Show WHY THEY OPPOSE HIM I 1 arguments of opponents of principal mccoy IVl cCoy POINT TO FORMER CASES letters from chairman baldwin of committee on teachers and school work and supt bupt X millspaugh ill cited to show that the Mul liall case isi Is but one of several mr mccoy kc be I plies to this and makes explanation samples of his instructions Instruction sI to punish I 1 1 I 1 an ln lively time la Is prom flood alien tile the doniat or of deluc aaion at last reaches a point where ter ils art compelled to oppress express cs upon fallen tho the mccoy those nho allen favor avor the lh or of t mccoy cy from the schools as the immediate result of tire severe pa pun III I Ishill ent which illicit lie ho Is 19 alleged to ha haie 1 to Mul mulhall liall nl at elfei oquin I 11 school sonic collie days ago aeo v will all takei take tile lio ground gralund unit that lie he hal been guilty elty afi E offenses cs before in support afi of their claim they cite the ease cae of oc stophen stephen i ailais jr ft a pupil pullet ut tit the sunnier school 1 in blell who it aa was claimed wis mas yo so severely punished by Ile cary who was ains thou then of that school bohomol that tho the committee on oil teachers Tou chers and school condemned both the manner arid and place of it mas alleged tat nt the birne that principal mccoy threw alln cw the buy boy fallen the floor and hell held him there tor for djino time nith his lil foot fool after lie he directed one date of the alers teachers aln rs to lo below lint the in the with which ho he gae tho the boy fin an unusually se socie talie whipping chipping LETTER filom COM 11 the nna matter t ter was investigated by the ih comm committee tte on lie Te Teal ahers Hrs arid and school scholl I 1 IN work ork after r which ell tile the following com mun lention was transmitted to tile the on oil april 7 AV J mccoa asti print ili al stamper Sc school liong lair sir lei in tit tin matter of I 1 ann it cament of steven hns 4 tov bv you nil the tom am on teacher 4 and school ork late haie thin ihan to say steel after full ill of tile ilio facts facia and giving them careful consider con uder fallen we ve hillme the bov punishment to tile extent of if that was mas 11 nc oMary cary to make ako bilm ira obey the rules of tile school need aint liili of tile tho teachers bui bill tte me must condee cond ninn a t he manner mant and place of punishment Y you ong boucht lit rent not to fly hale cje pm gine buur out feet feel on tile hie hay san durhl not to hav truck him with mith a tick of arv any size let in the presence of llie ilia mchoul ond died on nil ought not afterward to lo hivo have corporal corp orul pun punishment kliment in fit t tho he corridor coir or in tile tn hearing of lite t chotaro aarle you oil might not lie in the hea hearings ringI of cot tier school to lo havo cat ledl to t tho he leacher to 10 brin ou the largest alck I 1 lck by bv cefere I 1 to bund boul bouk of real rule I 1 ef veil ml observe thief ou oil ahne rules 9 and JO 10 leader dipti of teachers like lio committee Is of tile thil corporal ought to lie he adminis torel lt ril on only if it 11 list retort report and little after sell otel hns has been land HII the other officer irs arm have loft left tile building tend devoor n hn hen IL 14 chor li in angov we are arc asorey sorry to be unable to Indo indorse isto your coi conduct duct lei in thin matter in Aitor but beat the ilio com can entries Is s uncertainties lei in tile opinions me have before d arid and me T hoeft chopo wo me m I 1 11 cooer again have ocea olon to it IA grea farce with your management of able school of jf course on will understand that lion hitoe stand fl indr by bv ou in ill the initiation anco ance of discipline along neigh and complete comp lolo bu but t vou vote nor lit ili has ali nav power to go 90 further than tho the rules ft allow to tho rho lik of the inc commit tee herein I 1 C onvel convened l uio are for eat onla andi will nut not be communicated to mr I 1 ila a 01 oil any one els a nto aio tile ilio cupello enci at I 1 1 cry truly treaty yours your BALDWIN chairman i DECISION another letter bearing date of juno june 1 25 5 has also been taken front from lie ilio archives of the board to show that sir mr mccoys mccols illation bolth v ith many of the elie patrons panon of tin the it schools chool mere mf re strained and that his methods of dealing aith many matters that thai cattle came bedine librn title could be greatly irn upon tile the particular cular of the lemeir refereed to was a as folit follows evo a the thiam that concerns me moro more la Is a feeling I 1 content cannot cattle anti and ool ilch ai I 1 would not nol la frunk if I 1 did not rat correas that 5 our any method tit 0 deallia with I 1 children 1 ren and alth ilia patrons Is 14 ety cay ninny many statements leave reached me tills this ear from our pa latroa pil troa roia indicating that khlar volah alto school were viere very are much alich trained in ili boer came vt of rom rent plaint I 1 have blood bv dour our failing bitt lit un oil a number ot at occasion I 1 have iwori left uil nil able to feel that the might not ln e beret ml met iv bv kolew hail more moi 0 call poll polky olly to later tur discipline tie arid and ind pd ed mith it 11 tie dc liard ment of it it IL would goo 10 heard to speak too loo feelingly tit of our excel work lei in the ali n hanolt buth in depoll to LO trU ehing und died fitner til tra ir alion tion und anti this thin statement Is in not lint ut at ILI ull I 1 a amith walli tin fit incline w I 1 hao t hat hilll ill I 1 u filter mi would mould ret nutt fro fron ii a auxt mie policy it in to 1 11 v of iolar hiir ingils amplis I 1 do not jl think that tiny ono one reels thit there Is li if m dinyer of voter hoovia infinite urr letter ion on and aid I 1 belice b llio alio that eat tiller bour our dignity nui nor ih the allare of the school would unar dl al tail nil if you were mere milling tn 10 c ini lor 0 I 1 teas can adilou or I 1 its ints in ts of of rho ih little it a ind in left which lie r al 11 front boy oya biond I 1 think aw oil my motives lei in lines fiur air attea attention tion to lo thin mitter and ami will mill rf lv it lit in elie smirle til fix life I 1 91 ylo c it I 1 buix arm vo J r 1 millspaugh nill MP iuis DEFENSE principal mccoy N beak in last lakteen ee ell ing said id w tile respect to the hayes ease that thai tile thi mus diston led on oil tile th hid tile of tile the 1 the imy boy sall mald 11 in e was laig hut lot ariely Br iely inin klied till ciul yo yra u mall il so PO by flat it if 1 tier lor to lu in that thai I 1 ali I 1 le coln millet complained of the boang inflected in III tile cori our adur instead of tile vinco office the placing of my foul foot the buy boy little was lincK sed by three or lour later teacher was nah cited the fact was 9 that thai tile the boy pulled away riburn aiom mu file al ami E 1 1 fell tal tile gloier lie ho then started to aci amble imlay and I 1 ily placed my lily foot fool upon his lek leer to alid him ham this lei in the t testimony c a if mony bufore the committee As to lo the the chaise list lio lie told one of tile teat c fees to being lilar him the largest stick slick in the house mr air sald that thai ht he ill did d not remember ilia hid words nords tit adli s ly lul lint lie ho had bad the impresa slon that thai he asked pue fine of tho the Is to bring him te a filp whip from the office deferring to tile the cause of the punish anent mr mccoy said that ihal the bov had one of life teachers and karate ital her hands hande in tin tile varne connection tho the principal calls attention iHen Hon to the 1110 fad fact that keene mori tint uter after tills occurrence ho he was waa promoted prom oled to the of the ih here ho he has since served B tali to the letter from cupi paugh ir fr gal bald that the superintendent nent had only lizard heard one side of the mory ahen bon he arote tile and that it waa 3 more radical th than in li it would ol 01 estherm ae have laen INSTRUCT Ul TO PUNISH mccoy also d A number lumber of notes ritten to IA barria by bv su ru tot jh rit Illin paugh allai akin ailin to administer corporal corpman corpo ial to bials two tit of these jhc thc hc fire ur hir hi r given kiat n alif ill ficht fiat rt raab lt fin am fidlow lua tile the name afif if tile ilia tjui loing 1 ft ednk 11 ank nil mr Y t send nond back anck to vol I 1 hit bac P given i man his hl chole cidh 1 hi 6 t to in pr for to tf or of n P 1 etc vt or parul vt vi up be ore lila 11 ronni and 0 nean fir hla him garft for fop la hah conduct and edgr rea ion not all 0 ln d duffo ill go in that part fort of 1 li mr ir allro 1 I send ond back anck to I 1 ou all my r of r the case caro Is 14 hot 1 h I 1 aas as the ilia tome arro blar hoy to ua a hu r oo ifil in 1 alop I p fi h M when tic t lm 1 10 te 1 l 00 0 o bati man ro binl 11 him blouch dl ouch tie he an biln ali rn noi I 1 lav C knonk that he etim an witter i t he foru 0 falvo 0 11 no L 1 binl lint t to ie re rc e o gru rp e I 1 arn I 1 le h me it I ml leaour your hand I 1 bould at d not howen cri in madho ko such h it inet ont HI L all it severe WHY lit hn DID NOT RESIGN Rr SIGN principal mccoy was nas asked chy lie brad declined to lo tender ilia resignation aben M hen it A am stilted for by tho the president of the ilia board anti anil chairman tit nr the com on con teachers and school weilt oak lie fluid 1 I dont donl think they luid had any I 1 ight to c call tee for my any resignation an a no ito regula tiong hall been olo in ili fart farl I 1 did not t consider it II lei in order to pop that I 1 not in ili afna troll alon I 1 preferred 1 n I thorough invests ofallon lion I 1 athor than to lo resign lut beat I 1 have not lint it it Is probable that thai the lh based lioard will take the matter up borne t lime into next ue flork k find and dispose of it IL |