Show FELLOW SERVANT LAW IS NO GOOD Declared U Unconstitutional by Judge McGall McCall ir in the Fed Federal Federal eral Court lom Memphis Tan McCall Or 1110 Q fed federal court today re red 1 t th Ln La fellow ser nt act was Mrs Howard sued the railroad corn pany for fOt because hel he was killed while in the employ of the defendant JUdge McCall aid ald ip In part partI I tm am unable to bring m my mind to time tho conclusion that the 01 a common carrIer or Its for Cor in injuries inJuries juries Is interstate commerce or com coin commerce merce of any character within the mean h lug g or of the commerce clause or of tIle con constitution Congress H Had d No Authority My conclusion Is that is nut authorized d under the tho clause e ot of the tho constitution of the tho States to enact such Huch legislation for the that the relation ot of interstate common carriers engaged in interstate trade or commerce to their and liability to them in damages for injuries sustained in their employment as the re suit of the negligence ot of any of its of officers agents or or 01 by reason ronson of any defects or insufficiency duo due to It negligence in Its cars engines ap appliances appliances machinery track roadbed ways or works is not commerce within the of the but If it itt Itero t ero r the act does not undertake to regu regulate regulate late thIs relation fir cr liability but simply announces b by an act of congress a new law limited to a special cla class s of those in interstate commerce |