Show LUCKY BALDWINS LUCK judge decides he HB owe TU llan ashley anything I 1 I 1 san francisco jan 29 budge slack today decided that lillian ashley waa wash not entitled to damages irom from EL J lucky bu I 1 dw in fo for r seduction me du C t to n miss ashley As liley a pasadena i filled the millionaire fil alleging legin 9 that lip ile was the father athor tot ot her chi child I 1 j sho she said ili blie met him in bost Bont an anil d WB wan induced by hina to come oil to 0 california the ras ca hasi baa been it a sort an fn rational rat lonal out one from tho the start ean baldwin 1 in ili his demurrer dt to 10 the iho wt the chalin that I 1 r he had been bpck antl inti mato fill ashley Afi liley he t not ia lla ble for damages repute tint I 1 hafl so uell gnoun that no woman aou would id llave tits lila T dair ing tile trial griat wa AINs emma asbby 1111 I 1 all lant falls fluter abt r attempt od to shoot baldwin in court she just juat missed tile aged defendant and the 10 11 WA aa ti al for possession nc at I 1 the C weapon during I 1 ing chich the attorneys for tho the carlies artlas interested te came near sho shooting otina enuch ciu li other I 1 amma mma abailey was waa acquitted ot or the I 1 thadeo of attempted murder on the tha ground fit insanity during the 0 of the damage suit baldwin Bal divin introduced testimony showing g that miss ashley had bad been intimate e N with I 1 ill a other t tier men ind nd writ art an adaven to res judge slack in lits deeL slon sayi that the unfortunate woman thai hai no claims in luw tio no liow low mail iad hor her story as she he was show n to have hate been got manow novil hat zat of tin im alven turca although not the rea Lrea luro ture that Ital baldvins baldwins Bald wins dwitis attorney made tier lier out to be |