OCR Text |
Show II THE SUl'l.EME COURT MM Kfirrin the Jiulgmrnt In tha Case of fl Andrew llarlt n. WflK.Ii), jM llultr, Montana. WSJ THt CANADIAN CMUBAHItS ntAOV TO nCTURN. A Itetrrrnil flrntlrman Indlclcd for Libeling I'rooilarnt l'rratlirrs of llli Unn laltli. 0 TslrSTIbfe b MS MBWM hi sjtimt. mtinirn. berltlen of Ibe r. A, Auprrme tburl Inn Menlani, I ate. Waiiiixutoi, April 0. Tim United Htale. Hu rune Court today reversed the Judgment of the supreme mutt of Montana lu tltu cau of Andrea- J, Davis, n llAiit, v. Hrnry Wlrboll, and ordered the casu n mande.1 for a now trial. This was n suit for damages. dam-ages. And involved the lllie tu certain lauds In lite town of llullo. Mont The casu turns nnu (lie construction til be given lo the lowllslto Invr of thu I United HWn, Davie hill title llrder thu townsliu entry rl, of whlcli onu provision wasthat mi tltlu shout I be nc-quired nc-quired under the tt lu any gul I, silver irciMr mine, nor tuauy valid mining min-ing ilaini held under theeilstlng laws. Wlelakl i lalmed tltlu iiiulir thu general gen-eral mining lawn, nnd vriion Davis i tiered ta prove Hint ut thu tlmo llio teiit to ttif llutte town. lit wan Issued the pniiilres I" disiito weiu not known tuba valued foroiliieralttTaiiyklud, uljectloii wat taken oo tho griuud Hint Wleldd' patent showed that, as n matter i f fact, Ilia lemlse-a til l-uiitntii valuable nilnviAl laiiil. and a audi uuulJ hot I granted hy a lownslic latent. Thu ctuitsustvitic.! tin objection, and Hilt rullug, which wa really decisive of th controversy, llila routt ovrrrulis. a Tn (iii.tlon Involved In tlio ulj Las lai-i long In dispute, nud there are various, ami In some Instances diverse, decisions unit III the exec llllvedlpail-rncllls. llllvedlpail-rncllls. Mm United HlntlB Hupriliie Court linn several limes passed uioti It liy lufctetiist and JiniklUfilloii, hut tfili. III. nld, litha Urn direct -duel-lull. Tlio court. In ll opinion, wtltti n I y Ju.llco J hi J, ssys. "The lnirUtit iUitlon N, wliithirlu tliu aumiic4 of aniwlnlifo Hut lhur wvrvany alu i aI.Iu iiiiiifnil Unit wltliln tha j towii.tle, DavUcan buOanrlVinlof thf IrrmlMa urrhAMI nntl octtipk'il hy ilm lMiauw cf llio aiium!ueiit UU-' UU-' rovrry of inlntrala In them, and thu Jmuu of n atui)t to th lUixiverur Afirrtnticlt ronvlitrratlou, wo hnva , fulllnlotlinciilioluokill that till quta-L quta-L Hun mutt In anawcriKl lu tha nritallvr. 4k ll ' truv t,IH lancnaici of he ptatlllva KiIto tint aiiiilillhni ut tills to mlnrrnl ri 7lnnJ within tlio lliulu of towunltra U KN t ty broa I, Uit lu alrlctmiM thuy nro-K1 nro-K1 Vila only lint Ihs irimilouoftlii A towu.ltti law ahall nut lm tin luraua of mffm ,1W,I,IC ll'lv alM) to Taluahlu lulnlinr mIh liiinla. Wh think thty mint la liuIU ff nurtlytn hruhlUlt thu iiiw.ttt of tltta I'M toiutnlni; lamia llii;ii knouu to fil.l, K nnil iiul lu lohltilt nuiultillon fur all HKtlmuiifniliiiawhli.li linn lay ImiltJ K, iiiiktiowu lu thu ih t Hi uf thu iarth. V lliuolJnturiliuTuiialtuait ttaa Ktoaininlrrllrflo IbhaUtuiiU or rlllua H ami tuwm uimn I uhllo lauila hy kIvIuk Hf? alM tltlu Ihtrtto. UuuYr auch pro- Bin Hon many Iowiij, with hullJ HV n Inipi of crrat raluu, haw Krowu iii. I It wuult III nuiiiy tnuiici I41 a HulKriAt Iminllmrnt to tho rosrvM uf SI mull to na If tin- tlllia to lauJuivii lul wj hy Hit Ir luhabltiut wuro autji-rt to Im ? oritlhrownty thu hiitaiui-ntUUcor. HVwrryof mlntral ileualta undt-r tlic-lr W turfaru. If thrlr HHra vrcul I not ru K- lM-t thrui atcalntt tliu illK-orury of W mlrii-alnllitin, liuilLir uuuM II ro. V trtt Hiriii ngalutl tliu lurtalou of tln-lr r 1 ruily lor tliu puroof ixplurliiir for mini i. Tlio lrui lallon to inlur MC liilnaucli exploralloN wouaj laruri-unt HjE Inac lo tha huiiiuctuU tritontof mliif-raU, U tu 1 L-liit;thuimtiJcttuliiilUcHniliiAlu W lutanluni Ihr IahJ woulil lai tu ouu W bavlnif tlio tide oor and VBluoli-mi! B utt In ruportlou to Hie auppofU rich Win nml ntiumlAiii-o of lu pmJurla. U Wo ilo not think Any audi rt-aulla wrru ntroiiti-nii lalcil hy tn act, orlhatniiy JP conttrui Hon ilioulU ba rItfu tu It that Jftwoul I lail to audi rt-iulu." |