| Show 1 I A SWEET SUBJECT F facts acts Comuni vii og sugar making ANSWERED by bv one who knows hows whereof he speaks both sides heard A gentleman connected with the utah sugar works his hag sent us a communication previously published in the lehi Banner wherein he corrects a few sta stale ments menta relative to making sugar which a prominent democrat Deme crat of payson made use of a few days ago at a par party y rs rally Us tie requests that wo we give it space in our columns in order that both sides bides may be heard we will first give space to what this democrat J D irdine said as reported by tha salt lake herald it is as follows tho iho sugar industry is a good investment as figures will prove one ton of beets cost delivered which produces 1 00 pounds of sugar at 16 50 the territorial bounty is ia oua one dollar an aal I 1 the government bounty 2 which is 9 a total bounty making 2550 for 1 00 pounds of sugar the capacity of the utah sugar is ia tons of beets per day and the bounty alone is per day amenta agents say sugar costs per pounds at san francisco the freight is per loo 00 pounds making it H 55 laid down and this shows a profit of 95 bents per pounds the net profit of sott tons of sugar if tho the works were run to the full capacity would lo be per lay day and yet t lie be ca cern asked tho the legislature for additional bounty they do need bounty surely Ap applause pause the capital invested 13 and tle bounty for full yearly runs runa is 13 and the gains fr bounty on a double run next year will Is ba thu bounty alone makes a gain of ef 8 per cent and with profits the concern makes 16 par cent there looks J like ike a prospect proe pett for failure 1 applause the answer is ia by 0 A granger Ur anser as followill acil follo iowa wil for every persons sincere political belief we have the utmost respect and will never condemn the man simply because his bis views when honestly and candidly expressed are not the same as aa our own but bat when some political huckster gets up before a public gathering as ag J D i irvine is ia reported to have done and presuming g upon the lack of knowledge know kno sledge ledue of his bearers proceeds to make E statements tate ments and give figures which lie ha must know are absolutely without truth or fact we cannot help but look upon that man laan and nis s yle at politics with the utmost contempt why mr Irvino should got genuo ud and make anch a dolt of himself as he be did at we are unable to under stand unless it be that he was following out his hia line of action as made mani L while ahila a member of the late unlamented utah legislature le the tha report refer tea to spoke upon bounty the bounty on sugar more particularly in our country then he proceeded to import impart very freely to the audience lia bis knowledge in regard to the 1 best gar busino business ss now if mr ar irrine la is no better posted anty than he is en the beet sugar ques question tiou jae he is indeed to be pitied tor for his hia ignorance his first statement reads thus une one ton of beets cost d lyurel Ly erel which produces pounds ut ot sugar ht 55 16 16 50 the tha price of evi ri r ton of beets contracted for by the rtuh sugar cathis year is at the rate oi 01 5 per 1 tin a delayer d and we belkle he gnaws kno s I 1 it t wd we do not know what bui ineas the gentilman gen may be engaged in other that making disreputable speeches at political gatherings but we will to say that there ta is an opening for him in any sugar augar factory in the world anti and at a princely salary too if he can only onla produce his hia pounds of refined su sugar yr from ono one ton of beets yes let him give bonds to run a factory ard and produce instead ot ol pounds as no says and his services w will ill be at a premi im then he puts the price received for this thia sugar at per hundred which every dealer kanews is too high at least pt per r hundred ile he proceeds as follows lol lows agents say augar costs per in san francisca fraacisca iba breight it ir per note the very ambiguous ambi u expression expression igenta agenda say sav etc whai agents or whose agents day that bugai costa only 2 50 60 per I 1 boolba in san francisco buch a glaring falsehood shoud hardly be ty by a d deni cui alfor every intelligent elligant int man in the country knows anat tile raw sugar before being rf refined ined costs the refiner refine r aiom 3 per hundred pounds up we IVO wilt will also inform the gentleman that the freight per tar car load on auar lom san francisco to utah points is only one dollar dallar per hundred instead of 2705 ai he be states slates which will allow him one dollar more per hundri for p oils odis ile ghiates from his hia usual coute orce and makes a true slate mant which is that tile capaci capacity tf ot the utah sugar augar factory i L tous of beets beeta por day but v uh h n lie he continues and sa says ys the bounty alsup is ia ti per dav lie gets back to his bie re regular line of it requires 1 03 12 ans t ina of sugar sagar to draw a bounty ot 01 and to 10 produce that in one day from W auns tuns fis tf if bets is to extras extrac t nea y 30 35 per cent of sugar instead oi 01 tha modest 13 cpr cent which which are ills his former courts fig u arts here hera is the n at statement recorded J jh aig not net of pounds of sugar if the works were run to the full capacity would be 16 per day and yet the tha concern asked alced a the legislature fr for additional bonuie bou lity ap we are not altogether rin am but suppose the applause was wa civen the speaker in appreciation of his bis abilities as aa a liar for his big audience certainly knew that it is utterly ini immoss be to make the total output of ton factory bounty aud ail fur for one day realize anywhere near the amount lie ha cl lima the tha net profits of the same would oe de applas f must I 1 ave ath liim him to greater efforts forta ef for alter moie ol 01 0 the same kill kiral oi 01 rot comps comos this dirty sneak sneaking int insinuation but dhru afa u iney cin cabi make each year and gain their full dav inv t luent in two and one half years in ia da where does doea the uti un u uin uart colne iu in thus iltis aniag thal thai bm li I 1 are the facts what a contemptible way that is to try and make a point we believe there is a few th thousand glares I 1 lares of utah sugar stock I 1 ill onald that mr irvine or any one else who desires may inay have hare at par and if he has haa not already done dona so he will miss mies the golden opportunity of his lita if he does not immediately invest heavily in this thi concern where his capital will be returned to him in profits as he asserts as in two and one half years we have not learned that there has baa been any advance in the stock since mr Ir vinea vinen speech but bat would suggest he ha loose no time in in what shares he may desire for his speech may set bet people to thinking we hope it does andia and if his statements can be sub led in ia the least degree utah suar jar stock will soon scan be far above par out of sight as it were at the end of his tirade against the bounty or more specifically against ha lle utah sugar cathis Co this man who is so devoid of truth and decency says if they meaning the utah sugar co could they dare not make any figure but I 1 got them all the tha same yes got them perhaps from one of their 11 agents who says sugar costs only in san ind and now the public has his bis fi figures ures too wad nad a more condensed lot of lips lies wo we have never before seen been thrust upon a people the object of this attack at that time tima we are at a total loss to understand it partook no more mora of general politics ilian than does this article when he sees what a consummate ass asa he made of himself he will undoubtedly attempt to hide his blush of shame behind the innocent krata Krat fl whore p r ted for the herald and say he was not correctly reported we cannot accept any such excuse allowances can always be made mada for reportorial or typographical errors but there was too bueg much vindictiveness displayed in this whole harr harran angue Rue lo 10 I 1 0 admit of there being beine the least regard for the truth we can only assume that he was directly attempting of his legislative aits but wl nn en a man is obliged to stoop to such low and unworthy means to defend his past conduct he must be desperate indeed if ube he calls it cs and makes such speeches as that to draw political converts to his hia party we can only say he ha is welcome w yes doubly welcome so eo every man who will endorse such methods and say sav le he is a follower of such principles thui april 6 1883 1 0 A AG G |
