Show SOAP CASE DECIDED TRANSFER OF STOCK STOCIE HELD TO BE INVALID I 1 decided by judge marshall III in miffs tiffs will hold the tha control ot of the utah soap company I 1 t I 1 gi L judge marshall yesterday handed down his opinion in the hie case otje obe I 1 ij peran penn K M A penn anil and L P ingersoll va v 11 II F r Xhi cald john R L no ina r F kincaid and willie william T idan ia woodey plaintiffs anil and defendants are arc owners of stock in tho the utah SOKI soap company and the former claimed thet tho the laptev hul allY disposed of 0 fifty shares af pf it treasury stock valued nt at sr 15 per chaire to J R I 1 burt at a meeting irregularly called and at abich plain t effs iffs hid had been given no nit chance to he bo present in that the defendants m inight i g ht 0 obtain b ta jr L e m majority e jor alty 0 f tho the fi mock lock i and r t 1 th thu ki n p anc M vant n t t the e pin i n g f from real in any way being concerned in fit the management of tho the arf alra of the company 1 the tha judge juden found that the defend ants im aa charged cli arced by the had bovit in collusion against the plaintiffs and that the sale of tile the stock block was but a device intended to redound solely to the ilia benefit of themselves tile the sale sail of tho the fifty shares share of stock was wag vacated anil and droll was an matlo a il editor dl of the defendant in in lit the sum ot or jwo |