Show 1 instruction TO SO WILLIS els 1113 protest in caso cai Ss sas bained bowler xio citizen washington may I atio ako tko CO 0 o lovi correspondence has lin a a bearing Kirios tx uon api upi th question of 0 the treatment treat meat tat to be accorded the Ila wallan ciril enu isted v by court martial 0 of arco treaso aoi 1 tille rols of 0 treason and cf c persons deported lor for the same often who have appealed app paled to the government gover Govero l nent ment of ct the united states for or protection claiming to be citizens ot of country ciuni y the most notable were the lasts mes ot CC J 1 I cranston deported to ir and J P F 13 bowler sentenced to five years imprisonment and ao 50 fine in each of oc these casts cases appeals were wem we M made to the united states slates ave amant tnt foz or IM ilo tec lection lc cllon tion of state V C bob cb 2 S lt IMS A L will wllis kit kluha oulu si sari n be to ac L binovi 1 iiii ali x the iho receipt of your no 0 o A ot of tile ide siti kh libl it in rif lanon to affairs 1 lit hawaii and por w ticul arly in relation to the coreable reable to do de por tation on oil tho the nd lost of prime iron one ot whom A mr J trA nalon too claims to be b a citizen 0 of ih the I 1 ailed I 1 on en close colder ot of certain d depositions 1 amado r by mr Crans cranston tail on the luh anu and leih lath dinst betow bi borc mf vo uio the commercial agent 1 ol 01 I ano united tit at varI vancouver couver abe thrift e leano tho h 0 que lion ollon of 0 mr 1 r Cr WHon tuston s nationality nationality in in dau doubt el 1 and mr Iter a ahna in h astruc ted to obtain further irown X orn hm hlin on oil the subject aul jact under these tho the depart does not yuu you to make gny representations to govern merit in to alc cranston bul it II iti Is proper lo la enuresis to aou i ou tar your guldi paco hi a similar casks cases they tile tho views here entertained in nr gard ijiri to the iho course of deal arilon on fallen lu III that case aye it 11 ap altwarg alto arg that art r hattrup acon kept lit in jolt jail nearly a la stIvAl without Nit hout any choices laming been asade him he liuo then Is der a heavy guard would ki in ili spite oc at his bla to a gt earlier arid wo 1 request to lo two sva yon oil bv bless deported dapo arted finout having had un a opportunity then to do so had it not tan lor like acl ot at la a deneut but timely leu iru state bholi when you asked tile hie attorney general tinn all for ot of tho the III pio counes rs an paa lion hll that tho the cabinet caban l lira lica to deport the roen local it r the e x araso of 0 tile tha gocr ferr ferrod VY uy ax law AS aa paid was waa ta only ho he gate caio it la Is it t wa w ud ml no lie hao to and lie hn kavi gave it 1 I V f tuga ur tobt ht auy an question lum loii us oj to mr nationality ried bo be kenrid abna if tho the position thus r alim lw IW lit hi martial tho the vry very I 1 vf ei renders all aare cilles rv siding including A to arrest and nl deport atol 1 f and witti out any arca awon 00 other ihm tho tatt fact that tho iho pow er VIA it they may b be todil bilm ii roi fros LIMM rtin 10 ond and patch tl ti aay if be ot at their liberty and ile he bit boil may n y lio do dan cd tile ordAZ ord daiy LIY mi arll oil 49 e qt CC aw t tho h special il i without anun vr or on oil licar dittri art alto lily lit in tho the terl rim bd 0 allulli t ry t power to sit out such 11 it to pi yolon ail n in lit in tir the of 0 the to refute ic ardly ha y nil all ai th tile rl V 41 martial law can call in of tile awe ria worst t it a ink ul cs und and IT ed rapid ra tome low rh lt at was wai not V dmn and of the iho boram tho this ino the mik 0 the of the iho mik 0 cirii courts are rc in ill IA mt t or r laia full but in reason tire ilio cw innery vended bended then tl crib icinia should eatn kneir proceedings As AH lar ar ir 43 a siar a arntt 1 I d if by 1 th the pv P of f jun ui t lee ic lh to pama mi tapa V hod oil luci ifft feel recio 1 in illa coup is I 1 I 1 inal law lw ecal section on 41 1 i A in view of 0 what lic air bress yta I atod toil your our tant sra sr 4 loc coura jy by lh the ilc of ha catl lif aci W approved I 1 WL ini itri I 1 bervi Int V all 4 rise world lettjr I 1 0 at to ta elie haf bow lor il cains said ns jia a an foil COMM q Upa lowIt of k U D I 1 E 1 apih r S IW A 1 b I 1 tt f t 7 es 4 04 clr nua 0 nu N i ma 1 birj asel it sib dpn E on sa S of ihm bilat I 1 J E 1 JJ as uil 0 o 2 w b u tf 0 10 t 4 I 1 I 1 I 1 by bv it arn military commission as aon si sitting at ilon honolulu or participation 7 E or I 1 implication il callon jn carev the iho 1 hi january b or au and fr sentenced rr cd 1 hawaii tnt to am n at bar aird d bamfor labor lor five AVO and to 10 1 any I afine a ot of WOO I 1 tiler that he citizen now nos claims protection us AS mi an american ROLE that the hawaiian aul authorities norl F I 1 am bmw r rt that thai lie I 1 is not entitled to such protection t n h he Is it naturalized naturalised citizen of 0 that ME government when tar mr bovi bowar r left his hill country and W wont ant to hawaii does I 1 not lot adf appear car hut but on march IS icil he h voil voluntarily inter ay took look an all the constitution and lava oath to support 0 f the 00 Ha hawaiian wallan islando Islan dg and bear tr true ile to the queen without expressly renouncing or giving up hla his alien alleg lanes to the united states stales section UT M ing mis oath compiled iiii IA I iii A 11 ot of I 1 imwall pro idea that allery foreign r to 00 shall bo be de can d for or all 01 pur a native of 0 tho the islands subject only to their laws and entitled to their pro lection and no longer amonn ble to his native sovereign antle residing in the nor entitled to resort to ti his hl na mt live alvo country for or protection or in intervene tion I 1 ani am informed that tho the supreme court or of rall hawaii has haa held that tho the taking of 0 wo this antil operates to naturalize allM the alllen A nn rad admit aalt hint him to full it la Is not claimed that since itoi nir mr bowler bowl r ever to tile U rutted states slates or re aided elsewhere on the islands this Goen hab ban never hold to tile the do doc c trino of eg lance on the cc con n arar from its organization I 1 it t ila ha trial main n talked nine that the right to throw ore off ona natural aile glarice and assume another Is 13 not expatriation id at torney torner general blade black in includes not only emigration out of 0 one ones a native country but naturalization in tho the country t rv adopted as an a future residence rl dence the r he effect of natu aton Is to place tho the adopted adopt eil in n the santo relation to the th government as aa nativo the ra ricot h t of tho the Ila wallan government with hs alb consent con Bont sont to adopt mr bowler as fully nj if lio lie had been born upon its eoll eel 1 1 I as 83 clear as his bis right to expatriate him no wit L f lie he manifested his intention of 0 abandoning him hj american citizenship by t tho the oath to support tile constitution t and laws of 0 raw hawaii ard bear true allexia allegiance nce to the king and so 0 o far sit as known he manifested no contrary intention before bin hl arrest that oath li Is ip inconsistent cons went alth his big allegiance to tile the united instates states by takina it he obligated himself to support the gov government of his adoption even to the extent extant of jug its lt battlos battles in avent of war between it and the country of ills his origin 11 he could not true tru alle giAnco to both governments nt at the same ame time lima tho the president directs that you inform n mr bowler that he Is 13 not entitled to the protection of the lill states slates that on similar occasions pouted you win ill lie be guided by the vi cwm herein opre arid and that you furnish the min later of affairs with a copy of this instruction I 1 am lair your r obe obedient copl lent servant NV W 0 zoal GRESHAM R |