Salt Lake Herald-Republican | 1903-03-20 | Page 1 | Cuban Treaty Passed by More than Three to One

CUBAN TREATY TREA TV PASSED SY SYM MORE M 0 R E THAN I H A N THREE TH REE TO I 0 ONE O ON NE E Bard of California the Only Republican R to Cast Gast His Vote Against the Insure Snit Sin After E sill Ig ts 1 W C ti Notify ito M tb t T rt 1 March l After WASHINGTON W ratifying the th reciprocity treaty the Beasts te tellie sine die llie today at t Practically closed cloNd day wu spent pent behind doors in executive session Most Moat of ot the to consideration of or time was wu devoted the t h Cuban treaty treat Several pH b frt wre re made in la ts opposition to the tile treaty unit in favor or of It and aDd then promptly p 9 a at the agreed hour Mar 1 I o voting voU voUl V l ed were bad bd on number r of and aM the t treaty Wi mad made the u subject of an kY I and tind no yoU vote The TIM motion to w wd Wit looted it by a ballot bUOt of M 50 to li 11 II WI what hat hit I nor more than thU a voe uhe h vote was w 1 a aM only Of s ft ratification iary to secure immediately after the doors oon were i coed a few minutes past pilat 11 Poster Foater of Louisiana Louisan took the thet t tM M r tn In order Ord to make a set it speech in position to the treaty He spoke e for or about two to and a half balf hours bo His HI nd ad had been prepared carefully and andt t 11 i ita Ihl tt lonch lon Mr Foster Foter very WI gen gm en was wall complimented on OIl the man mn mani i ei tr ot of his hiM presentation of ot the opposition op Me t 1 of f f the treaty tty Appeal Par Jot or Home o o Industry In Tnt the he main hi hIs speech wa 11 wal an appeal appal 11 r i the th protection prot of the American u IJ ui I tr i 4 r producing He spoke r for tar the cane sugar u r Interests r but saId aid that while the sugar uK r interest was of paramount im Int ort ne e in his bla own state on account of oft the t h cane an produced there the beet sugar r n IJ iu tr had gwa wn to such luck l proportions proportion tl tIRI at many other portions portion of the Union N I were coming tOW to have a very i Iro ro rom m un ed interest in the making of su sui SUa u uil il a i r He H drew a graphic phe picture of pres prell In Louisiana and aDd saId Id J 4 itt Ill If It the treaty treat should be ratified th Milt was ws liable to be very fry disastrous t I man of ot his bI constituents Mr l I r Pouter Fter also a made the point that bat t rr as aa nothing to prevent th tha Intro ii tion of Chinese coolie labor tabor into ubi libit and said Id that If such he be Introduced American labor lalor uld not compete with It Grounds Grou of Opposition u ihei s in opposition op to the thet ti t I ta Ht t y ere t C Tf re made by senators Senator Berry BerryH H M nil nt I C armack and Senator Simmons of i N lh Carolina spoke poke In support rapport of Jt it ator Berry based baaed hi his hill opposition to tot th t h agreement on oa the th amendment alft nt of 1 j 1 I by hv the ae rl Th i M 1111 providing against any further re reh rei h i tion b hy by treaty of the u duty dut on oa i he h r remain in hi force td Ben Sen r i armack k opposed op the tty treaty on onu u ri eraL cis ing that It was wasU U II t retry to om our theory Of lIa tor Simmons was w the only t 1 it t t M w V ho hI made a speech PM h In advocacy of i r th o of ot the treaty trea lie II re rei l lal i h at al t some BOrne length to the pe h of z Foster declaring tie fir the treaty tr i t a ii of promoting friendly rela FelA relations between the United States tates and anduha uba uha He lie said Id that he be spoke for the th i n t t rd States and not for t r Cuba de den derng brn n ho hI h did not accept the theory t l t the I h UnIted States is la under ary arv II i to Cuba Cubs saying 11 he be t I iI in a I ue Wt w had done don all aU for tor the Cuban 1 hut h a r it m n r y y one nation could be b expected expect t d dI I 11 foi fw tt another But he that tha thaI I th t I h the t I hi h ratification of this treaty tt I uha prosperity proe be materially and that on un count account of the tM imp impi ed feelIng on the th part fu U i in an toward d thi this country our h t n fl to t cuba uba which now mount amount to 10 i bout hout h ut SYo O A O annually would won coon on j I He H said Rid he ha refused ref to ac c ct t p V t r theory that the tta American sU sUt u uL L t during industry would be in Inh j Jur r i t h hy adopting the reciprocal rela Iu Iut t i ns 1121 proposed ro by the tile treaty treat and ton eon n that the only Iy advantage Cuba Cubit ull have hae over the United State in It of sugar would be found h i i t t h D fat t that the Cuban Cu aoU aol I Ii some ome I v flat nat better adapted to that Industry man t II IH Iii ours our Vote Vota on A A AIn I In h of Mr Simmons t 4 Mh h NO In began M n The committee on i i tK r ig relation announced through Ben Sen tI i lr r t l Its Ita chairman ehan the tb accept t 1 e of lit tb two tWI amendments In addition to toU i U i already by the tom com TI I t The Th tint first of these was waa the he t in nt Increasing the rate of red n 1111 n n II T flour fluur corn meal 1 and corn tU Im i ni into Cuba tabe uba from fro the United Matt MattI S I tr i Nei Nelson n spoke poke yesterday in sup u rt 1 i pt f t an amendment along alona these thee t lIn 1 il ud i lator Burton Buno prepared pr the t amend nd ment 4 offered It provided for a thit 1111 or of 40 pr cent hilt bul the Committee e d i the th amendment so to as es It to t pro pro 11 hl 10 for tor a it reduction of 90 per g c tt nL nt nit l h uth other r amendment t adopted bv hy the M thern rn ml I I waa was suggested ted bv hv Senator tor Ha Un HaM Unu M u ind int fixed tl a It uniform reduction of t i r nt ft on American Amerlean cotton jo d im i rIt into Cuba luba The only aye and no i ro h taken on the committee amendment M u n the amendment adopted some t im Til ago uru b h th the committee at the r I th I h bet sugar augar Republican senator DIn i r against further r treaty trat redu t M ri n Huar imported into Inlo the vinn 1 for tor the next five fhe years yean or hUf i 1 ir It it tv remains In force fol A dIvision t called cull for tor on this amendment and nd it n itu u by a of twenty oth tt tN the vote b bd 44 for the then n nt Mild end S against It It tb t the negative DUve i r h twin cast t by Democrats The Thet Ther t I h hT r r i amendments in lI II t t pled today toda and nd the amendment r i iku the approval 1 of the entire ton eon contie t b tie 1100 to render the treaty ef d f I Ih u h nt tt then were adopted Strict Party Tots Tats After the th committee amendments a had bad ien teti the offered off a Ii an n of amendments but they were ld down by a s strict party n vote One d c r tha hee t I h amendments amendment provided for the k out of article C of the t treaty hilt tik ii makes make mak declaration against Ui th I tho granting of any concession to Amer Ameri i ui all t baco imported Into nto Cuba That arti 1 was wan left Just Jut as It was 11 when the thet t r rd ra i 1 V wan wa sent ent nt to the Oae senate nale The TIle to strike out article C 1 of w r d 1 l t h by ft BestOr ator was ras a defeated n It HI dl it I another amendment provid i tr r th t hI admission of American A rice rI rII rk t I itha shit i of f dut duty Senator tor Foster i at ite iteI l t I amendment t that I ir 1 at hall hafl not t go o Into effect eff until untila I 1 a I i the Chinese l I w tit f t th i States ates but it like the theM thel M l nerv i adment u met defeat Ben Sen Benr IM is withdrew his ha r amendment i 1 the nit States Statta s to Issue is an anUI n I imitation UI Cuba uha uba to enter Center she ibe t nl mil wi i 1 Mate Mat thereof but save gave no noti ti 1 that would renew It 11 wha the tIN tINI I IIII o 0 tJ the treaty should uld i me m ui up up h li hit he I next nt t regular The Vets Vote to 1 Th he nil ot tt rt wa was taken ak on OD th tile the motion otIen In t n ret h I u h tt wa was made mad by hy It Senator t allow a at i ii mot prevailed ft IS to M II Min jh 11 Ir t t in fl i till aa 5 follows follow H h th U I r Ulen Uen n An kit i Bu Bil R Hl tta H nt e ur I iton i irk 1 irk j Pr r I m ni It I e l 1111 u t Idl 11 1 i id r d k Jost r Yr Frye t toa Osa FleW Ration Hanaa ft H Heyburn Ho Holsan HopMa Kun I K n Later Lodge L LoU Long Nelson ebon Overman av avI p Paar Pir Simmons moot OOt Spa ar Stewart ewan Stone ton Warren Wa Wet I 4 ailey hard Bard rd Bate Berry Car Carmack CarI Carmark mack mark Clark Mont Mon le Poster Footer Ui La I Mallory Martin Money Morgan Mum Mor gait gan U Newlands Pettu Taliaferro W WIn I In ID making k the pairs pa two senators senator were paired fer r the treaty with one OM against It t The fM par pa list It h III a It as follows fO Kearns nd Hale with Gibson Millard and nd Proctor Procter with Clarke C Ark AIlL Scott and a nd Quay with Dillin end and Clapp elaW with Kludge sad and Matt ViaU tt eN i N T Y with Patterson Conn Coun sad and Hawley with Teller and Clay with Dubois Duboin u Quarto Qu wit Culberson Calberson Mr M Hoar HUll was waa absent abis a ad dd unpaired A When tb tIN the result had been footed up tn tb figures una I were werf announced uno from the tb chair du r and nd the presiding officer stated that tut a athe as ashe the he t treaty treat had received ved the necessary P t vote It U bad had been ratified Ben Sen Senators All Allison end and nd were wu appointed a committee to wait o 0 the president and notify him that If It he had no further corn com OPI to tet make kt to the senate te tate Ille Illet senate t was waa 11 ready 4 to t adjourn These two senators aena n the two oldest In point pont of ncr service Sue ice In the be nat Immediately their departure de for or the t Whit White house bouse bo hut but they had left the chamber whee the senate nete found Itself again In into o controversy The question qu this th tIMe me ms the debate dt on n the th canal AMI treaty t y which had taken place after Iter th the ea m of 1 reporters reporter should be PV given a tn tb the public About Ablaut an hour was w sped n this tha Ih subject b the debate debat being m meril f pa es cx tension teston of that of on the lbs saute same subject Ultimately the difficulty wa warn compromised by a suggestion made by b Senator Benator Gorman German that tbt all aU the peach should ahou be made de public but that nose none of them should hould be given nut out th le leof of Senators Morgan Morn and anet Cullom ullo which have hae h already been published until after situ the ratification of the treaty by bath beth the United 1 States and Colombia should beaM be lie proclaimed When Senators Senator Allison and nd re returned t turned from I the White house bouse hou Senator Al At Allison lison announced that the president had bad no tb 0 further communication to take tak to the senate H He thereupon moved mond the Anal adjournment a of the senate sent and this t mo motion 0 tion prevailed without division