Show ariet vriet answer TO D HelO loses tho controversy with anis letter because of insults offered SIR on my return fraai nevada a short time ago my attention was billed to your gentlemanly tion published in the dispatch of may letl in aich you ask me to either tarnish a proper statement of the bosi ness cf the biah adiar jo or crawl into nay shell now as I 1 have 0 o more control ef the business of the utah sugar co thau yourself I 1 am unable to the statement called or and ant being one of your chell backed kind I 1 cannot comply with your wry modest request you accuse me of mentioning the names of the gentlemen composing the board of directors of the co for ef lec yon had accused the utah sugar co of robbing the people and these men were tha friemal promoters and are tho principal pria cipal owners and board of directors of the company and there was no other reasonable cone but that you meant only did not have the manhood to call them by clams you aurely did not mean the fire or eix email stockholder 11 site myself who have nothing to do with tho bui ees now mr irvine when vou think it over dont you aeo the ridiculous position you placed yourself in you make the that the buiar jo has already made enormous profits and when 1 make you the offer to give you tsy share in thos profits if you will guarantee me aba reasonable interest of eight per cent per ann your pretended acceptance of my ial tr you except tho year 1831 cju victa you of not believing your awu statement that they hive already made profits you also make the condition thai T must antea you free accas to nil the books panels etc of the company I 1 suppose yuu were well av aia that I 1 not comi p y with thoas conditions but if the I 1 last anything it is not think the board of directors will make a tnie and honest report of the bua inea of the company but as the bord of direct ora are composed of the same honorably hono rabla gentlemen I 1 suppose I 1 dire not cail aliena by came er I 1 will be of doing go through buncombe aal for transparent effect in board to the personal per soral insinuations winch compose tha greater pars of baur letter you siy I 1 have reached ohp depth of ani accuse me af a lack ot or chuning as you call it and of not being an honest man the absurdity of that I 1 will leave to the judgment of who may have read ny former communication and as to the lack cunning or smartness I 1 will not dispute for I 1 have never set up claim ol 01 being very bunni ny but any man who me of beina dishonest is 0 o ala expression of the lamented boraca greeley a horse thief and a liar I 1 always try to and correspond with gentlemen and nona other unless I 1 make a mistake in my estimate of the man having my mistake in this instance this will close as far aa I 1 am concerned any furter communication on this subject ISA D WISES juno |