Show C lailo ai E R ill AD tammany boss greatly enraged at lawyer moss 0 ss POINTED QUESTION PUT I 1 I 1 I 1 refused to answer and may mayba ba proceeded against EFFORT TO DRAW PLATT IN resolution introduced at a conference of 0 the committee with the object of getting the senator as well as several other republicans se me fore the committee defeated ly by ISS a vote ot of five to two startling story of protection given criminals by police brought out in evidence ot of simon buttner charles stephans stephana a walter waiter details the at temps made to induce him to commit perjury regarding gardinE Ee the rob bery of ex mayor ol of trenton in the th broadway roadway li garden now mow york tork april 17 ta in the lie session of 0 the iho maget investigation today hon hen richard croker was waa again the principal wit witness nelLs or of mr dosya examination and the probabilities tire are that tile tho tammany chieftain and john jobu F cairroll ca imort will bs be the subject of 0 contempt proceedings proceed mRs before tho the state hhall adjourn an adjournment ot of the commis commission ilon nitta taken ehlt alq afternoon until next nelt friday und and mr f croker wats subpoena frd to t reappear before I 1 tho the suasion session on next Wel liddy avin ing 1 I 1 before tho the initiative ot of mr loss many of whose white mr broket 1 otis 1 I it t T hied sills that e k T 0 1 ya V heeks ato into being belt perso nall tho the ellair chairman 1 n I 1 took 0 it such action ns as would 1 lenac tivo mr croker in ili re chinal contempt it was wait stated today that u when h d Is mr dr fallows s ot of the committee left albany he be had instructions Instruct loua to prepare papers adjudging mr croker and john P F carroll in contempt when hen the tomal cammi blon besau its ito lii fil iulo today about the ali time alln tiling brought up was waa LT a delort leonn as an thu the 1 broadway I ro artway aulden Jul den which hall thour in tile iho upper broadway broadnay Bro adray district distri cB for some time in this place the ni lebed ii ked robbery of 0 mayor of 0 trenton frnk frank alag ouan took look place simon kutiner tiner r the iho fo former raker of tho the garden made some start ling chaiya price and his waiter corroborated in palt pait hla his tesI testimony WANTED rl PLATT CALLED tit ait a conference oc at the committee told held before the llie proceedings opened assemblyman If hoorman onfred reao lutins calling for the investigation of tumor minor ihal a law arm in the illy fly of new york and mith the tha assistance of oc other oilier persons por floii by corrupt carrupt ine means ans secured the pass passage 89 h 1 lie of tile state stale of oc new york cork of a hill bill knorn knoon AS tho a Ailo akorli rh ons gas e 1 and I tit I 1 d declario dec ec M larlo art that reta purpose of oc till the gas baa aai aa I to enable a gaa cOlli company pally to forre force a c con D be 1 CIA tc 1 11 ot of till all the gas cai ot of the illy city to the end that ahot gas gag relight ila bo oiled amil killat pi fee of the skime regulated by the called consolidation the resolution ful ther declared flktti it ft mas a necessary to ful lot lo ing ln ix tile low law firm of tracy li aramin platt I 1 toshu tho tatt ill coi wora ix tors of the astoria post hat light t company tom pany donator C platt benjamin it odell lidell jr exion gres small l fit quigg lolin john B U und and a others tho the resol resolutions tiLlo its verc defeated by al a note alc of live to ill two ill et I 1 lie iho I 1 can nien ibets of cit tho the eo biml I 1 t voting no a sir air mazet s ot of I 1 the lie resolutions resolution bald aid the committee ila biad I 1 certain cerl lii wort to perform that thai its me mode lie of it procedure durei had been laid out that the present la Is no time for or the ahe taking up ot of extraneous trane ous matter it va asa lie spoke for or ill ull I 1 tile tho republicans republican ot of like IH ollin littee ASKED TO III arjune challes Site piAna formerly tor merly a ja I 1 the broadway Broadw ny garden barden i nas as tile tho first wags exa milled lie ho wb avas in the tha broadway Broi dway garden lit at the iho time Md 1 d ex mayor ut of trenton to have liivi b been lee rk robbed there steps did not b believe robber had been committed and so HO tiB tined nheu I 1 S butilier Bult Butt ner lier tile the I 1 proprietor ol of tho the ilief Il arrested After afterward mard lutnen was appio approached ached by a man illan named singer aho auld him that money could 11 ho nia made d e by v 11 larl that t il HEO was a is robbed a abbed I 1 11 it el told i singer that ho h I 1 lid I 1 ad a already rea d Y 8 sworn 0 t to I 1 the e contrary conry at a it subsequent ab so qu e n t I 1 interview le a A with ith singer and fr frank ank pd fairell a rell it ft 13 t a I 1 keeper acl wr lien y it LS Sli 11 u itz n res rant keep or belne a also so p present r e ge n I 1 tit lie los baat named min man rave gave wit n ess ifa I 1 10 iv ichen m jeaa atness eald bald lie he mas ma 1 jilla I 1 to su an e car w I 1 that t mabian WIT alt ads ro rubard ile I 1 in it 11 er 9 place levs wua promised 00 an and ini ot of I 1 play ment ss t told old buttner I 1 the plot plat and waa sent tit by him to aboss ho he told him t to a ibay uy ilot bing about the matter to anybody would woul it like to said bald lie he then Stir hans I 1 he is m mon on wion 14 on wok in n LL a poolroom looking the laces lace and got bot 3 5 it a da day ir tor for tile that wit ana after work ork u which bich bo bit told to do bitnes knew no lie pickpockets pick pockets MAN POR fort perjury jowl JOB of 0 those in the tha at the instigation tor for plot fitness vit ness fol round and a second roan man tho the perjury lob job georgo 1001 arso fariell re talked laed wit alth calill Ta lill and AT aa aid he vaa mail al 31 the th lay ay before the falbe affidavit davIt taa mas to b tx e drawn rl up od uld aid he to T a of I 1 I 1 g barked out net and about jl it and no not t do it I 1 told sinner singer alit aid se phi boas he was angry anery tilo aig we e api w allt it I 1 started out to flad nd there i 1 11 his is but lie ile miss subpoenaed as not net ill 1 TH k ile next t da day I 1 iud nn murt I 1 wl met schultz al and all he l told ITIL 0 o 0 o wait unell lis li s went e al n I 1 to 0 ml geo captain and n aik jilin all 1 1 I flit alte he should ilo do I 1 told old 5 L 1 did 11 not t want to a co a on 1 the he aliferis lb all find 11 ll ho he sold aid nil it right I 1 could ifould 9 BO to 1 phil la dripola if I 1 wanted to stephans stephana said that q sent a in roan a n willii en bilm to 0 the atho be went nent a aa 9 tar far aj ad newark k they y sat bot aclo olt t there h e ls a tind S stephana t c was utu told lo 10 go to t alio llio 1 C ff toy schans a and na wait toa mrs men sytse aft no N 0 L nt ag arr tred anil and stephans stephana r returned to pr protection N OF POLICE file die examination x 4 ten or 0 Ster stephana bant was d at tilts point and femora ft Mora called simon BU to the tha attal ha testified that in III islo cania to this city pa io country liy ll 11 he c went t eli a rectal it M no lulu hian that in hu would lime have to lu ss se the police 34 mu uxa annu birtcil to ocie DM inspector ln vl buttle could not see him and ip i price then a now a buttner thit that loid him he would have to py pay him vip u month to insure of flip eho ichon which he started alli thu that itan it urr boily witt wim ile wa was i to get halto and I 1 have clon dono bu liurni a islas hlin top for quite a while le nult ncr buttler Butt lor that it ivan in ISOO isail tl 91 hr he paid tire money moncy to price at AL that aliat i time t nall ill ho was simply gme running inning nil air ordinary aaroon DuLt tilt ills his ext Uio adway sa andl M has bus han bc n frequently by police flie er ond and declared to t ha be all right 3 fail gone cone well U until tit capt C apt price came to the precinct anlu ur UP BY R tire thou lutiner rull ncr irald it mia mas IL eft caw of 0 hands ul ui But trier an ore that the firsts a F arle slid was wa to threaten threatt it tit li close clinic th lie garden up tit un ull ie ho he t tle and halt half ut of tiny any rubb ry clial ill lias lit il ui U object objected e d scald and told P pi ice ile be NN as ail I 1 11 ining 1 gume gamo and letting out nu no boons but according accordia to ow oi twit not prior price rc pIled I 1 dont i 11 it 11 lien damn n it you let out r oats I 1 want a tnt sith pice leu v n a as int hot a nian to ill akgul ali buo it a it 1 I it in 41 aly may witness i od id fail ro 0 hn he a aked alth nauna lu ill hould do lio m 49 told tt tit bob I 1 rob nelson nr abon a aloon I 1 IM por I 1 N atness oba cad aird to nelson ind pi ice began ill t make arrests in aliv gattle huttner amt tal to see ace evl sn rin but though ille all alii d 1 I u doarn flat alnis lit hi nasi alway to sec pet mm him tit tin if n flut huttner sold aad it lir was wag it to K g lis t i c at al adams tire policy king hing and nd owner of the karrach Kir rach bravery IS la taking beer baor irom from adani adams buttner i buld i u 1 I ill he be uell 11 protected altu but t T HJ 1111 lu ht lid did not as adaris dain p i 11 ll lint wt t a sties sago ironi iron tin liln in in ill r giuld old apt no n n th ih buttner lestia ht aft interview ith cat capt T if i lil fit it h he alleged that the ii I 1 nl 01 ald id 1 I will rell tell you I 1 r I 1 lla ht n air abir against ast you is 1 i is 11 I 1 neair still have anything bu u tilt nn it i attly W in ahi it 11 i ad 1 1 I buttimer But tifer to sell out DI 11 led ED pr pi neubery guern joh acif the conversation then their tul tui 12 0 1 I a robbery ot of fali u aich had I 1 liken see iaco t he previous sy day at tire ji adu albay garden buttner said to arl dont doit blame me ino fritot rol U captain A soon a ate A e chessid of it we ue sent to g kc gt t who ne of sour officers and tte ile told tin won was ile got tile money from tho tha woman now 1 it your leollo encourage those these women to rob facts it they stand in for one half you tant cant blame me we ave carinos put it a M match atch over every man afian and woman sort and natch them dattner asset asaei toil ted that lie he bud if known more than a hundred similar cases lit in ft bich the police had matte made women I 1 briare with them the had stolen front from men lie swore aware that on ono occasion a noman amaji robbed a mars man ot of 1500 and gave the whole amount to tire the ward man mail the robbed man complained to caal price and said buttner dult altah this misfortune happened to these p ople itce und anti the th they met the girt on the street I 1 and th ill had to arrest her slid sha said ald if 1 I i ai S e tho the nard ard man the life mail ad of att aft r she he told that ill they y returned tho the I 1 KW and let the kirl girl coll 0 o CARED foil R tenderloin OIN DISTRICT outliner sold said boto bob nelson balled all th ill women arrested in tile the tenderloin buttjer alleged that arke had him film arrested on the charge chaise of robbing ma gotwals purely lor for alle spite anil and that makowan previous to the arrest had apparently parent ly beti been satisfied with the explanation lila nation buttner had given to him testimony was suspended and gave ave elvince el eld dince enco in support of that of stephens fail been it waller sv elter in the broadway Ero adway ganders str mosi said baia that rind find stephens had been followed follows it by ills his men during their entire lu in the sarden garden case RECALLED ItE CALLED richard croker cooker nas then called I 1 mr jr knas asked him about tire contributions maua anade by the clr judicial candidates last year air choker could not jell the amount tire tho Tam maily leader and sir mr mos ilona had a little tilt till as n to it whether hether sir mr croker had arid liand that the city was waa not wide open mr air had never heard allot the railway or persons Int interested in it 1 had contributed 7 to tammany hall during alm ahn last election clr 1 I V croker had roc elved no money ill or indirect from mr cart can oil ell tills ini the last year from andrew fire Ii rodman man he or of rather his arm rm meyel Cro crola lr hid had received money moncy mr croker paid Is was lilt mr ric edman in n ahe united states fidelity company you know that ail tho the holidej of 1 r rs or oc the city government take out lh in it bornds from your company in crisis it 1 lar carls Ir ls not ot oll ifil ot of aillem liem arid 9 iid tilt witness leas some take them out front 5 our boss basis company coa alny this ild loud laugh lau glit tp 10 lo do you enearl mr plaits company nik n ik rt 4 air aboss yes sald raid mr croker you know I 1 nican anti there was moro laughter mr fir cilker Cl okill 1 I his a m I 1 n company had ball the major mafoi try lly of fill lie ill 1111 ins anesa in the uty and mr platts platt 9 in I 1 lu state slate REFUS TO ANSWER mr mors alors ackett mr croker how have burh li it paid for his stock lit in tire clift united jetti bond cAl Pally anti whet it tile alio gt erk tk wo was riven to ira hlin hilin upon I 1 lie for or of tbt com piny mr ranker ie TU sm d to lu answer and mr re ie qu w td led the committee to direct tho th a ni liff liffets ebs to mr maani so BO dl jo L anu an siT mr bow no asir t lr said paid tho witness brinly please to lebord the gentle lemans mans lenuial ite filial to andner tilt fill ot of these thi sc quits hon concerning alie lie dottla gott la ot of this tha hoc ind and her lit lip hurt paid for fill IL II or oil nut or luthar luth rr h pot got it al tile iho of tile tho company said mr ir mo and record r cord 91 abw that flat hr he deflin to ana on oil tho the ground anund that it Is 11 pi fit I 1 1 I i trial mat nj ici ilter atLer assembly mial loir mail mall air C itter bald att was not in h AVI littlY company I 1 i 4 t never liener any batok in the lh ins hill gas Us ill oaf wanted to know why he be tn 4 1 d I finite anwer answer to these lurl QU iu i ill nil mid and mr croker cooker slid bald knon I 1 have get to answer is in anti anil must reserve some to my judi ment if I 1 dill did not abraner saint I 1 could sit here without anMer angne lne ling a st towing at fill all lie ile had no stock in the ithe new ow amsterdam Anist ardam company though ho he once had ions ionic before tho the introduce int hon f the ino Aff astorri Lorta business I 1 TI 11 0 parted with it at least ten days the alin vote veto was taken on of it the I 1 A korts bill had parted with it because ho he did not v tell leh to ret mt mixed up in in that business no had bad only held beia st t on it a margin A 1 SHORT ON MANHATTON n apu r au were short on oil manha it asat loa uri mr slew a clu auca J I 1 floss that on saturday sir mr croker croke r had utterly refi thed to 1 I ivan ivaa not mt mr croker that nult never nem happened at all it if you tell I 1 hod had aft aa it L gent gentle lentan nun I 1 bould have told you sir croker refused to admit that the democratic 11 opposition to the passage of he Af toila gas bill was waa by reason of the elie fad fact that lie he and his friends and I 1 t the h a inc acro of the democratic orann held stock in the flit new amsterdam cai c company ai lany v which IN ad a rival to tile the company mr air loss mr aun it ic he tied given its son sea fra prank irk alth ith to buy stock in tho the kloeb ilg construction company but buc mr prokor doo declined lined to answer chairman blitzen InstrUCt instructed eid him to answer and ho he refused the same game thin occurred filled lurt mr bloss asked hint him how much stock of the company mr air croker held and how much he ha paid pad for his interest batem st in III that concern mr bloker said lie he thought tho the elty would bo be much butter butler it a civil service uw CUTS when mr ir moss loss said that croke biad bad round found that in business mit matters |