Show I 1 I 1 EiTT tED IT 4 I 1 I 1 I 1 P mil adran 0 it go into 4 I 1 I 1 alic constitution i I 1 I 1 I 1 i I 1 I 1 OT AND SHARP FIGHT 1 I 1 fleen thousand people pros I 1 tested against it 11 t i t I 1 I 1 AST ST PLEA FROM ROBERTS I 1 I 1 ellered the insertion of this clause 5 would make the adoption of the 1 constitution doubtful tames james I 1 purges urges the convention to seed heed the 2 voice of the people motion to reconsider j defeated by a vote of 32 I 1 to 69 various views expressed x on n th the labor question the con q 1 a fins fine body of 0 working nin executive and revenue and taxation articles adopted the motion to reopen the woman EU sut frage question was wa defeated in the con convention yesterday after j L short hort but lively conflict 32 voting tor for eabe ae reconsideration of the article on elections and rights ol of suffrage and afif I 1 against T this disposes ot of the question and in 14 ins tt the insertion of 0 woman suffrage I 1 in 1 the he constitution before the motion to reconsider was acted on an all avalanche of 0 petitions on I the i subject fell ell upon the Secre 1 table ible making the hie total of the petition erv r for or s parate submission and of those opposed to it according ito 1 statements furnished by leaders on each id tide side during the remainder of the day the convention was in an all energetic mood m 0 d ielne the three articles on the E execl fcc utile t department labor clowd and revenue and id taxation it displayed a purpose ito i continue to be a 0 us by voting tojo i egan work a at 9 instead of 0 ja in the morning and by adopting rules lies to limit debate the recommendation of the he commit ite on accounts find and expenses that the members gen Ren relinquish their claims alms to further compensation was re led yesterday yent erday by a heavy vote the committee on schedule Is I 1 s ex cx aled to bring brim another stirring issue into ito the convention today to day a majority I 1 ito members having yesterday tied filled a report on the prohibition quenion n that thai it he be not sub illtyd tied to a vote of file people but left ft action diction by thi the I 1 the anfort prevails that this report will t adopted by tile the convention the prayer at the opening or yester YS y session se mas aa offered by delegate Dl sate riello insen I 1 FLOOD OF PETITIONS when petitions were called for or U I 1 be oman and their both ith hoed that they hai had reserved referred moh mach ammunition for the final en ell gement prayers for separate suh sub Ini were viere presented prem 1 S follows f n ll 11 0 I 1 ny BY mr fr roberts Hober lg from 1 1 9 1 0 g a laa botera kers bf IC Ys ville it a ot of tile the voters of t the illI precinct by mr tr heyborne Hey horne from 21 mn A cali county ty mith 30 by y mr orcen green irom from pleasant view with alth 24 by air m r K keith alth from isalt lit lake city usg M by bv mr II 11 r kearns frant mm salt lak P county 65 CI by air tr squires arnn salt lake city bort W by C P larson barben from mantl alanta 31 by y sir mr from kalt sit lake city and nil county 3 by mr mackintosh from rom salt lake city gal i by sir mr sharp from rom pid 2 29 by bv mr clerel Kl eiel from ogden den by mr it sharp from fro provo 97 by 2 mr ricks from lid 69 by y mr haynes from fro in murray 31 3 1 by mr ir hill from rift fait lake city cl by MF hr hayn R from sat lake city SS by y sir mr VanI lorne from salt lake city alty 22 by mr janie james from salt lake city ity I 1 the following follow lne petitions asking for I 1 the ills ot of woman suffrage in tile the constitution were presented by mr heyborne from rom iron county with 11 PIgna by mr jr Frow franclik Franc nels lii from rom morran 88 98 by mr warrum from logan by mr fr allen A lieu from plute county as 2 by mr fr hart from logan ass by mr kerr herr from logan loean 16 by mr jr low from hyde park by mr h I 1 r I 1 chidester from weber county ou nty north ogden summit county HS cache county davis county I 1 iron arun county am wasatch county utah county 30 20 gunnison Gunn lion 21 31 millard c county y ml carbon county wash wah antton a county rich county 27 iran cry county 52 salt lake county THREE OF EPHRAIM mr lund jund presented the laet fast potation on the subject it was wa tor for separate and c contained 4 the signs lures of people of ile he remarked chat this tah and a previous pre loua one for separate submission contained the iam of 0 thren three fourtha of the legal voters filters of ephfraim Ephr raim and lie he was there fort ort inclined to view with suspicion the ll lilon from that town presented by ChI chichester clester WANT W WT THE LAST DOLLAR tte report of the committee on ac counts courto and expenses relative to the ray par of ellich was waa laid on oil the table on wednesday was taken up on ell notion motion of mr lund sir mr ean 11 0 of weber moved the pre quil question on con tho the report lund that it WB was not fair to ills pese mo of the question without it a word ol of debate evans withdrew Ms ah motion anil and lanol pro pron mixed ild to be as short a as the fund was ile he urged the h adap A ilea of the ibe recommendation that arem kam w receive no further compensation it dinless there should be it a balance in file t convention fund afar compensate lit t the e officers ti nicer in full and paying tho the t P aUns bilan th it convention turned a doat afat ear car to r at ir bunds lunds pisa and rejected the re tion by a vote fotr of 62 to 1 28 8 WOMAX WOMAN cufr SUFFRAGE HATTLE BATTLE g i th the motion to reconsider the tote ote by y bici holcli ill the article on elections election and JF ichta ch of suffrage was jamood was wab i then taken up lip it having havir on monday been made a special order for yesterday mr air varian who he made the motion was air to delcua dl cua s it when mr fr car coray y interrupted mith an all objection to the a consideration of 0 the nuci quest llon lan A pa parliamentary ra barlien ary is rangle over tile the objection followed s at t the end of 0 which Preel president dent smith it held beld that under the rules rulea the objection bait ft an in order hat fiat it 11 necessitated the taking of a 0 vote te to determine we whether or not the question be considered the objection was voted d down c only a devor cw voting with v I 1 th C cray corny ray to sustain it mr varlan varian r ming ihla his remarks paid mid that not only the effect of 0 the insertion of f a woman suffrage clause la in the con constitution it I 1 atlon upon the people of I 1 1 I 1 tf I 1 42 fi f I 1 I 1 af ia I 1 f I 1 I 1 1 I mr ivins take a tilt out of robertz roberts utah but its influence upon the th e sentiment of the people of tile hie united states stales p hould be well conald considered red lie he dired desired to see sec utah admitted and therefore was opposed to taking any chances on oil the defeat 0 of statehood OFF DEBATE sir mr roberts roberta rose roe to speak a varlan varian concluded but thurman obtained recognition first and moved to lay the motion to reconsider on the table and roberts was compelled to take hla his seat with h his speech unspoken mr evans of weber asked tor for fair play toward roberts roberta he said the latter bad informed him that he only wanted to speak lie file minutes rut but the temper ot of the convent convention lon was in favor of choking off on debate and a score of delegates excitedly demanded the putting of the question the roll awa was called calic d and the th motion carried 65 to 35 evans ot of weber who voted first faral in the affirmative changed his bis vote to no no explaining that ho he did so because roberts had aad been denied a hearing A somersault immella immediately to ely atter after the result was announced noun ced the convention proceeded to execute a somersault mr avans yvans of utah moved to take the motion from rom the table ile he gave as a reason for this unexpected move that he did not want C I 1 I 1 I 1 oem kw k w i A e q i I 1 11 I 1 hii I 1 W y 1 mr roberts maxes a last appeal the motion to be hanging over our heads everlastingly T the he motion WAS carried by a vote vole of 0 67 to 7 and the motion to once reconsider being once wore more before the convention evann of utah move moved that an aft hour bi be allow cj for debate on oil it sir mr Ohi Chir flester loster the woman suffrage lea lender der moved to amend by making th the time five minutes tho the motion of kv eve ails hofweber of weber that it be fifteen minutes was carried LAST PLEA mr roberts was waa then permitted to speak lie he said that the question that had been asked during the woman suffrage debates debater where are the petitions for separate submission had been answered for since that time petitions had bad been laid before the convention vent ven tion loin signed by people asking for separate submission regardless of what tho the number was on the other side the convention had no right to blindly ignore the reclus frequent of american citizens who asked an opportunity port unity to vote against lo 10 woman 0 m an suffrage without having to vote o ot oot 0 against tile the constitution ile he asked tile the delegates to consider whether they coull could afford to thrown away thousands of votes that might be secured for the constitution mr air roberts declared his belief th that t it if the question should be sub mUted separately woman suffrage BUff race would be defeated il the question be b discussed ceope if before the people said raid he be and let us see it if it is in such a foregone pono conclusion that the people are tn in favor of woman suffrage ho he was vaa willing to go on record as predicting that th the putting ot of woman suffrage uI rae in the constitution ution would cost the litter latter thousands thousand of votes and render its adoption dou byul HAMMOND NOT ALARMED mr hammond Hamm onil replied that to leave woman suffrage out would cost the constitution thousands of votes ile he thought there was no dancer dan that statehood hood would be defeated 1 I believe continued tho the san juan juall member that democrats and republicans will ill not turn a col cold shoulder to utah sacs no ne spring chicken as the jibe was ras years year ago aco sacs she s a full fiill grown m maiden iden 1 I mean matron and b bow va and crapo and break the their hacks backs to get lier her into the union ir la aughter VOICE OF THE PEOPLE wr mr james said the a bould linten lii ten to the voice of the people de mand lm frig separate from all over the territory the petillo its for it had bad come the people deiv entitled to the privilege of voting according to their oan lodgment judgment itow flow many petitions came from san juan asked hammond san juans population IS 1 all here replied jarnes james the separate petitions col amr me without brine being backed up by br an continued on oa rue rage GI 61 SETTLED ITI IT continued from race PE 11 did they not inquired roberts yes sir air james responded then they were the spontaneous ex pros armlon slot of 0 the people yes air they came in answer to the cry that no demand had bad been made for or separate minorities HAVE RIGHTS mr klasel wanted to ask aak a question b but ut iams isms mos sald said the time tor for debate was waa slipping away and he could not yield any more of it tl continuing with rapid utterance he e declared that if people should a ask s k to have woman suffrage put in the iho constitution the cc convention n v antion would have hare no right to grant the request minorities had it a right to a vote on an such nuch it a question the convention hall had no authority to compel an american citizen to vote in it a way ho he did not want if lo 10 tile the opponents of woman suffrage did not want to have it choked chatted down their throats threats bitterness or OF THE PAST PART mr evans ot of weber said it if th the woman suffrage que question villon should be made an issue ot of the campaign cam ralen by fr r xa 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 II 11 I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 iii I 1 11 1 I 1 ai I 1 mr james spoke strongly in fix favor fator of separate submission means of te submission it would revive all 11 the bitterness of 0 the past the real purpose ot of the separate sub was to defeat woman suffrage have those opposed to it not the ra right 9 lit to defeat tl it it they can asked roberts yes yea but the differences ot of the past should not be revived lived re replied evana youil have ern cm c m now newt exclaimed X klebel lesel no we w mill not declared evans ile he said he be was opposed to tho the submission of uie the prohibition question tor for the samo same reason that he opposed a separate vote on tho the suffrage question quest lon that th at it would stir up strife I 1 mr wins referring to tile the a suggestion gg estion alloris lloris of sir mr roberts that tho pet petitions I 1 for separate submission were spontaneous read the following instruction from rom a slip 0 lip attached to the petitions petition get this filed up with signatures and mall mail it to your delegate lit in the convention dont delay A dozen members now tried to gain the attention 0 of the chair sir mr chidester was recognized DESTERS CHI MINUTE mr evans of 0 utah holding his watch in his hand band rose roae to 0 point of 0 order the time has haa now expired lie he declared there Is ono one minute left mr chidester hos has one minute called out president smith above a rising uproar 1 I want to soll ak the gentlemen who talk so loudly about Am amerlean Ameil eilean can citizens zens began chidester if the ibe majority oil nn this question are american aitt zera zens tic ile charged that mr james wanted the minority to control cont iol when james challenged the statement and insisted he be was being misquoted you malie make such assertions it you dont doat want them corrected replied chidester Chlde ster anc angrily rily the gentleman orlea cries out every time he bil opens his mouth CONFUSION AND UPROAR ur rOAn here the snivel gavel tell fell and the chair announced that the time set for debate had bad expired the short discus elan on had aroused intense eelene feeling eel lne and when chidester Chlde ster now refused to take hla his teat seat and demanded the right to go on closing the debate contusion confusion resulted numerous delegates demanding his suppression philp othera loudly called question question chidester managed to say eay that tile charge had bad been made that his petitions were signed by children but that there were ten names of children on the separate submission petitions to lo one on the othora and with this tho the champion of the suffragists subsided subside 1 VICTORY ron FOR THE THC tho ithe sell loll was then ballod on the he motion meelan to reconsider with the result that 33 32 voted tor for it and 69 63 against as follows lov a AYES AY US td ams il dl 31 oritz liz bit itan I 1 murdock of summit clark paire pace cushing peterson of grond Fi dridge peterson of 0 San Pele goodwin pierce green lob libuna lo buna a names hyan a ab sharp hyde pc james squires ur clevel slover love r keith strevell Kear ann is home ne lund varlan NOES KOES allen larsen ii ireen C P Am dorson ij a lemmon amnion mn ion it a yer lowe peter brandley lou lotta e wm win buys I 1 low call baeser Ia eser cannion can sion maloney Mi loney all fau ihan 11 ell mcfarland C oray I 1 monab arria corfman of beaver crane murdock Mur docte ercer cunningham driver bettra emery preston Pr citon Ra raleich lelch evans at utah hicks kacka evans a t ulber ul ber Rober robertson barr robinson Rohl naon of kano francis robinson of wayne vav e gabbs shurtliff snow flirt tSy hymo niona 6 holladay Thatch 4 heyborne slow ard Tho Thor esou IS air hea thorne horne i in thurman Thurm nn n john jonn jonnson non A borrum JIL jollay nill willii km kerr r whitney kemball mb of st lh late Wilu inu ariss lubert el I 1 absent of laeber lewis milter miller paired who would havo have aye richards Ai |