Show DOGS DENOUNCE GE I II OSTEOPATH BILL I II I 4 Say Sal Bone om Setters Are Ignorant I I Incompetent and Harmful I I POINT OUT o GROSS FLAWS 4 CHAMPIONS OF BOTH SIDES TO TOt l t DEBATE BEFORE SENATORS Regular physicians drove horses and carriages and and wagons and thrashing machines through the osteopathy osteopath bill yesterday afternoon att noon during a hearing before the state senates committee en On public health They punctured holes hole in inthe inthe the measure large arge enough for a baU si a ato I Ito to pass through but did no succeed t I in killing it The bill will be amended amen el I h w here where its ite Imperfections were made manifest and In its altered form wl l j i ibe be reported back to the senate I Here are some of the objections to the i bill In its present form as lS pointed out ut utby utby by the th physicians ph R it p tS osteopaths to issue death certificates in gases eases which require mod med medical ical leal attendance as well welt as those these may ma be treated b by osteopathic matJi ads adsIt It permits the treatment of i ious ous disease by osteopaths without re requiring I quiring quirin any an knowledge on tn cr rr part pad I as to the nature of such diseases f 5 or ec C I bacteriology I 1 It permits the few tw osteopaths there thee the e I are in Utah to t be b the sole judges of I i I I i their own Qualifications 1 I It allows the secretary of the arc pic lC j i posed osteopathic board a salary oft ef f 1200 while the secretary of the mod med medical I i ical examination board gets only i a ear year i It places a penalty upon the practice of osteopathic methods by any regular I i I physician It permits the practice of obstetrics I I by b osteopaths who have been unable J to pass the simple examinations miJ mu j wives are required to pass and who nh j j i have shown show n themselves unable to tn t com coin comprehend I 1 the simple questions asked in i such examinations 1 It requires no knowledge on the part i of osteopaths of antiseptics antiseptiC use ti I or any ny other preventatives of blood I j I I It requires no knowledge of i logical chemistry or any other kind kina hI T f I chemistry I IRad Had Rad Say and Skipped j I I I Four physicians Appeared before the e i committee representing the state boni boal i d I i j of or medical examiners and the Salt Lne I Medical association They attar atta I osteopathy all aU along the line denounce deno un i ithe the practitioners as ignorant of even rudimentary knowledge of anatomy and pathology and declared the pass passage P passage age of the bill would throw the doors doorn or any other preventives of blood I of at Utah Ulah wide open aDen for or licensing hun bun un community and endanger many lives which might be saved sayed by proper treat treatment treatment I ment meat After having their say the physicians tried to leave leae the committee room but were not permitted to get away before they the agreed to return at 10 to today today today day when the senate committee will listen to a joint debate between the regulars and the osteopaths as to W the merits of ot the bill Before the jean meeting Chairman Murdock nad been told by b the osteopaths that the regulars would try to avoid a C them before the committee ommittee and askel the senator to insist that tbt osteopaths osteopaths paths should have bae an opportunity op L t the regulars who in tn turn were to be De accorded a like u imd ni loge tege True to the th prediction pre the revs reea r lars Jars made every ever attempt to get away quickly but Were ere not allowed to es escape cape je before they the promised to II apPer today The hearing ting this morning moM Bg wt witt W be in the senate chamber and ancl will wUl be one of the liveliest of the session There are osteopaths In this tRis room rooi who tried to pass aUIS the simple simie Uon tion required of ot midwives declared deda Dr Union Worthington of oC the med medi 1 l board They showed shoed the themselves hes es stu ctt stupendously et I ignorant orant of that Knole ee re which is Ia absolutely abs fundamental r the practice of obstetrics To perm permit this class el ss of men to t license UDe th m l to bring children Into toto the world wOld vo ld be e monstrous Some of the men meR In this t room tn 1 to pass the examination in anatomy proficiency in which i Iii t Jr boast boa t b brt t they could not do s st so Tey show shon they the knew little or nothing about th t the nervous or muscular structure of th tb body bod and even less Jess Ie about To them microscopy and b kno are sealed books These Thes men ha hae hac c done harm are doing harm bann and w will continue to do d harm if It they are li licensed l censed ceased to practice before they have th the training which will m enable ena lf them to paa pass passa s a regular medical examination tion Ignorant of Some of these the ver ery men who under this act w would have the power of judg ing lag as to the qualifications nee sa v for practice have shown the gross t ignorance H when hen questioned along th tb 1 simplest and most genera general lines Jt J dared Dr R H W V Fisher Isber When Yh n ex ox examined in the most simple way con eor Or branches of sc ft I nee in w whit they the pretended to have hae been beer trained trunca trun Q such ucb as anatomy they Senator Williams asked ask whether the physicians had heard h cf f any harm r Fe suiting from Crom the practice of i pathy UA A woman lost tier her ler oy sl ht hers hera in inthis Inthis inthis this city lately because se an ost treated her eyes ees for wo Y lM when a 1 physician could have ha ve ifa wi l her nil ail ailment ment in a few minutes md zid cured t ln In lna Ina 1 a few days daJos 1 d Dr Henry La LaMotte LaMotte Motte Iotte representing the medical cal t c so o elation and gave ho rho h victims na name naIl n so o w what hat he said could l he p verified rift d These men know knon only on onI cn thin thing declared Dr E S Wright chairman of the state medical barl and that one thing is i only a small part of what every regular phys tin rust must know to tc fore ur he can be admitted to practice hey rhey have no standing In the Ute scientific world worl which is liberal and progressive for thor they nothing but b t what wh t a science for over a tOO cn be recognized by t l C i 1 practice preset pros pre i 1 in the medical profess p f s r strictness of its lane lairs Physicians t tt I cates can go to may many ma lY other and practice but they thoy it would become known that l t X k licensing osteopaths J Physicians Use 4 It Is not true that physic an antie tie but dose and cut The r physician uses In 11 hi his ate hl practice r ris is best in osteopathy and mas masin massad massadin in addition uses u as all aU the met a modern science dence e has hai placed at poal P SI In many ma cases ea the ii tient absolutely reS rests s upon ih th some drug dru the tee of v e 1 been tested fee o oCten oien that it its i re i iare are known to t a degree of abs In ether other oases the tae us f I surgeons knife is bs ut lv for saving a a life An AD i a aI inot not the knowledge required Ired for fI i 1 I lug log such sueh cases case If an J to touch a victim St f appends i ithe the th appendix were swollen sW Den r t with poisonous matter he wo w o othe 1 1 the sack back and by s se wco the death ileath de th of his patient patie t who saved easily ay T the of f fin A i Ain in a simple Ii IiI I Both oste o and ana regula regul teed to appear In f fi t fort fore n nI t tate I ate nt chamber f this thiB ls morin Rr T r 1 meeting v e as s est eat attended of or aay any ee th I h hof of ot the tb session s ft as the tte een on r I awakened trem nd ns the lesi I |