Show I ARGUMENTS BEGUN I Utah Smoke Case Before Circuit Court of Appeals St Paul May ia 23 Arguments were be bo bogun besun begun gun sun today in the States circuit court cour of appeals Inthe case ease of or the Smelting company compan appellants against James Godfrey and others residents of I I Salt Lake valley Tho The latter secured a perpetual injunction in the United States district court In Utah the thc th smelting companies from operating their smelters upon the round ground that the fumes fume from the tho smelters caused death to vegetation and sickness to the inhabitants inhabitants tants Judge W H Dickson and Judge Andrew Howat represent the United States Smelting company Waldemar Van Colt Cotto the Utah Consolidated Mining company John A Street the Bingham Consoli Consolidated dated Mine Smelting company com pan W WH WH V VH H King is attorney for the complain complainants ants The arguments will take up alt all altof of the tile courts time timo today and possibly tomorrow It may ma be a month or pos possibly possibly sibly three months month before the court hands down an opinion in h the case cast |