l cinloyil ly tarttiv, or lu the Intertat of (trlalu ila.ua of crlmlnala, aul talk with them ai lu Mh.tlllie law I., ltU, what your duty la, or with any la-rum. Vim have ii i right to laki tlionlvliiiof law brikeraorlhilrnllonicya ou the out tile Ifyiuwlihauy alvlte al any time, lake It from thedlilrlct attoney, or aik thecouil Mr. lira lley -I ill In t quite unler-ttau unler-ttau I your honor toamwir the nun. lion Mhl'h I atkrd, ni tu where the ovldnie ahoHinl that one of thoro-ovntraofa thoro-ovntraofa lull ling, tmlM foriiu. lawful uriotee tl eevllrme thoaed tint he waa reilly anltiruly an low. mr that Ihcre woa a uumbtrcf c nwneri alio were not ehuMli tu l owiitri, hutalmlltt I to be whtlhor miii ullliidkt him alone ui on that evl lenci? . IheCourt-ir he wit the nwiur of the ImlMlig, or the oMiier uf uu In iret In II, aul If ha reutihla Intereat for the urjw.e of i on luctlng any bin Initalhat laiinliMful, hueoiill bo In dlrto.lt nr If II ( y all i oust ut to II, thty Will I le lllJIcled, rue gran I Jury had no furthiriui tloua tu put aud roll red tu their room, |
