Show OF o ALLEYS Two Paving Tax Suits Come Vp Up in 4 Supreme Court on oa Appeal App 1 A Joint suit involving the question WIther r the two alleys alley opening onto 01 street treet ar are private or o thy ehy was argued in hi the state tate su an preme IN me court ourt yesterday afternoon They oe care f p on an n appeal tr t ros Judge Jud Wil Wit Mam n aan C Hairs HIFa court where it wee Was held i tHat eat the th alley aDey y known as the Calmer 17 v run runa s t right bt angles lell north Dorth and ii west t of or the Ute Commercial block belonged to TI H L A Culmer The Tho second suit Involves the alley run C u in the th rear roar of the Utah Stove Hardware company at the north end of et t I Commercial street In itt both actions the tile I thy etty is made the defendant because e it Af j i e o pave a ve Abe Aba two we alleys alIen and Uld force ee and the hardware company to 14 pay Py their share of the taxes They TIley re e Isted on the ground that the alley be he Joed to them and nd that the city could a not DOt ot force th m to nave If It they did not j waat to Inasmuch as a the two actions Ion td the t pa same fame me condition of oC o facts it itI n I wea agreed gr d by stipulation between alt all pes to Make ate ak them theIR a ft joint a apPeal el to the state supreme au eme rata cow and all to o abide by the decision Of 01 that tribunal lb I p I I CIty ty Attorney PT George L Ny Nye and As J I f UIt City Attorney W C Shoup an ap p ear red for lor the city and Whittemore a k n for the respondents The Tho former argued ed that the aI alleys ys had be property of ot the tit city through grant ant which contention was w i i ny the die other aIde side I I I |