Show J AS NOT IN SALT lAKE Judge Hall Rendered a Decision De-cision to That Effect BROTHER AGAINST BROTHER Question Arose as to Whether E F Beck the Defendant Was Here Last Year Deputy Sheriff Called With Summons Numerous Times and Finally Left Papers With Defendants De-fendants Wife Who Now Says She Wns Joking When She ToM Officer She Expected Husband Soon Tlo mrtlon of the defordant Co quash the service and return of summons in the case of C A Beck vs Edward F Beck was sustained by Judge Hall yesterday The action Is slightly out of the ordinary The parties are broth ers and C A Beck the plaintiff alleges al-leges that Edward Beck owes him a large amount of money In 1S1J according to the complaint J5dyardr Beck left Salt Lake As to whether or not he has ever returned was the auestlon which Judge Hallwas called upon to decide yesterday Tn October last It wan reported that Edward w sIn s-in town with hia wife at the home of Mn Becks mother 2JS West Slth South street and Charles Beck hastened has-tened to lllc an action against him The summons was placed In the hands of Deputy Sheriff Cum mock for serv ice and he paid tens visits to the house without finding Edward although al-though Mrs Peck told him repeatedly that hm husband would return soon On thc tenth visit Mr Cummock left the summons with Mrs Beck Edward Ed-ward F Beck however In an affidavit forwarded from San Francisco wars that he was not In Salt Lake during the year 1901 and his wife while admitting ad-mitting that she told Deputy Sheriff Cummock and others that her bus band was here and had gone out temporarily tem-porarily now swears that she was Joking and that she did so because the callers declined to tell her why they wished to tee Mr Beck |