Show THE commission conclusion ol of Elf crais arts argument on louisiana Loul slina his harview of life hie inela 0 i question tho reply of mr Jbell for tile side a commission expected molote tolote to vote on oil louisiana today to day bios rob reb 15 tho the electoral Eloc toral commission met at 1015 still evarts tarts C lin on the ecna teas sido lie he said alij that bat the to 0 o cast ltd its votes in tho the state stalo find was vaa note not cratit from rom the general goern ment flatter oer the Fe federal diral it the terni tho the redowl the oth aud and lotti articles of the lie amaud meats reserved in term to states aill the ilo amble not delegated the w h of of selecting vic clars do Is tar coming the molo mojo nuil and issuing certia a 0 tn log belonged to I 1 tho be states Atea it will vie for or the iha federal government nt to danol the TOI votes after they had I 1 left c it the ibo ala mla swa As ail in ia the ibo flotilla case so late this bo dyball thip power of s to count ilia ibo vote the power was vas gr a buted to theme bodies by the conrat pillion lution lut but not the iho por poirer of legislation tho the power pos possessed essed by the iho liu ito charged that t the ibo other sido lil ed it in position holding lu in the floridi case that it fool bal judicial jadi cial audbur ity to quo iio war carranto warranto proceed ingao and now de chinng it was wals 1 I judi adl C ial cil body the duties were paid mij lo 10 a bo be legi dativo ue he cout that the vested la in the bo body was such as in ID tho the two housto for or the por per lor manco 0 of a uty ta to celet tho be tOMI T toto cis and aad to voto veto for or electors for the two vo lid did not posses the power la in to fo the ibo liili ty of Bro browitt watty and lawrence tho the statute proscribed they should bo be waited lor for aud and if they did not appear until to 1 aioo tho the vacancies acre to bo be filled by tho the to re they did mot bot and nd tho the vacancy was declared nod and ameir smeir tilled by ithe bo selection ol of thebo dome bamo men it w wa no na stated t to ill fill ibo be vacancy that thai th thair lir title to lo the ibo office of electors we WM to bo be judged there WM was nothing mho in abo offers of proof ou on the iho other side d t abst detracted from frodi the iho el atit of tho the 6 GoTor governor nor to certify to tho the antion ila iio tilt relieved of any to prove prom that Koil logg was debaca governor for in 10 the ho firby tho be other tilde offer to provide that through ilia months of october I 1 aud december there was no proof that brewster aud lees lei cisco were cr not dot qualified to an elec dec fact on the CLIA of december it was waa also among amone the ibo offers of proof that ilia ibo kellogg was VM by acy tho the defalto governor GoT Gover Dor of tho the state stal end this eels cato chows for vo loom hom thu the votes v apro era legally cast before approaching the iho lines lion whether tho the evidence submitted could bo received it would be first r to 0 o examine what the iho anwa 6 or of Louis louisiana Laun is the liw law of mot motlena luna two ia dependent act aca P on abo first ac too to elections in aud and to on CD colof constitution of a reveral law lil then bcD alicto haq act to electors these two to abo olic tiou ID nn less they wore were rape 4 led w which they acro not dot hero here rend read ik at provision in iu t ho he letter act providing for plan iko filhol of vacancies if tile ibe clec ire tora lots did lost dot appear booro 1 4 oc loI by r q u e n t av h st 0 1 1 t ibo b 0 cru v da sl u g s inn i t s repeated but toll all too 00 to ro I 1 c was w lall 1 la 1 S 7 0 tharo WIM a of tb laws of the state and not a of 1 ibo he laws hirtner nor a it of theia but 1 mido made by con coir grela no he referred to the revised fled stat nice the iho acts of ISM 1868 to la show they had bad been incorporated in ID tho the it bi tates ILA TO ro iced edt and acid eben read the lv law of IM 1875 paired march mill and an it made no DO provision pro Tinon for the iho of their duties by electors lo clorn it 1 did not dot by arms goo of ila repeal the ilia act et of ag a g incorporated in 10 the toa rea at antes so for in as that abat not dot witted to the ho discharge oi of their duties lo lie 10 said dot ciao of the ibe cot yonh visited new orleans during lo 10 to in governor kellogg float ho be ought to C count oil it tho the voto vote which A as DOW the bo construction 80 bp put pon tile tho statute of the be bt banie kid lie argued against tho the authority ol of congress to to interfere in the ho affairs ol of 1 aljo and anid our forefathers for father were cre BO of power they would not bot dermit tho the OLL ct at tho the fedt rat ral finger rot lit a stala elco tica and ana forbade the action of federal but now it was wan to t tho bl 0 b c es a 0 of f s r noraa loins laposi upon i h e p 0 c r of t he S talt 0 by ln ID I 1 10 0 through this commission into iut the ibo election to a state ila ho 0 I 1 it As 63 a monstrous an their post position in ia the F or babo was unchanged la in the abo abi cuca of neco astary there dould not dot boo be a rEv revision Islon of tho the count ila iio took the ibo clile of the ibo electors sad said raid that acting without color or chow of authority beier ifo nor ilia elector belting beato to in it into to office their action val TM A holly void in of lis ihn prop option recited be cited numerous 6 autho ill bother other bond baud 0 so find Lave reco led lad 6 oca oil ag ible there t wo we color and allow of and the bbate was waa not to be ba deprived of frh art act which it approved by an objection rued raised nt lit the of if the iho vote jo ja reply to the abo of trumbull that bat Pro provoster vister and levitate Lavi retO beilig inch met but plis hii cl cotora were au aud S bowa lance there re were no 1310 tofa tau cesia ato in lot he 0 LT coo a toned that oat IW the office mufti ix hol filled ailed or there must lo be a oy ey by no n nh a vacancy that bat wa wits not lot vacant ar an to fed e d arut there wall van DO evide itea that touched taa locut and it ibric ana it would bo be sable an to disqualification ht ho argued that ark ail lector elector ur ses not tin an cal eer but bat the the abo tarou olph d in 10 a liko like manner so ft a primary of 0 the word elector U w a voter voler HI at the polla pille ila ia bood no depiro to to partisanship to pu has case rr no on aa elti zeu and wanted ilio ilia wrongs ia louisiana LourEa that bat had bad go BO been rewe lot wanted them remedied ly by law II 11 vividly pic condition of ott audini irv in ill bat oud and solid it visa opt a state of of bf ulra claing to be L smiled ait duj whichever cheyer ido ads tho ilia smile camo from an attempt vu arao mean by b putting lite the LOA provision or of I 1 of ago got COY 9 to carry out iho be it was waa by tito th moans mcana adopted adap I 1 rd that tho the alato tow woi well cared arm stripe no nud in in the ibo florida case to in returning board acted aery ciera aidt ia ia the iho I 1 cao cat charmen laid it bo be elal a all doraty of p the th Com commilla milva bed bad aliat at wua wits the ibo of 0 ivert saia MII bo be could riot not know that lot bat he was ira Jol following lowing the ilo arg romont of 0 0 9 coner abo to had not denied that it II 31 inquiry quary was vui extended to lo to net act of cl tie loara it could HO go to vory tory poll but if it we WBK found tile Commis addrion noD wits van getting too 00 oo fur for to sea eca it could swim ashore fiK bore drowning alich L tell ever the afa of iba ali wider water at the lb point wm was against it 1 11 work vork conr not dot be b thoroughly done it find belr L lift Koppo flo it hal ikea provided provi dod that tant the governor loverto or loo 64 lb the person to lo cast cant tb tile veto of ia j would duj bill iu in alre tuto into the mode by bj which that thai governor wu wait would it 11 slap to inquire vilie thir lie ho aa U a party terly to lo an authorized board to so do what was done dodo dot ho be the tk 0 in 10 lo case in ID the an lo 10 d do i prito ibo 1110 oct not alt it would lt be enough to 1 0 know he be wm was defallo governor of 0 tb the stun state sad nod ilia same bamo rule rala applied here har with an aa earnest dac nets 0 of the tha blicka black a of louisiana eonni it wil wa prot proposed ed to lunka maket bern ilia lillima ol of the for or the be constitution patto them tho the right 0 of BUrm fio atod I 1 hey acro to now to be ba slaughtered for hay ha iok DR it it in their tbell L t borts torts closed cloned nt at 1 la 10 and oil occupied ill all tits tim allotted to iiii bit iii i aide ie and on oa motion molion mor of burland r the Cota mission took a recess re 6 aart jurgo clifford Cli floril announced that tie the republican tida mile lia boa its hilll 1100 idd and that two aid balf donegi renamed t 4 tho other side judge cam tbell then proceeded eded to 10 close for or abo e no did noc that the iho elector owed thir ex oroa in ilo or of aay ny isil LS aler but bat they derived their rower iram the iho people of cf the 8 to its which united state aiace us boier er the confederation ond and bedfor before ti df was adopted which wapiti wr in its own Iso informs to form move moro arltol ocilla mr blar campbell argued tho the ioa lius has power to deal with tile 0 of ci the it hoard aud and power to look into 1010 ovary every set net ol of the legislature iak and if that thai legi leg future coo invenes principles that abit lilt at the bottom ol of Ameri americal cao they should reject the votes while abe learned earned aras eiklid coati juaa til ad 1 I drew an in galt inary lotof abot of the iho 0 ot t as a an of his hia and to enable tao me to pat the Ibe cato caio fairly before you DPP 03 BV for an IL fatico the iho stio or of Lm islat b if pasted inch no aa act no HB this lie do it that william Wil lisin pi IN I 1 kellogg Kel logi J madison well sod their are made baido a body corporate cor vish arh oil all the iho powers ora or a corporation under the ibo civil code of louisiana and aaa there is 11 granted to llin the solo olo sod cod ciola ive privilege sod bod immen ty it to 0 appoint IQ in all forms forma and staff at all times as mf mav bo be in the be S awes of tho the states electors doctors fir nod and vice I 1 resident it at etch cich under tho the con of if the united att which my may be apportioned sad od allot if to the ibe swe ut of lilii liou or tho the of hirju L ju blinn mily bo be on an bitted to tod sod from time limo to time limo the ibo Legis latEro to mk make bueb direction 8 iii m way may be ba necessary t 11 0 o make this arant nut effective sod ad Us be 0 inlall all such bed commee ids is as may dry bo be and aa do all 11 II acts acta in furtherance dhoot would bo be said cud to 10 such an act at ai that ibm 7 yet id it is in not very far from the cis I 1 bt foro fioro the ibo court it the abo electoral votes were preist died by that torpor aioo with the deila and a gua tures required require i ill n thorn a of either house of net a stock bold r in 10 a corporation who would for a mo meet belittle to it with acorn A ATI aid id the ib spirit losice or would bo be clear cear end aad oil ibo judgment w ald ad be a j st mr campbell assumed I 1 r the loo preheat tho ibo act ot ol of provides for the altet election ia ro of electors dro ioie anil and called atten iua to 0 o thoo oath ot of office hid board be bai to tu iko tiko t lie slid bil they on their port part to provo that hit the returning renT Dio board never carno ossel old pit ciar vr corn cam bilal a birgio return retard made by the ibo cummi w to of 0 tha tharion ili tion they male ma le the tatul attil statement nt pi of the ou BU per ballich was wa a n tc coon ondry dary paper counsel bore bora gio a history of low love abe 1 lie electa in is ia louisiana came about md and who etro the ibo persons alio he witched watched and controlled it and said on n tho the regist ration books there are talent registered sod od in ibi census ol of ilia iho state there are ro pupull ion of ct voters totera A ati ring 00 oo the iho face abo or of thi ihl returns there were fr fir one ticket and 75 05 ow OUO tor for the ita other I 1 undertake to bay it lire li re was a sitio in this union I 1 would woold not dot sly liy alit I will sty 87 that ibal two thirds of 0 ibe be S atea nath f this ib onion thai voted at that clodon bava not dot blown ibo be tame fame quamby or lion IQ in compari rOQ with the drabo liia flea on the ibe census book I 1 alive aliceo ata sot a ti ri glo state slate ho he aked a ked therefore w chero to era WM was the iho propriety ol of this wholesale denunciation of ci louici aaa a aid cd her people A fact oct moro more startling then than tappy which hui hits been n burled purled hero and dd which may serve ac ibo next election for or camp campaign ign speech t tt f that bat I 1 lime ime is ia abst oo OD the be SJ 30 lit of 0 tober lober there issued out oct ot at the iho circuit court at of a new orleans tell dud P ap pp p wards darji of ol of arrest to beige beike ten individual of if the oily city of now new or eo ease for bit boi twy registered ered the melves ike aa compete oll voters in ID 1871 1974 they eui aoi braced some borne of the iho mobs moat abl in ia city m my nod and family byi oiD among tho the nim number now hot I 1 ia equal 10 ibo ta add aadil dd all lea he sworn to lo in order to procure thes there waa vita nut but a cifolilli cio lilli of cf truth or any desire denire 10 have tho the truth hundred and tally castle wro were tried and od dismissed on aebi sight bat bail jt it propped prepped the purposes pur poss the were made jy jy two police MCC all of them I 1 read them pula luell lf thurman tho iha whole ten tea media by two ml ur yes yea sir two po liemen lioi io in fach each word baad liadi A the affidi vito tilt on 00 these a red lias hats is drawn around I 1 he b feb 15 tb else eloc oril ilam B loo nr the cloo cl the be publio fessino abis lad bad a lort pi brafa fee eri lun hn looi glitis so arse a anticipated bod and adjourned until jo 10 lo 10 ch ck cis tomorrow to tu morrow ulab I 1 lie that on ilo 1100 questions dim remard to 10 the ail ad of ibis evidence li 13 abo Lut iiD else cue it ill i proposed by tie llie democrats demoi that it lis id pillion at 1 4 0 a ock to lo morro end nil its coins I 1 lie be notified ll it is abut alter the ibo an do DI buddem ut dt of the ibo d omo forno ud ad dill limp ill be gives agn o to conever lot lor further dollitz b tidd ing the iba JUlliet torl cut apt bl out talf hour aready given tj 0 1 oa 00 ach it bj bio been folly |