Show I 1 I 1 A much vexed question do bided by audgo judd IS FARM LAND taxably IN CITIES P din mote court courar Allaro all liot the li I ip irdie p ill lie I 1 all reno co I 1 clora 1 in or of it 11 JO H iwert 1 bour y I 1 he firt edh d r ar I 1 rr V ri 0 o 2 Jrr ilef ff I 1 aih nit I 1 b c W wn of the 1 binkier bin tier 2 I 1 itow tun tiiu court aitio trul 11 abl CAU cai ton mn M n bb it for noi roll rv and from tono to 10 fluid lima I 1 boon given clvin it I 1 alm ilm h 11 lt t lil 1 buo teen abbet IA 1 noia it I 1 1 anve 1104 III lliel rl p nod nad 1 I b birc bait bad I 1 in old of jko t I tf f no ju I 1 I 1 am now coutont to abac ance L the he but in I 1 I 1 bin fw tay are to coureas 1141 J ault I 1 ito not 04 LT ac III I 1 die casos 10 0 o lliel nann CO banou nt in ii lah that mint alio town of nf 1 uproot root ta in sno sao ef carle cnally 1 3 na 1 ill 1 u Imn dar if a lit 1 b ty be b J n ro abnia laboo of igind fit apt or of atiat ill luil 1 1 I 1 1 0 1111 nd lint chat oil if ill tax Q qa ca lii F or hlll roil tito tim andow and 1 hi recording to in hie th of al fuchi 10 about I 1 wo find a hair ili aba iowa aull and I 1 it in for I 1 flingou farin flo inc ngou duj RL t Cullum lott I 1 jonir I 1 havill 9 bieu I 1 grivi blotted itla lUil lulo 1110 to lonn R lots tot no nud I 1 III no M as bic any bout 61 po pa forras far at alio ti D iella front moe included lu in the C ora 10 nov 0 ai to this court sitting in ID the state a ot n a the llivera to would baio hi besen no to u J I 1 and thu the conclusion vituld lia jim lie a elk kirtly to uia the court at lt 1 1 h I 1 m a am him to ID a territory I 1 act i no actor act of ci vt hod there lt 1 no ritten consi tullo n liy hy aich lite power bowon ue lue do flavor or fot in d 1 I binl in on MI municipal corpora none tad vo val Z 2 P frond oud edition the statement 0 of the law UH as bullon 11 lons T whre be ar ba inal 11 III s d or u a to lato total rural or agricultural imada which ingot octer never beo macd noo ire not net needed ir or toni I 1 lola a noa c I 1 a no direct ta mt from orviall I 1 to ania havaran hav arUn ling to to doublet such lands to in ruuno in 1 capil I 1 ma 1 1 T 1 01 the 1 1 lue 1 to be I 1 1 1 an abo to 1 I 1 1 r 11 I 1 not nol daru rUil d t but airl tt in ibn ah fotr OR F to ul fobb I 1 to a 1 to 1 tho m oi cupal ab that at bm ban ba in n ken CIA lucky ill ibo detcz 1 in blen ave tot load ironed in in loni iowa rod I 1 nell rooka and d d atje i del n bu iwo v denood t atiat h I 1 camle mil 1 sad bud laub tie anle tower power to toot point or line hem ber it IQ he net I 1 IF to the ilia proprietor ina jo municipal t point del it 01 af a rue viorel rule Is that the FIRM to sub lub J ct t y to coeur MU atlo D z blouir V M tin bafo and e rad it eirls but the right to tax nut mat mar wm und ly W property oc hu hiu tvr bw pl b attl id I 1 I 1 ahmo hmo exan lood thoroughly tb iho 0 chiller to abo ct front rolito d from iwa lubot b makin aud and from dimur 1 bud I 1 uial on no doubt lu in the world fit flint lite cw ertil As a of if them I 1 bre ai cad the cannot caw r bl orford vit ri la in 8 kofl tit nl pak mil S 83 lucre it ahn hot nC Tnt 0 or r tylnn war j iho for r pur DOS as i ardnt r lo 10 I 1 tor for fitter either atma or r or other lurix tn of a 4 town lunn and ioli I 1 if 1 bo iab ali e parrice par riwe a ol 01 1 ine aming its ir manuo it lit re within t 1 Q it me I 1 I 1 P r by aa wi pe berut Rut 0 I 1 theall it llma F it 4 seen mb a an ra ct on its iti raft faco only oolf or uch x ill 0 of 1 abc 11 ill city 1 att 1 lo 10 4 illy 1 absi 11 ale bill gioie m lhnn 1 1 bell to aitio IM caf 11 T to lax h 1 1000 tu a oaUt lile of ian and Is in a ile 4 g f private t I 1 T hou br be 1 I I 1 na aad ad ot 1 to ibb constitution I 1 in a a cit uie fore ami direct aad TIMP intent of the act to to ruth outside tl lands landi I 1 i city ta lation the pretext pretest of bawn l hoir tit alio protection B ol 01 taft claf 1 1 ort d ibb hotuj LlilA tur or oscr cooil laif fand da krisch Kris cr jor lur edba nl lk B no tools lor for cho net lh M of limit ol 01 1 a 1110 lu its actual u d bl br 0 bone and d u n in ft b axer alm o of t 1 1 I 1 tap b ll 11 al an indefinite n n it or of of mm fan m t ba lands and flroa PC nt a di sta an train from the ibo local Is til 11 it nill ill do moo timthy by an of t hom cm MM eal eai and ami 1 mory I oc of them rest t the he decan id lou upon I 1 that ll 11 fit auto I 1 the constitution which in found in all the jio of n the terome act tal states alnita ot of the amer item gro I 1 mau of that plu pr prop a iny boball not be taken for pa lutille I 1 lle d hout motion it il to IB exin nod meil in ID diff reat aftem but nil all run la in lint benr or intuni ag now jiow if this contri bit I 1 bave reworked lon iulo such bitcon it ii nod and 6 I 1 1 0 o 1 1 I 1 10 1 0 no don dolbt amut tar ali 1 11 of ih d and would follow them willi A till itule it ivar or bute are R r rd alj rj ft t ns I 1 ajl i 1 J ej Z h a ot joo ca af stint b ada UK lift is alic of abu more thau than tint thor 11 alto deat d eel along of the ibe uto court of ib U aliu ltd lt d t h ata are arc to lie lost u biu bat it aft iffe ehlI 1 0 or 1 it 6 but colue C ts 1 I kilell kIll LL low 1 11 1 31 an tu ace t afaf 1 lita court la Isko blut y I 1 anund fit 1 U 0 of cl like bul boms roms court or the citi sm staffa and III 11 aft 1 1 ihu I 1 1 1 bawor of kill 1111 1111 bol uart 1 1 11 1 1 1 11 st d a 18 a feel ion vici ibi wf we by rl tritt ikuo fur rabo alio llio I 1 find cifa exact point brulc i upon alif 11 1 h bb 1 1 r ILI win what tra rhall in I 1 1 I 1 tor or local pur 11 1 hl ili ratio of a oil ell 7 rod DI sub bub M mn v r met bud to p I 1 too to atie mt of fit own a 6 bail be as esl A c d of DB forced realty without IM due i I 1 rocta ct f U law bi b lt X tural collection ol of taxes laiva merely because brucw ID indi fl duall cw work hardships or 1 I L hunlen no tho rho anre abe A ninn own log olt til green f farming land fund bound e or of the city jim 11 1 0 I bur j action tor toreain eOIn I 1 the clerf I 1 ruin in in land collecting tax n first head ailef aft tufit bis propane had awn taken in ilo CT r the or it 1 won boun d n ca 8 and dt that I 1 it KW fis coling I 1 not at ll ll 11 attl 11 led I 1 lur or city cily jet om dot I 1 lo 10 a my any fenu I 1 1 I 1 property nod not 1111 1111 in oo 00 tat to corporale corp ampo orele M pao find and abat ala t attempt to 10 aho him ble without dout b but I 1 under abou tbt fah of to taft ton of the ih unita stoics and was nu a of r t tb it aoa apon that a U 0 tl et mm e C r Is ir in to 0 P pu and ibi iv it wu ald in tbt 1 l tint her the ilmond on 00 wh which illa ibid 11 P provision aunt of 0 abo o ct of to ahn va mom to t Is 19 chat u t abe ha aa load ad 1 in que thin 1100 Is s end and alna bail baa b bren e n 4 f lor 0 ra inam rm aadil or agi 1 1 u only 1 subjecting it to tor on I 1 lor con u deirl vw too 4 in error to or of ma his g midoux zy I 1 I 1 too d du C i franr ol 01 I 1 iott 1 hal it it IM id probably with troth train ahal abo lh exil bo mat ol 01 the blui hie of the land find for taxation 6 jointly crAt lr in ex of its value A abl b or not m cannot hm hem inquire we have hate w often docia dedam thal a na 6 cannot anterior review nod n nil correct e ditora and tolo tAkes of the tb ficat t tribunal rebur 20 on berrar alost sure hect that it Is 0 onar 17 be k cy to froe I 1 to abose without A or rho ibo argument on tbell iott rt but from the of the a into of to lb law ol 01 1 ren b by 1 br b r b jv rho arcu neill is I 1 atiat lar 1 in thu kh to iona am I 1 abe b 6 1 law itself lii IN in conda t orith the conoll 1 a lt hat lis li ibe ol of uie the bt ht olea ab anil and bior toa it eay it C li ellb mitch h force that imd id af pf 1 ch abin zt wl h tl ina li HM air owner e taa no not t ined oi into town lute lula b but of 1 idolfo let on manit ing to tor r of royal foria toIa and gli wh 1 11 no betm timers 4 an run con a or r bwl cannot ot bo even by t the subjected to the th t a of A c city J too natco tax the riaz fa C t ini bal 04 of othera her of at aur cox chano clatie tor ter the regeon lot this 14 I 1 uld bald to he b that oil taxes am for the conent of to aitio a la in a c chiy it who a own r itan the limits at inch unk mm auls all and abo hbo bo u UM or might a the them it they c chwe be orol v ht tilla 1 a he ha harbala reaLa so oo bell anti cus cose ft arf CUM cited from rho h bleher achl coa co cuarta A ol of K e and ruy jana iowa who to abl chet princel princ nl li af arlt 1 and store ill abone bouru bat bold that fairro rent jucus oil aji ft 4 city anra a dot 1 let to 10 to ibe ordinary cut city tabea 11 now afaf I 1 the b 0 court cotter it la no 0 pt ol 01 1 ur 1111 11 11 to a if lute if ifft abl I 1 b ib aboa 0 o d 1 I T aber IIA a ammi 1 kokh I ark arb be I 1 iman tho the citizens of a own city 1 1 d sailed boord no rom for carn ser the b of the ibe hollod and tod t e hold f fur u I 1 la ort they into rho oa SM I 1 abat a of farming in 1 jig proper by catl Is not not in ID violation of uio the nali tuten of br ton united buttes I 1 I 1 w wim lit led i to be of salt latko city against reported in ID 2 ot of utah llah III bul I 1 I 1 fount upon Is a thorough borough wading that this trave Is I 1 not lo IQ point and it jf t it were the decision ot of the ab supreme court of the united control atter nil all clue tho court li Is to como to the conclusion that it if has sought kuyat for the past mouth month to avoid that it I 1 IB so ao em cow without but due which uie a 1 of utah mut must correct but or the Vi ollda will have bavo to appeal to congress I 1 bellove bhae that jr ft this vea presented to lo via boull correct tb boull at any 0 raap D if 1 tho he i will coo kr of th thu U f luz Ul tie eft I 1 doubt dot that ln makreas mu irM kreas would correct II 11 IL tito the judgment will here to IN be for thu the upon lite hie fur bit taus I ifill jud judge 1 I wl vi ih h to note au all ex a X lo 10 a ilia ido ruling of cho bo court cogell cogull court rt abo exco plinn will ho noted J W JUDD J edilu plans boap teet teetered ered a bubul complexion |