OCR Text |
Show I 'Ml? THE MANDAMUS DENIED. I fH fi Compelling The City Council (o Issue I -I k fl tt w J rin,lT AM' t0MmT H J? I i Cllef Juttlce 7ii. &9i h HjjUfeW M Laat ev.nlrig" Issue of llie sS's.Wa- lmrl 't contained a vutj)s.l of llie decision of HU I lueHupremeC'ourt of llie Territory on M$,H I I writ of mandamua coiiiliclllriic the aHW1! ' it City Council to Issue aliquot llci-use to B' fc i UJ.rerrrAConipaur, delivered by J ) Clilrr Justice Zano yesterday after. I1JP noon. Tlie onlulon la given Wiotr In r ' run., kTB ,J."l'i ' - 1:- ' Irry, tlaloUIT, v. Halt I-eke mXti'l" City, defendant: R 4i I Zaue.C.J. Tiilalsana..llaitlonly 1 is I' the lalntlfTfor it remitory writ uf Ll J t W inaudaniua to comitl the Council U$ J- m ' H" J'" c"r Kut Mm ii- IHmjw'.H 1 c.nae to retail inloilcallriir liquor. In B J" mi rcrlllnl nlltlon li how it com- IStY ff Illtncoln allrrrctJ vrllli thooiprrna Bj.,' m 1 rrqulrtnunbiof ths itatutM nmf the HHRibM.i' oiuliuwoMi In nulling bU npnllutlon AHKLirKU for til. Iln-nne. fKfK- ,B! To the tltornttlr writ the lUlrmU !; jLiiH lint ratkMltiirrlurti, VKirl.it by Ooo. KW ( Jl1- Koott, lie ruyor, nJ .IkdihI by HlwfflnRf Kmuel A. Merrill, 1U attorney nJ tr,9jv& 4 s 1 Charlee B. Vsrlftu, KMocUte rountel. KnStlij Un the return the dofenilant tUtenth HJmjVBiJm f'illowlDjtfcUnJ relluUion themu HEI1 .rl uftlcltnt reaeon tot not KrantlnK the H Jt'n lloetUKi: That the city hail luur.1 I iVrW thvatre llreiiM to Cuarlre P. Iley. K'1 i Jm J J noldi A Co. with the cxiirefti untler HPV VjH'l tnJlog that no IntoilcatluK rHLV Jru'VI liquor. ahouM lie reUllnl In HalBG the LulUlng, and that the iilalntlir HHHjIt u li bellevrd In oolluilon with that n 'Wn company In endeavoring to obtain the A vKk n HceuM to aell llnuora In a room In Ita KaffiM ' 1 bawment; that the bullillnir laeltuatetl hSm, vwt "J on Franklin Avenue, a narrow ttrtel; HSftHI'' J& that Ihl.eUnt and tlie block throuicli 3NiftK'v 'r which It extendi, It occupied almoal rHfipMBVy Y exclu.lvely by rreldencee; that atoul B 3Bp ' S twenty rodi mm the theatre are a tilr- rB9f JsL ri lloecbool and a Iioum for rollitlou. Ufn i V 1 wonhlp, and fifteen or twenty rod. pHtf-.i M. 11 Irom themlranothirchurrhithttlhere H j;W I l!J lono aaloon In tho avenue oppoilte Hr.! tiC MiT U" ",0lr" believed to he BfeXBy! Kii bUricitxT to ooi-i'LY AM. niuaus. PHK. I'ffiffittfBil AI1LC UEMAA1M Bl MJlHBfcriS'V- w. .. , , Ht "tXQC'u'i areoVthe variety claw and are atteud' HRt BoB'T'i "' alniont eii.lulvcly by nulei: tliat HmVr ''iSBBJ lil the plaintiff, without llcenM and von. HErabSs Iffi trary to law, told liquor In the room BJHmB y 19 ) Iwn nlitliU after llie rlrtt ref ua.1 to HRvi rUf K J iMueth llceriM ami that on the nlnht HHu( JSf?''') f th. Mm lint, a rlDg1 nht waa lor- HuoT WMbA I inlltudluthetlieatni. GH WV' v Iuooncluilon the derendant cJalrna ll flMW ' thatlt acted within IU illacnllon In ?' 'fVKelF refuiliiKtorirantthB llceiiM and that Hivi V" ' lheeulepurMieoriUnieuitieriltidoliiK (' ?i,. Q ao waa admire to irw r publla order HiB ?'ll O rT and Uie morale and happlnu or tho Sl-J' (J iff peopio of the neighborhood. HiKf'' '' ' viewer the foreRolnir facta, otiuhl HW'S the court Is grant the vreiuptory man- ait' ilatet HllaEjt'' .' i'ti- : A If tho refuul to rtrant the llcenw HUD 'lilfc :. wm not within Uie deerrellon of the Wf' ?, J cvuuillthewtllrhouldlieue; but ir II HHU 'V H waa, then It ought not. G ,- The lower of the city Council with R ,-, I ricttotlietulJeit I. found In vol- ,'t P'. umel Compiled Uxa of UUh.lHbH. I . l i Bevtlin 17UU a. follow.: "1 he illy HI '1m i Council aliall have the followlnx lw HI P' 1 ii' tn: 4Jllt toliceiiM, regalite audux I '" f tb iimuufaiturlui;, arlllns, Klvluif HI v; I awayur dUmluir uf In any uuuuer I ; I t, auy lutoxliailus liquor.." riie aectlou ' . I A aUuproTldee that the term of the IU. m ' II eriMhallnotextendlyoiidllierauiil Hl lA i i clll ymr In which It I. ImuoI. and It kW' M liauljecttntherratrlrtloni of thoeelf r'J&v 11 tralUw.of the rcrrltoiy, aud a land HIVKE7V I . lit l required, and the aale to minor., uBf. 'JSm Idiot., Iialiltual drunkard, or kwiih Hlqfflr M "' Intoxicated, l prohllltnl. Knlloii U-iTttlW 44trl, volume?, .nine lumpllallon, for-I for-I 4 .' W''' bld.iheielllnirurfurnUhliiK of InloX' HI . W IcaUnnllquoratuany vrwulu llioau. j I illlortuniuriobbltenf any Ihiatre, etc. HJ , ll THK IMWKII T IICISBt, IIUIUXAIK I, ' theule or dUpo.ltlouorintoxlcillnir HI ' ,W llquore within In llmlU I. lumued hv Hi J '3 Halt Lake City except m far a. It Tt HJ VGf. fj,(tui,"a by the above iirovWona. HI '. ' tl fl' t-ouu'11 r Halt lle City under Hi . Cf llie power to llewiee, rrRuUteanit tax, I ifl J'M hy ordinance nulrd iwllllou . by the apidlutnl lo lirewiitvd lu I whl lithe placu of hu.lntM and aomo I 9 other minor facta are miulred lo be HI .,li 'tated, and alio u tuud In the aum of HJ it l,00U. wltli.urtttreaud provMoii. aa Hi B lroTlJed. Tho license LmmlriM to I B... be limited to thrie runutli. and for a H iy retail butlneea tH la charged, llie i It aile without llieun, and the mle to Hi It Indian., Iniaiieur Idlotln la rnuia or to l inlnoi., auJ the ule on riunday I. for. j, bidden ami punUhed, And It I. al 'iWt ' videi thut the mayor may, by i ro. Hi 111 Vamailon.fbrlldtlie.ileordUiaaliloii tl f of man llquurt on elKtlunUaj. aud H ill. " hollila) a. HI Rllir ' llieqUNilon now i-oima, liu the HI ' ilSkV Couuill any further dlKiitlou Mill. HI I 1 IrBf re.iect to Kruutlni tiirh licemw? 1 "i yiM under lla rt lo teguUlahai n auy HI I ulacreUoii a to the per,ou to whom ", H lleeiuc; thall In cranled, ua to tho tim l'vof bu.lieaa,or u to tho miuibor , I Km r Ihemratobeiiranted; H i t-Xm , rholu-maturoiouldluiveprohlbltcil l b traillo, but It did not do io. S J ,'';"', It dllnleetlioCllyCoun. l ollthuiowirtollciu.., rri:ulilrra," ft I ,,?,i" .."'? l"vir ' "inferred on n ' Ml . dellUrath.iajy. AnU lu ,, H ,! lthrv.ittothenitlictla notllmli. , .II fcl '" iu inlnUterbil dullee. qh0 MJ lower of llieliUUturonnuiilinlted H - trHI wltlirpei.ttotliolualowf. and all of Hi J',,W'oiiowMioptolilbli,ubJl HJ toafowreatrfctlon. naiaid, , i,. ,Hj i1-'.1 XU cL"""r lnlhelocul r 'Bit '".'J1?1"'1'- Ahalbe Mill or nixh n I K .heVeVM1 TTd by " V"f''d Willi H B..H t. . 'flW.i't'Hiileuionany nuiatlon i, IK J,mi ,u, 'teUou ui vulefwoJ I IHmm.' V 'a 'Sk |