| OCR Text |
Show SUPREHEci)URT. Th. Fanklln kum Tbeitre License Comes Up. ir IS U.'lL'l.ll tIN IIKHLT.IICK Tlic I'oniplalnl ami Itiurrr. Itbrncy llltk.an't Ujieuluj. All Iho Jujgat wore prraent at to day'tn-louoftheTerrllorlalriuprrpie Couil, After the dltrnstl of aeveraf inalltrt which occupied iicirly nn hour, tin, caae of Meatra. Terry t'o of thu Trnnkllu Arenua "Varlely" Thenlre, wat ctlle.1 on, being au npp1 . cation lo thla court hi grant an nil. iittlvuwrlt of m.ndamiit itiuipelllng lliu Council of Htlt I.aVo City to thor eauaewhyalhvnaoahouIJiiot ho It aueJbylbeiubillionppllentltt to nil Inloalcathv HiHora to palrout of their theatre. Ju Ige l'owera Mid Attorney Dick aiiiatlcnd.it lo repn-eut Terry A, (!o. Colonel Merrill nnd United Htatca DUtrlct Attorney Varlan ap-icared on iiehalf of tho clly aulhoilih-., nwocl atvd wlllitliemboliig Attlitaut County Attorney Klchnor. Tho etatomaiit of tho applicant act forth that on the Clh of January, ISOI, Ihotald I. J. Terry mvlo application by lK-lltlon to the Clly Council for n llcenne at n rvtall dwiler to tall or other whedl.iotoof rplrlttiout. vlncut, malt or other Intoilmtlng llimr. within Kilt l.nk. Clly, which K.tltlon writ algned ami flltd hy the Iterordrr. HaldfluioiitatoJiloflnlttly Urn ir tlcular ilace nt whlili aald llu'uri were m bo eol I, and that the iinie wen. to liedialt nut at Mail; that raid J.ri't ."" '! aald lalltlou a laii.il to Halt LakeCity which waieon illllonal.m follow : 'Ihat during th. contliitunio of thu Itrm for whin aald llrenao ahould lm grthted ho would keep an orderly nud wtll-ugultteil hoim; that ho would tut allow gauii ling with raid, iihv, cr auy ntli.r device, or Implement, uted lu gambling, wllhln hit 1i-uh, outliouio )ard or uther pn.wlci unjer hit urn. Irol where ajcli butlnew wat lo bo ion iluetiu; and tint he would pay nil dtmngm, Ilnra and firftlluriw uhhti might Iki auju Igol ogalii.t lilui under nuyor tlioiruvltlnniuf nu art of Ihu goviruor and lrqltlalho amtmbly of Hi" Territory of Olih. Tiat nu tliu nth January the aald 1.. J-lVrry.ia.il Into Ihe iny i-.WUry of Halt Lake Clly the turn if IRMIor Ihe llrvutt- latlllontil f jr: thuUhi r the llllugor llh! Itdltlotl, Iwud an-1 Ju.tl-lltatlon, Ju.tl-lltatlon, ho cauaed turh U,ul and k,. Iltkm to Iw pnwenleil to tho City Council Coun-cil at lit regular uniting, ritiuratlug themtogratitlhupra)erolFaldtttiioi, hut Hi it l.dy thou and tin to turned in do m. Tint at the Hate of prctent Ingrald ietltlon ho rioueatcd tlio t'lty Council, In thu event uf a rituailto gran: tho llcenae, to lliform hlru of the ground IhrrtiifJ but thla had Iweti re-luted re-luted nnd a Miia.1l waa alll, given. Ati.tiilcg Ihe nllernatlvu writ of uiattdaturtherulotuttttdlrtcludatoiitio tlorvtidant, to thotr ciuito why tlm llreiiioprajcd for by plalntKraliould nit be graided the facta rvla-llva rvla-llva to the ap 11 Mlton made In November, ISO i, ti ibatlra r. itey. iiohia A- Co., for Iho thealn- lleeine.uro fully revlewn.1 Among olhtr thliu It waa etplitoly Ulnul.lln I Ihat too tale of Intoxlcatlug lrr area wuull tilitmeilktirlout oKtoliou thu.lo. -Mi aunrancn waa glten, however, Hint lucli I ipnra would not bn totalled to-talled iiiii Hi., theatre premlM; tut pUliitlll fllletl up mid ttockc.1 one of Iho ro una In Iho bawtnentnt a place for carrying on Iho retail liijuor biui-tiitt. biui-tiitt. Applhatloii for n lln mo wat made by hlnl to ilefeiidanl ou Dec. IKI, lilii, wlilch waa then rtfuxil, Tho anttver next acta fotth Iho rca tout for audi refutal, among nthtrt Unit tho north, ta.t nnd anulh aldiaof tho block on whhh tlili llnttre it looilitl nro aliuoat viclualte. ly ootupled hy (tlvalo far.illlia: that thu Thlrlienll. llt.l.l.. Hchool of Iho clly It held and conducted conduct-ed In tint tchool building ou Hecoud H mth Htreet, neatly op-clio the owning lo Tranklln Arrnuu lulo aald unit, and lait a thott dlitanco from the tliwitu; lljtt lmmtillttelyt.ppoi.llu thonH.iiluglo rrankllu Aveiiuo and liiljnlnllig aald Khool lulldlug, oil Hetvnd Houlli Klroel, lia placti tf re lh-loua wonhlp of mtmliera of Iho I'hurchcf Jitu. Clulat of Latter-day Halnta; and Ihat about half a block further ta.t, on the corntr of Hcrond Kaitritroot, It thu h'lrtt Tretbjltrlan Chunh. Htld thratre(theantwer gcte on lu tilltil) It ihuniuluntid n "Varlil)"' Ihialre. DllUreut pla) uud vahlbl-llona vahlbl-llona are glvt u there, Among olhert I'rlio llghta or toiitrnlloni are nr uilllnl, mil, at ilefinJant It lu. forunal nnd ladlovia, Ihe ilmriet.r of Ihu it-rfornianco nightly glten la inch- although u t Inmoral or In uiceul na lo attnul audlmita com. taii almoat entirely of tucn, to Ihu txiliialotinfladlea nud ihlldreu; and that the tale of Intoxicating liouon any win ro on the piimlaea during, hu. foie, orun.rthe iftforiiiauriti would reaull at thma In illtorvh r, or worau. iherifore dtfendant nlhgea that "ihn plate Hutiil lu nlaliillll'a apldlratlona was and la, iiiilll fur the tending of Into (rating ll.tuora ot any kind." The defendant It advised lyivuuxl, andliellovtMhattho Klllngol tplrlt uoutliuorato any of Ihu natron, nf mo iniairu irom tlio puce III the liatu. would bo In violation of law, ami particularly of ttrllotl WH of tho (Ainipihtl l.autof Ulah, lbt9, tol. a, pp. .Irt. Kor Ihat rtnanii ih fi ndant la not authorlml to grant llalntlll a llcenae. That the hwa of the Territory pro. hlblt nny ting or tire light: yit, at defeniaiit wat Inforuiwl, thu raid Charht T, llejnoldt A Co.. (owiicn or leattit of the etillri' prom i a) did ou tho nlghl of Wulnaa diy, January I Itli, IDOl, urmlt aprlie light la tw ceil oue (leorge l,u lllauche kiimvii na "Iho Marine," nud Jim NVIIIIama, dtalgualed the "Chamiliin of Uuli,toUkuiuni ot II oMock: that a "ring" waa tltilicd, a ref. i reo and riitniJa wtru choam: that "llioconteatlotledfortla niund,"nud wat for a rto lu money, IMendaiit nert upon lit Informa ll.iu and belief that ralilbltlona ur the above llml noull lu Ihufuiuro bu ier milted In raid theatre, mid llitniore tu'imllt that till li n rcawn why li ahould not now grant the liteme pra)td for. TliutliinlltlieitimlMj. thu ,r,., anl, luthetairelaeoflltilluretlotior) liver, acted fairly aud for tho Utl Mr iiri.i i.iij i , niaawaai. .a,, il Intcritti, and to rrG9ta the hioralt, Iwacu, good ttnhr and hnpliiet of Iho to leof tho illy, and eafclally of the lartliuhr utlghliorhood lu which tho Franklin Avenue Tliettru la carrlnl ou. Hence defendant ir.i)a that the prt-Ytit iipbllcatloit to tho Comt Iti dlmltcd w 1th ttuta When the rate wat called ou Attorney Dlcl-on lntluiat.il that he wnt prtiaieti lo nrguo the tax. on dtmuirir, and nfltr Ihn rtadlng nf the defendont'a nmwir at length by Utillod HUttea Dlattlct Attorney nrlan It wat ilrclJ.il to let the matter Hun, I our until tn u other thort casta had It. ii dlrpottd of, lu crdet to a'lonl Ml. Ilkkaoi.atiopputuult) to lllo hit demtirrtr. tjtm thu caao coining up again about II. SO It wat found .jull.- 1ihk-iltle 1ihk-iltle to procted owing to the con tinned noire occatlourd by ihu ateam In thu ple of the nj jtiratnt ii.ttl for dialing the notitt room, nud after aome talk nfannl-Joiimmeni nfannl-Joiimmeni It wat lluall) eJnehlnl that the titling thoutd t e held In Chltiub era Thcnco Ihejiidgitaul ntlnrni')! lirot-rtilnt. lacui ) lug a room adjoining the r.rillorhil Library. Iti the citirae of hit opening argument argu-ment Attorney Dickioii eald 11 wua roiitiudcd that Ihu Clly Council had Iho lower, lu Ita dluretlou, to grant ur rtfure thla llcoliae. I llllt janvir wat now dlapulid, and thu pur lateaoilght wat to have Ihe adlltdi-teimlinil adlltdi-teimlinil by ihu Sui nmu Court. Hit illenttri rind tutul ihuralldliyof thu MitwiroflticdifiuiUula by dimurnr. Thero waa a gooil dial coiilalutd In It which, on tho alt nf hit dlctil, hu old not admit, and n great deal that waa Irrelevant. A gtral many thluc;. charged to lu Itn, wiremutterainir which the op- .ii.-iii, nan no romroi nun iiiwuitll liu took nu art. ItiloiilJbeailmlttid, lm tindertt'ivil, fjr tho -iire of urgu mt lit, that the aalu of llipiorihargul aaliitt i! o applicant waaiuailu undtr a uil.ij n-'.i.n.lon, he billeting that Ihe lln uae had Ik-oii vottil liy Ihvt lly Council. Mr. Terry wat not lufotiuiil lnihninlrtry, linlnil, until liliiilr. at, wlitii ll.u funhir iaio waa at on atopitil. Mr. Tttry had not Ihe haul dialti- to allow lilttuuUniftforlholaw b) a. II-lug II-lug ll.iiur wahoutn llreiue, Noihhij wat rhargnl nealnit hit chinirter. CVuii.it Intlitiii that tho JegWatiirn never Inleii ll to tiinfi r audi nbwhilu itiwtr Umii n Clly Cumuli aa ha I hotn exhlblUil lu thla li,.iance. Tluto wtru r-cvin tnlia given at the Council nu cling Itforu wlilcli-MrT.riiTtiapilluiautt,foru llciliiectnic, In iti favor,' ami MVen a altirt, uud nn thla tie Ihu major gate liltcaitliig Mile agaln.l Ihe -tdlilou. No tiuAoiia wero naalgtml for the re-fiinal re-fiinal to grant the lltciitu, allliough ri quirted. Mr. Diction proet-eiliil to quoin from a largu iiimilir til legal outhoilllea leatlng on Ihe mac. ant nat aim ajautlng w litu Iho Ni.w 8 uport cloted. |
