Show I 1 I 1 THE ORATOR I 1 I 1 scathing scathing 9 review of the the es 4 b by y carli Carlls I 1 s 11 leg I 1 1 defendants SHAME SHAMEFUL FU DEED noll r the testimony Tet of such a a man an not sa titled to credence the oaf 2 gions of the PiLls CO treated miss pollards demeanor Doin cAnor on 0 alza vi nods stand indicated chist she sh told tola the isaf IS af I 1 e I 1 11 1 as washington april 0 Altor ncy ca liale who Is more deeply ve veried M ill in lain III ter national law than in 1 bre breach ach of 0 P prom in jae litigation const consumed turned to today d day a Y I 1 II 11 the A criminal court tit in it a review of thotis th or alimony limony were before iho jury in I 1 he r pollard oil breckinridge case cam ilia his ell wa WM 1 a detailed review of uin d de livered in a clear dispassionate irnia inan tier nor although at tames be clawy or M berred to 0 o colonel in very vert ec athing but coolly worded tel the t glicr balfred congressmen dueled ducted himself very nonchalantly chilt chat 1 ting balli tilt lila his lawyers during day 1 while madeline pollard sat sal I 1 front of 0 him and kept hept her face shaded by a black gloved hand band most ocho time 1 l only once was waa there any Inter ruri can aud that was ft a lien colonel brock act ilia speaker right upon a point ot of family title about which lie lia seemed to be very particular all ali day the blo closest sest attention was waa given to the bleech by tho the jury aud ami hie file spectators so my abat there was adeep allence in the courtroom nr mr carlisle will continue to tomorrow morrow and it is 1 not that dint uio the speaking e will last until priday A C was is a counter attraction in tha of a bigam ht ao dothe the curiosity workers hanging hanEl ng about at ou I 1 ih courthouse were greatly enforced 8 DECISION ON till THE instructions judge bradley announce I ills hla debt iea ceolon on the prayers rray erg tot or instructions instruction li nine ot at the prayers of 0 tho the plaintiff were granted Errant cd lit in a modified form and five refused six praye ot of the iha dej de fondant were gra granted ire in a modified foran or subMit utes granted enal 1 l and five refused incidentally the judge jusef paid faid that while the burden of proof restel on inn tho the plaintiff toi to show that a conj con 1 tract to marry was entered into lf ir the he defendant set act up that tile the contract wasi wag not made in good faith the burden burde it of fit proof would rest mst m st upon him to show chere was an understand lne to that ef cf feet i ATTORNEY TORNEY lAT CARLISLES attorney calderon carlisle opened the argument for the plaintiff after calling attention to the disparity in the social positions 0 of plaintiff and defendant the attorney stated that all the defendants dolend influence acquaintance and family connections had beer been used to unearth things detrimental to the plaintiffs character lie he then reviewed the early 1114 of miss mio pollard which was free li om reproach until she he met the colonel ur mr carlisle said that all the ilia attempts oi N def defenso eruol to impeach the plaintiff had bad failed fall cil briefly to the en ell ilKi ment of vie the plaint Kt to william wiiiiam V P d i at invited the attention ot of the ju 11 a tintype photograph of 0 miss MIES at i A af rhe he ume time when phe first met ac P F kibridge kin ridge and said look lie ha iri in md then look at the plain I 1 1 i i ring how little I 1 the he defendi hits hats changed since then I 1 w 01 ii haired kentucky congress n ing the jury so thy they had no ti 11 I 1 it seeing him as toey they lifted 41 11 ll i i a an though pulled by it a BL 17 III nom E w up that meeting on the train when ra rast arai st the lives of the two came thor and when their testimony began tc it biffl r BI as they said bald the lawyer remarked ile he has haa told you that there was nothing improper in her conduct then nothing to alarm him PICTURED ahn DEFENDANT before we come to this rn let UI las insider who this defendant was ill was of one of the best beet families of 0 Xen kentucky tucky ills ilia father was wai a prominent presbyterian divine and ho was blessed with all the advantages which training and education could give he had bad great personal talents he graduated from college at the early age of IS in 1857 he was admitted to the bar in pad W he was vas roan inart led to it lady of one of the boat beat fan bantilles tilles in kentucky who early died in ili 1861 he was a second time marr rn arriel leI to a lady so estimable that here on the witness stand lit in the midst of the case he be not forbear a tribute in his voice to that woman who had boon been the mother of his seven children As lie hu told lold he was a happy man was beloved i li ills his wife atud and children he con confers feas that no 00 man ever had le lem excuse for wn 0 L lie did that no man has hag had burl gr er ater advantages that no voids could polut blut the depth to which he fat this was wn the gentleman who tillo met the schoolgirl m n the train RELATIONS WITH RHODES born tom this point mr carlisle turned ba to mr rhodes who was wa dead ho he imald and who could not be called the lettia lettis from pollard to him iw been read and disclosed no writ hint of tho ilia relations which br had to charge existed between them moreover Ala reaver the th description given b 13 mm alax brown of ills his character and of mil ills deference toward the young oil gill led been heard it was not extraordinary that she should feel alarmed if t rhodes attempted to compel her to carry out one alternative of 0 her contract con trait and nd marry him she knew colonel I breckinridge as the most lawyer of that section cllon so and having net bilm having been told by him that he be knew her father she aho wrote to him tor for advice there began beban the S secand cand stage of the controversy between them colonel kibridge hall had produced it a letter which lie he said she sh had written him site ahe pronounced a a forgery mr Cail Cat lele liale was reading the of colonel breckinridge r rb carding hn his first visit to miss pollard the colonel spoke up in a of the me concerning concern lne the breckinridge family faintly saying haying that bo be julee judge Breckin rlUe md and not general e THE WOO RIDS the lawyer laid strolls stress upon the re fe section of a closed cloned carriage ride from the seminary compared comi ared the story of 0 tho the colonel that without any preliminary ee encouragement he be had become intimate with her with her story of limons repulsed hla big advances of oc hla hill flattering longue which had bad been accustomed cus tomed to sway away large aun lences con can I 1 filled to nil an audience of one girl in 1 a I hark hafk the mere fact act of colonel the cain to uka take had died ellav pollard tile th daughter of it a ken tuck Y saddler Bad dier to t ride vasi a compliment and nd flattery to her arr the statement ot of colonel to staler major bloode that tho the first night lii lie hart had taken liberties with her person nemon and the geco second 14 he had slept sl pt with her her testimony find not nob with liia ills to show the alimony it of colo colona el l irtle was not worthy of 0 credence the attorney referred to his statements that his relations relation with miss rollard continued through Kli nine yearn alid nd has leen been entirely without love 0 or farci fascination nation a mantion so low that I 1 thought he would bf be afraid I 1 to admit it taking ilia lil own stater statement neiN L that tb thin hi woman was merely the plaything T of his pas sionA it doe not lot add to I 1 lill I 1 I 1 credit that lie ile should have taken such IL woman ff ib asli lalau th in rt C 7 t b to such buell a woman As aa mrs 31 blaich U b yn urn hw r ben ell chown n to bo be a woman a W alle ta b ar arter awu such ch standing such c rounding 1 K considering the colonel tr own civil SAM az 11 11 or r how lie he hod had deceived mrs I 1 I 1 acl burn durn a woman of the a and 1109 rom rain hin him own state the at aa rny aney tile the july to J illk whether timpy py could trust rust him under circum J E lal arylne ang aich puch valrhy induct induce y ants na for mm him to th the facts SI sha I 1 11 tolt TOLD tilt T JIB TRUTH ill ran to lo the 11 iti of migg roll aill on oil tile r ane tapa u mand when after two hours ft dinet din et examination she lidd lida been aji il d ton to a dagand day and a III halt it ot 0 craps c without being shaken on oil II 11 1 poni point it would be easy rr far I 1 tl 0 I 1 v f nh to talk of her aill ft u n bill only ono 1110 of oc two iwo con conett dt I 1 efm 11 1 ns a mini mind tr pinel by courts still nirl ox F ed UK oa a witness or as an absolute he heraper alnee to the truth could enable 4 p I 1 son to dry di ahls fad and it was doubtful 11 I 1 the former bious rold avail 1 11 sueh such in an ordral ordeal ir if one was not telling it I 1 I 1 truth n alg the testimony I 1 ot of sam su tit ah els 1 f and 1 I arter tile the of HIB I 1 M i while MIBS pollard Iolla Td wax wan at SA baym aiji ali carlisle Cur llala came down to PI 1 birth ar azof of the first firs at calia concern ing lne 11 lih 4 hr said there was not it a shado ft p r I 1 or of r ov avi n to tn cairn out the dw deft floida 1 I 1 s insinuations that ahai another aili lhnn on might hr be its father I 1 I 1 mr air Chi lisle had fird finished died altini lt ini tile hour horr tor for abard ed |