| OCR Text |
Show A FAVORABLE TURN ; a the rrollatlimi Hclnmi l'njhn.I (tut llir Uullcil Matrt toncern-Inj toncern-Inj tlm Illirltig Sta. ft BASIS UPON WHICH TO SCTTIC THC OirriCULTICB. )rd Sillelmry Carefully tntietilrrt llliltic'a Ultnntili in 1 Malta Ilk lltmirki. 4t Tilrrripa to tat stwi. I.XIIIAIIItlll AMI Ml A. abe lUUrlnr Nr rtellallene Uracil n Dell I lla.li. WaaiiinutuV, Match 10. The Hch ring Hca negotlatlone litre taken ,11 arable turnitud llio govcrnnii 11U of tlio United Slab and Ureat llrlialnst "-r tnhvroat but reached a liuli upon V.I1I0I1 totelthi their dinl.ulllea. A rnmmutilaitloii from Iord Hillrbury to Hlr Julian 1'niiuccfoU-, ilrltblrtiiliibder licre, wai made taibllc by, HecrcUry Ulalno tonight, lull Lord Htlhmiry ta)ilhcdlipatcliof Mr. Maine, ituder date or Decemir 17tli lael, linn beeji carefully considered. .... "It In now clear," ho nJdt, Ihat thealvlecra of Hie I'rualdeut do not 4 lalm Induing Hea aa i man daumn ml. Indeed, that they reiidla(e that contention In expnw t nui. .Nor lo tlioy roly ne n Jurtlfliatlon for Hit cl.iren of llrlllm rblpv In the oitn n uiwn Ilia contention that llio Inter. wti ol tlio mil nlirln Biro to tli; Unit; ail BlalcaKOTernmentnuy rljli'.fortliat lairputr, which, according to Inter iivtloual Iw, It would nut o'liorwlw laueta. Wlmlevcr Importance tin attach to the preservation of tlio fur Mai ipoclcs, "l Ihcy Jurtly look oil II ne an object d.ieirvlng tin' moat terluue tolloliude, tliey ilo not conceive that It ronfira upon any maritime ,powra right over Ibo open ocean, which thai Juwer coulj not awtt on olher "Th claim of tlio United Hlalea to prevent tlio exercise of ami flailing by oilier uatlona In thn llehrlnr li rcate now oxcuialvcly uiu tlio lntcreit Mhlclilyi.tircha.Mi tliry taiaewa In tho ukare Uucd l.y Knita ror Alexander I, llitlio)rarl9.1, which t rohlblb-d for Ign viwla from approaching within llWlUllaiilulliaof tin cool 1 lanili, thru lloiiglng to ltuaau. In tlm IklirlnirHea. It l not, aa I under, atantl, lontenilwl tltnt llio iUlulan bov. irnniintat thcl tlmo of tlm laxly of tills ukaw nt it any Inlierrnt r U lit 1 1 ciifon-o audi rolilbltlou, or anjuln-J liytlmact ol laaulug It, auy ililiui uvrr tlio i an ava, lieronJ thu trrrltorl al limit ofUireo mllua, wblrh lhy Vroul 1 not gtliern lw liavo aoiI. "llut, It la aalil, llila rop lion, Vurlli!.. In ItaoU, auiulm validity antl forai arIit the llnllah oorn-V oorn-V maul, IwAuaa tliat sore rnmoot ran U ahown to have aroriiliit IU tirovlflona. Our mulaiitlou la tbt not only can It not b atiowti tbat tlio KOVrrnmfiitof (Iriatllrltnlii.at any tlnm allien lbll, lia admlltoJ tb uodnwa of tlio r; ttmlonaiut forwarj by tint ukaw, tut it ran bo aliown tliat It baa i-ato-Korlrallyilcnlnl It on nioru tlian ono occaalon.'1 'loautaln tliUccntrntlon Ionl Pilla-Viurynuotea Pilla-Viurynuotea from ali Iter of January, H.J.from Uinl Ijiiiidoii li rry tot'ouut l.leirn, itiixlan iuiiIj lor to lion. Uon ond alw from n mr, I y tint lluko ol WolllnKloii to Count Niwolindi; In Uclobur, ISM, rrfniiliiK to admit Itua . ala'a tilalm. Coulluulni!, lord Halla- V Uiryaaia. ' "Mr. Illalno Uoi not ilral wllli tliwo tirutmta.butronfinva blnwlf maloly totlioBiuMfrallou of Irrallca aul. in nth made UIwm Orrat JlrlUlu mi I KiiMla. and Amorlca and Jtiwla, In la, ami wiwlallj llia Ulweeu Hunt aamltlrratllrlulo Tina trwty tloua not contain a wonl toilRiilfy thu aiukveiu-a otdnat Ilrllulii in tlio claim wvutly ait forward for-ward by llumla to ontrol tlio watora of llie ana for lif mill from lur runit. I uuderataiKl Mr. Illilno'a arKiiuirut to bo thai IfUrtatllillalu Int.-nJ.it to lirolratukaliiatlbi' claim of ltuiala lo i icludo abl for lbumlloa from lirr euMtlll Jluhrlnu Bin alio noillj tako tlilaopirtunlty of doln.t ao; tKitthat lu louUiiliut larai If t atliulatlona In-fariir In-fariir iif full llbf rty of navlirallon and flulilni; In any nait of Hie oiimu, couiutonly tallfU tliu lJclilo 0.iui, alio, by Implication, ri-nouuciil ri-nouuciil any claim that coilld '1 arboout of tlio ume not of nlruiiu I atancoa In rcRainl tnaoyaiathat waa I not l art of the 1'aolflo ociau. And I then Mr, Illalno got on to coiiUul I thai llu' I'liriuHi I'ailllu ocean did not, nn I din not Include JlaUrlng ara llvm If thla laltir ronteulloii worn cornxt, 1 aliould rarnratl) demur to the cuiirluilou tliat our Itihemit rlilit to free ikHuuicu and frni llihliu over llinvauaibin "f ocean roul 1 iw vf facllTdy rmouucil by mu rrllceine vr nmlnlon. Hut I am not ri'iirr.l to admit the JualUm f Mr. llliln.'a ivnti ntlmi. tliattlniMonlaM'ailllo ixin' ill( not Incluilo Iktirlnir ' Mr. lllalimad. duwai a limit lNt of mnpalu which a dNlgnatlonillallnrt from thalof 'I'a-cillo 'I'a-cillo ucian' la tflTvn to Itrhiluic aea, vltlur aa 'IWiilu aia' or 'hen if KanifchatlM.' or 'Ufa of Ana llr.' rin arpiini nt will hardly bavu any form uiileu It la arllC4t li-Willi njual truth to all tlioillirr octoina ofthe world." LimlHalUlwry aay llio ilotcrmlua. Hon of thla llut will lm molt aalla fuirllr anccrialnird by lomulilng booka uf iclniiui ., of which La ai-Iwudanllitof ai-Iwudanllitof Mill" thirty of Tarloua Uatra, from KM downnarda, and . irlnlod In vatloui voiintrlea, which raiublneloahow that In ronimou ar-lanro ar-lanro llio worla "l"oclllo Ocean" do Ins'ulvlUlitlnerlei. "If, than. In ordinary lansuajn, lli I'acirlii oieaii li uaod in a pnraMi in-oliidlmtthHwIioliikfa in-oliidlmtthHwIioliikfa from llilirlnf'a Htralu lotho A larHot'lrclo, Itfolliwa that the Hit', nrtlclu cf the treat of UJi did acru;eln (Jnat llrltaln. In tlio fullii-t pnulblo inunnir, Ircelom of navigation und rlililmflu HeluiiiKrlia. lu that c, no liih-rmco, liowitr lullm-t or ilntilloui, nu Iwdranii from any comiiilulon In tlm latn.'ini!i of Ihatlnalrumrut toahow Ilial Urtnl llrltaln boiuiimwI In tho uiurutlon which the ukate of 18SI attmi lid "Tho docuoianta I liavo quotwl auf. flcltintly ratatllih that the not only i ' dldnotanulacoln It, but rrpudltlM It more than onco In lain an I un iiulrocnl Ivroia, ami what right Ituuh did not hrriOf poHaiwM, ah waa not ablo to ttatumlt to the United Htatea. "Her Majcaty'a covcrniiifnt have, In view nf thrao oomdderaltona, no doubt whatever that llrllUh auljrcui enjoy the Minorlliui In the Helitlng Hta which tiluuB to tlirm lu ill ty portion of the open ,'X-can, Iml It la norrrlln.linn matter of Unci re atl fartljiilhatllie I'rraldent li wilting to refir la arbitration what ho coiiKllirtnl lobe mitUra which Imi been lit dcr (Jlniaabli lietweetl the two go, era minlafur the lait four yearn. "InreiiarJ totho iiiiMtlotia na pro-ImKil pro-ImKil by Mr lllalne, I rluxil I y aa t the ilrtt an 1 M.ond mat a number rf ul lectloni will Iw cltcn-d I y litr MnJ.a. ly'a Kuvernmrnt. The) aio aa folloa-t "Htl What ticltMreliirladlcllon lit tho at a known na the ltthrlng aea aul what exclualvo rluhla lu thu aeal rtihcrlialhrrrliidld llj'ala avert and eserclm i rlor au I up to tho lime of the CeHntl of Ala.ka to the UnllwJ riUIn? "riecond-How far were the clalma ofJurltdlctlbtiaalo the atal llih-Mt-. rett'tilrrj and uniculid by tlnut llriulu? " The third imitation li txprearuil In Uie following! Waa the taaty of water now known aa Ufhrliig Bra Inclu led I lu the 4iraae t'aclrin ncvt , aa uied In i Ihn tnaly nf IW between (Irnt llrltaln and Husala, and what tlzltta, If nnj, In ltehrli!fHra were f(lvcn or conceded to U.-rat llrltaln ty aall trial) ; , "ller Majfaly'a (livrrnment would liivo no ohjectl mi on refrrrlnittu arbl-(ration arbl-(ration tho Drat Hart of that qiirallon, If Itahoullbolhoughl dcalrabie to do ai: biillhey woull Hlvo lint oinientl with the nrcrvatloii thai they uo uol admit that Hit ikil.lou ofl It can Ini'lii'lci the Uriier iteration tho arbitration woull hau li deterndiie ruthulnlUT partijo. Ill viould tw their duty to take exciptlou (Jreil llrltaln has nuttrauirxveled thv, any rlithla were fflvun to her or conceded tohrrbyaalj trtaly. All lint waa done w ua lo reccKnlze her tulural right iiffrcenavhMtloiiaul tliiat, im lu all other parta of tho i'aci llr (). nil. It i-altdllnotRlielhoae i-altdllnotRlielhoae rljhla to (Inal Jlrluiln, Iwcauio they were never hera tonlveaway. t "l-ourlh-Dldbotall thu rlghli ol ltuatla aa tojutladlctlon and aa to aia fltherlealntue llehrlni; Hea, rail of i the water lui dar) , In tho Itealy be txeen the Untied Willi a an J llilull, o! Iliu r. Jlli of Murrh, 1HT7, I aa iiiilm lalrid lotho United BUlea under that treat) 1 "lhlaquNllnn la lianllywotlh refer-ring refer-ring to arullrailuu, aa (Jrc-it llriulu woul I bo t rei4rt-l to ai ivi t It without dlapnl.. "Tho fifth propu.cd (piettlou la aa followi! Woat are now fie ilthta uf the United riutra m lu the fur aeal flab-erleaon flab-erleaon the waUraof HehrliiiCHea, out-alJu out-alJu of irlhnry territory limlla; whellurucliil;bta grow out of cea-alona cea-alona by ItUMtaof any aneclal rUlita or JurlalkUou bell by I er luaiich Saberloi orlulhiiwaleiaot UehrlnvBeafOroutof nwnrnl li of tlio I rtr-lliii; lilauda an I tbehablta of the nnla In rrmrtliiK Ihltheratid rrarlmr. ItttlryuunBtbtre-ont ItttlryuunBtbtre-ont nud fioloi; out from the latanda fir fond, er out of any other f let or Incident Inci-dent ronnecled with the relation of llio-e aeal tliherlea to the territorial jva-rMlona of tho United HUU-.7 "Tlieflralibniw, ' What are bow the rlgbta ol the IjuIiwI MuU:'etc., li n uue-tlon whlili woul I be very i roperly referred to decMuti ol art llru-lion, llru-lion, but the aule-ijjt tit claitae, which nAaumialhat auib rlghla iimll have Krownrutof owiierahlp of the breeding breed-ing lalan la and thu hablta of theaeala In reaorlltiK Ihltber, Invohra an a-auittf a-auittf tlon aa to teecrlpllon of Interna-llr. Interna-llr. rial law at the prea'-ut lo which lur Majeaty 'a Rovemnii ut are not pn. pared to Kccede " " Thu alxth queallon, lelatlng to tho lAbllihmeut of a cloaed ivrloil In ao.il flahlni,', which duala with the tuuea that may arln, In raau the controveray ahould la derided In favor of (Irrat llrltaln, would 'thliwro filly forot the atiUtince of eeparut reVrenco. Her Mijnly'a Roverumitit have no otjectlou to rtfar tho queatlon of a cloi(.d tlmotoarlllratluit, or to amer-ttln amer-ttln by that ntratia bow far the enactment en-actment ofaucltprovUlon la iiectiaiiry for Ihoprmrvallonuf Ihn mul aM(b, but any audi reference oiiKht not to contain worda anrarlng to allrltuta rulal nnd abnormal rmhta In lite mtttirtitllie UnltulHlali-t. " rtirru laau omladou 111 theao rjm-tlonawhlih rjm-tlonawhlih I baono doubt the kov-ernmentof kov-ernmentof the Wrialdeut will to vvry Klad ton pair, and that la nfereuce to the arbitration ofthe tpieatlou or what ddmaseaaroduetoiM.rioua who liavo liu Irjureil, lucaae Italian lat detir-mltinlbyhlm detir-mltinlbyhlm that llio mtlon ofthe UnlleilrlUlia In erlxlitp; llrllUh vea acla haa bnii without warrant In International Inter-national law, "riulject lo thiao rcatrlrtlona, Her MaJeatj'aKiveriiiiientwIII have it-cat Katuficllon In JolulUK Willi thu go veru- field of the United Malie In aieklllg y meana of atbltrallon nu n IJiibtmenl of the loleruallooal ipieatloita which ba e ao Jong fiirme.1 matter of controveray controv-eray U twn ii llio two governnienta," |
