Show THE IRVINE hypothetical defense puts PUIS Us caso case ll in 1 I a QU question I 1 land it ft ANO AND ASKS AS TO HIS SANITY A great summary of sin nn absorbing caso case drawn up as aa a it covers tile whole ground of the alio demonb Defon sig tho queries asked eased on it LINCOLN nob hobt OOL oct 23 tho long lone and complies corci pi touted tod question quo ilton asked of medical ex P ports orts by tho the defenso la a tho the irvine trial la is a curiosity in legal procedure proc a as well us as being of great creat interest wherever IT no la 12 known it Is 19 as follows the hypothetical question we to will assume tho the coso case of a y 0 9 D man R a now thirty one years of airo ago 1 ills 1 t s g grand r an d u mother on lie ta thors side suffered r ed long ions from epilepsy and died in lit epileptic lit fit A sinter of his grandfather on his bl fot father bora 8 side bide was tossed for forty years sometimes violently so und she died in in liranz nono DAY lum A second cousin on ills fathers tat liera side aldo became violently bodane and died to la the lo in sune at mt lown iowa another second cousin died an ad Imbo ollo A elator of his big father was an imbecile aud and hla his father was vas subject to severe iou it at tack to io the iho head boad for years finally dying front from paralysis tho the young youn roan to reference Is 11 mude la Is tho the prisoner lit at the bar william 11 irvine lie he was born la in the of ohio roina roma lalog laing there until ho was about SIT fill years of ago after which ho a A moved ved to the abo of indiana living most 0 of t tho be time in tile the town of marlon marion ills rattler true u n no iio received a co common ninion school education with tho the exception that for three years ho be boarding school inbok boa about the age of IS 18 or 10 19 bo be studied law fur for a year but wits waa not admitted to tile bar on oil account of nun non ago afterwards lo he went oat into the abstract at marlou marion and ro ra in that business about the conr boar 1685 when lio lie removed to tho the oily city of lincoln state stalo of Nob Nub where ho he was waa yn till in the abo sent leal estate business and after a brief period of ehnis IQ in the ebalo glass business in tho lie full fall of 1888 he made a visit to tho the city of salt I 1 lake tit in tho the territory of utah alid and in january roc removed noved permanent nao cutly y to that city und and engaged to in the real el elmate tate bu business busl Loss lie ho li is a young man that hat has bus always boroo boron it a character above to ro in every regard ho was always quiet and peaceable always upright and honorable and add always evinced groat great interest laie rosl lu in the welfare of others la in lio lie was nervous aud and seemed excitable ho was our emilly strong in life his attachment for others lining bolas particularly devoted to la those to him by ties of blood und and in tensely domestic dom eatlo in lis hi taste was sue quo in ID ills ventures and soon after lis to salt lake city gained tile the of tho the people of that community to such nn an extent that to in august 1691 1891 he was elected to tile tho utah legislature of which body bo be Is still a member ila was also lu in 1501 1801 a director of abo salt lake city chamber of Q aad lu Is KC at present a director of tho the drink bank of cum cull merco merce of that city while living at marlon marion Ini indiana India flana nl in tho the your year or ISSO bo be bucario with hla bid wife ira she then holos being about the age of 15 yours old blu ba was vos TUB tilt FIRST ASI AND ONLY GIRL GIHL that he bo over ever loved and ills bis octlona tor for her was villa so strong that it seemed to possess his hid entera befog their courtship lasted until site bhe was waa 19 I 1 years of ugo whon when they wore were married and since ho he his has idolized her lit in 1684 1884 a child was born to thena it a girl battled Flor floronce orce or dioro culled called flosine Floa Flo sile ilc who Is now of the age aaa of 8 years with his wife ho be lived thero there happily in marlon marion until tho the fill fall of 1885 when they aboy moved to lincoln lit this city thoy they afterwards built a home bonio that thai was crocton on an 0 street at that thai hiroo both of thom them were struggling to work their way uy up olm in tho he world ue he was economical prude and od frugal sod nod she tho the same she doing her own housework to uld aid blui to advance both of theta planning and looking forward to it a almo when they could hivo moro more ot of tho the comforts and luxuries of life and when they could give to their little all id the flint they felt she dos deserved ry e d together they planned and built their home bonio their honio home lito life in wits very tory pleasant hid bla wife possessing bis big entire trust aud and conOd and never at may 1 wakening upon big bl part any ought or suspicion that bbb was otherwise than truo true to him their hoino alfo in salt lake city was also exceedingly cee pleasant plou sant und and the th confidence that he bo bad reposed in ills his wife to la the past wua was never broken while they resided to la the latter city they bad nover dotor had any wha whatever tevor lie ho believed la a lor her toy lay ally implicitly about the year 1886 bo be became acquainted with it man by the abo nime ot of 0 B E montgomery meeting komlo him the best tewo in the city of lincoln in tho the year 1863 1868 lie he became quito quite intimate with him they engaged in business together in salt luko lake city purchasing with others so addition to that city that was waa known as highland pork park white while bo be wu was in salt lako lake olty city in I 1 1668 montgomery metud that city and they were together tug othor moro more or less len during the time that he bo wu was there to that time montgomery had occasionally visited tho the house of irvine lit ID lincoln n at the latter latture 3 lari tation no mado made Mont gom ory dry his hid guest on many occasions occasional opened to him his hlll doors sell scaled hirn him ut at his table in asoo after iryene had removed to sit salt lako lake 0 city ty montgomery wont to the arco amo town and mr irvine and MB lis wife save gave at dinner party lo 10 honor of mr montgomery treating him with courtesy and kindness klud ouss aud and after that they invited him to their home frequently montgomery had gained tho the of irvine to the ibe extent that in many bust business netis traina niada made him bis big confidant lie he sought bin big advice und and obtained tits his suggestion ila was a a took holder with omory la in the samo bank la in this city tile tha german national bank in ja january it nary 1893 1802 the wife of mr irvine accompanied by their heir little daughter with tho the toi full le knowledge and consent of bor bar husband left it salt lalie lake city for the purpose of making A Rome somewhat what EXTENDED VISIT and relatives at lincoln and mabs lathe in tho state of nebraska tind and marion carloo la tho the state of indiana As already mr irvine had bad previously been elected a nicu ibor of tho the legislature of utah tho the session of that legislature commencing lit in january 6 and nd 1 thore thereafter after for or it period of kilty 1 dayal previous to ills ving lie had promised her ter that ho be would moot her and lots III child its ft soon after the session 0 of f the legislature us as lc it would be for him to do about abo middle of april 1602 learn log that his vitro was la in ill beaith by a 10 lottor t 1 r from her he bo made his bis preparations to J jola ol 01 e I 1 hor aar us soon us gujt it was wa possible blo it was hit his purpose sod and lr la so 0 o informed lol ormed her to snake with hor bar und and her bar dan glater an aa extended n ded tr trip 1 p n malonff 1 0 n t t taft h Atlant lo seashore dubore eu bore up p ending t th h or oreth e t b 0 a u um rn coor golatto the city of ati philadelphia and now new york along alona long island inland sound bound to portland and on up the coast to the village of grand art which ws wits the of b beautiful doom of no found it poe por albio to leave suit salt lake buku city on or about the tb isab of may 1802 1892 and lie ile la in lincoln about the of may previous to his bli arrival to in lincoln Llao olo his bis wife llad gone goco on oa to omaha where the ha had bud relatives rolat and wiser be b bad visited those and from othere aber at once proceeded to Sl marl arlo on oa arriving la in lincoln Ll ocolo full of hope and joy bin whole thought being byln on hill hl coming trip and little alio llio be grom test plou suro in mooting it bis ia wife ho he having exi it rodelf nt at sh salt 11 lako lake city jufa prior to ills that bo ans about to tako lako lite pleasant est trip of bid hl life that lio lie wits was rubout to join bit wife and ad little cIrl parl again that they would all lio be united that thai ho had bud tit til last reached a point whom they nee need d not worry over their floan finan caal cou tild unit und that elili hla his wife and the tha little girl they would repent their courtship days and snake stronger eiro tigor the lio affection that had bad thus bound them Pro previous 0 to o this and titter his wife led had left salt sale lake in looking through boino pa p pors in his desk he hb found count it place of paper containing the maluo of G C 1 montgomery in his bis alfos ile iio stave the tuat luat ter ler scarcely it ft thought thou glit ut at that time As lid ho stopped 0 off ff ahn train it a man whom he had bud known said to him 1 I mot your folks ino aDloe his vw ito and daughter the other day and when mr made tile tho in a its aa to whets it ft was learned that it win wai some time in the month of february on oa it train front from to chicago and that on that train was C E r that atter after the iho train had tuned started the iho man mail who save ave the information Inform Allon said raid that ahat montgomery proposed that they enter uio lite next our tied find somo one to ploy play n u game of 0 cards that in tto tho next oar car mrs airs irvlie wits found who joined them la in a game of cards cardi and CONTINUED WITH TO CM on to chicago this In format surprised biot him somewhat as ho he lad had boon in nation with hla big wife and ana she bad mado made no mention of having met mr montgomery on tho the train and ll fl tit ith no particular reason for so no doing lio lie ut at once rc called the abo incident of bluing nazim on u u scrap of paper to which toleration bas bag been unde and the n lila not gi belr virl 1 rise to buduo suspicion s pl c 1 on caused him tj feel somewhat du h isi t int go 1 u e mr irvine visited friends la a lincoln find and in tile tho to A to uell upon bis big cifes whom ho be had reason to taink was wai stop stopple plo with tile akstins austins in abt city who uro are intended to return alln colu coin tho the next city going to omaha rod to the austin residence lie ho found only mrs mra austin mud a youns young gentlemen present the rest of lite family being lit at chor cill unit ho he learned that ills alfo a mother hud bad loft for marlon marion the previous Thu with mrs BITS austin he alb tho the plon sunt visit that his wife nod had nt during tho winter whiter lit in tire tho course of the conversation mr austin aballo suld said thill that mrs I 1 ir alno on her way east lad stopped la in achl eugo that arl mr mother upon learning it 16 bud bad stated to mrs austin that her daughter had bad telegraphed her that she lind had missed the train traia and was thus compelled to stop over mrs airs austin remarked that she had told the mother of mrs irvine that mrs irvine had stopped slopped fur a purpose that purpose puri tuse being that sire she intended having a rood good time and thit that lor her reason boason for bo llovina so was that mra irvine bad told lod glicr ter that slid aho intended to have bavo a good tImo tina gound Aind stop in chicago not undine finding his big mother lo in law tit lit onitha Onial lat mr IT irvine doter determined ter tor mined to return to lincoln that evening but upon going down town found that the train had gone ono ind and consequently bo be wont went buck back to the austin reside residency when lie ho arrived aber 3 the iho people it had ad returned from church nad had were present mrs austin very soon hoon with some will awill Po Laning mr ali irvino 1 I havo been thin klog about what that I 1 told you I 1 do not think that add meaning mrs did bioc in chicago for tho the purpose or of li it iving a nood good time the cheso conflIct im statements lit 0 o cou can unction alt with tho file information given by the gentleman nt at Lin lincoln colu together tos with t abo b 0 feet thit that mr irvine had bad believed that thai hh alfo to passed directly dl through Clile cafEO alro sho she never hablo informed hire to tho the contrary raised a suspicion to lo tilt alj buind that till lailo must bo be wrong and ho he thereupon that evening telegraphed hor bar asking other things that sho she wire him nc at lincoln lit in tho the caro care of his friend mr abbott what hotel she alop stul pod ut ILL while la im chicago the next day lie iio returned to lincoln Llo colu ills wiro wife telegraphed ahna eliat sho she stopped ut tit the grand vanilla hotel this ills 1113 MIND to sonio sense extent and yot yet he bo could not fool thoroughly satisfied end aad in order to banish till all doubts once und and for lit all tsuio lie ho wired tile iho grund grand hotel find asked whether durloo fourur y auteen the dates earned mrs W JI 11 irvine and an daughter h had d regla ut ug that hotel botel no be then mado several calls upon in lincoln a and nd irk in tile iho course of this day stepped in ut tit th tho 0 gorman national bank and conversed with ith no that day he received revolve d a reply front from tile tho managers mann Rera gers of the grand hotel stating that they had bad found no such shaina on oil their books this contradiction of liln hin eifes statement worried him blin greatly er eaily had ho he informed friends that it wet waa noces sary for him heni to RO go ut at once to chicago ile iio arrived lit in chicago tile tho next day about 8 to la tho the morning feeling greatly oppressed and being greatly worried lie ho wits unable to oat cat but little tho the night before and was very re iglesi buted slept but during tho night ila iio bad wired ills lil wife to at ac the wellington hotel hold in chicago witch ho be arrived in that city boiling that there bo be dormo mis mistake tako ho he wont vent to tile tho grand padilla aud ad there examined tho the he batol at itis register personally ho he could not find ills eifes he thon than went to the tha Welli cig ton hotel and found that flint to ID to lit his telegram tel eKram bli bill wife was waa there lie went to glicr ter roomi she greeted him cordially and attempted to meet him with a w wifely italy kiss lie gently pushed hor her aside sa ying to hor her that before lie bo greeted her ber us its ho he would like ilko i lie ho wanted her to talk with him and wanted her ber to tell lim lien the truth abar does till this me ngeun she asked adding this Is a nice way to great your wife lie said bald to her 11 1 1 I 1 want you to give CITO tile me an aa account of your trip and to teu tell nio me the truth they sat down isad ibo be besan began describing her bar trip from salt lake lie said bald to berthat her that sho might omit that that she eho had bad written its as to that portion of her trip nod suggested that she commence com menco with her bor trip at thereupon his wife remur remarked ked that after Il leaving layIng omaha she toot met mr stull of lincoln and a lady front from omaha and that aboy played cards that abo train was lato and when they reached chicago abo wont to the grand her dutch nod and took a timor room mr irvine inquired |