Show ALARMED AT EXPOSURE OF METHODS Chief l Pauland His Subordinates Trying Tr ing to Stem Stern the the Tide of Public Indignation 1 Ii ij Description of the Black Hole Halo in rn the City J Jail il Where Suspect McGuire Was Tortured d ten days day da tr fem m the date ot of o their J t JUST i arrest Prank Prk Cline and Joseph JosephI I McGuire the highwaymen i i J were yesterday arraigned for tor their pre prep p ry hearing before Judge Tan re r Both defendants appeared pez pa pat P r Jf y at et t ease tase although McGuire was f pale and cun due it r 13 claimed to his hI experience In Chiet Pauls Pr criminal maker known In po polite i im lite m police poUce parlance u as the c t n cell coll and to the world ot of I j r crane as ns the sweat box bOL 4 The ThO storm of ot that haa baa haar baar r arisen aizen n lsen since ine Th The Herald Berald made pub Dub lic lb the methods used by the police i In i torturing the two mon In their et at f rt to extort a confession from them f i haa h s nearly overwhelmed the police poUce de ii Chief Paul l u and nd hla hh bl efforts to making I i rites are I theft lr AU All their en eni ent I 4 i t the tM hearing ye were t G tl pct l toward H discrediting the stories Oli u and McGuire in the q t 1 by IJ t e e f rt of ot stemming th the tide of ot public e nt that had wt set t In against the 4 t T Tn Tr Uley were we I z 1 1 tur Cline wh wee was on the stand I r T and hla ds 11 tate state t u rite GWen given to The Herald dine Cline es I whoa who but McGuIr ed oed the a Is a 8 c t c th the e la is I stilt still ill LII from at et hia biS imprisonment and und Ire kte b treatment City Jails Black Role Hole The Dl ek Hole Hola in which McGuire bread and water t a 8 confined on a tj t foi Ol six days and a halt half Is la lo 10 lout ut under th the police station tatton At the thet thet t tm m of r a flight of ot stairs leading 1 let i th bE basement of ot the station there thereSa thereS S t Sa 11 1 a small door scoured by a padlock I I ir f bind this door Is a narrow passage 1 z ll 4 ing ng to tc a door several Inches thick discloses a aB at when opened 1 i I tS tJ a door fl t f B f Jl ll it rom rIOm dug duff out of ot the earth Th Thi The TheS j e S 9 of ot thiS room are lined with stone aton t L red with wood 00 1 V 11 n len floor covers the th bare 1 1 earth crl t t 1 that is alL There Thero Is 1 no t fe r of ot any flY description d In the cell and andre 1 re so bed clothing When the door Is t absolutely a y no light filters into B a the tb apartment and no sound can cani earth or the through the solid r i cr cre door Barely enough air or ora comes through a af a purposes f Tv small amaH augur holes bored In tho the I door Jor writh W opens Into the passage passages 4 s v ay A There are arc no flO sanitary arrange I with the exception of o a 9 Un tin pall pail T d toe for refuse A 4 noisome smell email constantly US the nostrils of t the thee e prisoner According to a man who has wl vt tt 1 Ceased the imprisonment ot of mon In this dungeon dungen th when the irson who wh Is to toI I endure dure the pun nt ot Uen e and ana anada andi 4 It da t faB IP i fl av iII placed In this thia abde adt i the door dor closed QI on him It I does dOlus uati a o the tho thel Wm lAU U J JC m so 8 bad but gradually l f darkness and the te silence 1 U at of ot a a grave exert eert an influence In uce uces Jr h r him He lIe le tries trie to sleep but the thet s t 1 of ot blackness surge around aroun him b ve thought is Ia isto 11 1 and terrify him His next I It t to try to get ge OB om one glimpse of ot the light lih and nd for tor this purpose he ha gets down downor t or on lila his hi knees kne anti and ani trios tries to peer p r under has han been bean pro provided t the door dor This Thle however hI bea d 41 vided for tor for tor or the punishment would S J not but be toe if 1 it were we otherwise c Nerves Give Way The the prisoners nerveS nerve already drawn like fine wire by the Intense darkness and stillness give way par partially p partially E and al in a rags rge born brn ot of hope tal his rations of throws ii I nd despair he lie hi breed id on the te ground and tramples tramples t I them under toot foot tol the tho water furnished E lum follows cult uit and ns as n he ho tramps ui lit I and down the U n he grinds the i I 1 Into the foor tr and the Wa wa waI Wap tir tr converts them Into slime which I p add to the foul foulness foulI t I null i in a few tew hours hour ness ot or the air airI I I Then the prisoner ner assails assan the door and andI andI Ii I tries ties to tr tar out the heavy hevy planks un unC I C ti tl with wih his hands handa bruised bruise and bleed r and completely exhausted he falls fails In I th hoer fOr with a 0 broken heart het and andt t fobs bs like a 8 chIld Every Ever vOry ot of cour CUl courI I gt has ba fled 10 and he cries elo as a 0 child U tN T punishment II Tune TLe a day da ho he hears herthe the Jangling p aa tie 18 the jailer j lr comes mas with the thelo theao lo ao f of brOad bread which constitute rw hs U morning m and evening meal mel As he het a i t M 3 keep heel kep no 10 n track of ot time he le counts count tie number ot Of days dys ot of his bie imprison n ot of the jailer When V r rent by the th tripe trip trip ler Is t 1 door dor is opened to admit admi his hia keep keep 4 B t the light Ight blinds him hm and end he lie is 15 isI I I r rr rid pd to over cover er his hla fac taM face with wih his hi hands hands i L ore his hi eyes es become beme accustomed to I Jr th light the door ia 18 1 shut again and H he is 1 deprived of ot Ui t the chance to see I tie light for tor on one oce KM glimpse ot or which bo ul uI had felt fel that he be W ok W his bi This s Was hate Fate ate 4 Into such uch a place Joseph Jos ph ii iiii I v thorn a preliminary pee heaving or a 0 ato to t BW sea friends a man pro pre pr tumi J by b the law low to be b Innocent nt un unI ii I t n I proven guilty was thrust by order cl ell C Chief Paul PaulS S For Fir six six and ad days das he lay In Inthis Inthis Inthis this noisome hole without once see seeing ing the lace face ce of ot a 0 friend When Wian en he felt feltI feltt Ig I t t hla his mind was about to give way nf r rIt I 1 L f t came carne 11 ie police officiate om admit that the then I 1 rI T n fl aa a kept there th for tor that tha length it C tin mt and ad aR that he wa wae Wa fad tt on Of bread bd a i 1 Ht r and they te Rive give as a season In 1 1 t f It t that It I an was feared ter that tat if It Cline Clime k it 1 were e tos toger together th r i I t would woul eo Hnot c et some ome me story which 11 hi 0 ht tit defeat df t the Ue eada eads of o Justice jul They t a that hat t th ther thees r was wa no place piece In the tb I ei J i hr leHI could eul be kept from fromI t I ru n so s they th wr w were r compelled to i hm fr m in ts the Black lc Hole Hol under the ther te r I 1 d i staton They The did Id not offer eUe any aDY cf f a as to t why wh they found Jt It i r astry to deprive him ot of o b b bed d cloth clot l S And to t teed d him h on em O broad and andr andt an r t The TI assumption that tat he was waa wast waat t a I 1 there the to wring wl a confession cnn c I t n him to Ii Indignantly dented denied enl by b the thet U Ut t it ie department nt Crockett TOIlS Tells of Holdup v c E Crockett the alleged victim tm of ot oft 4 t M Muire and Cline was wa th the first frt wit witra n r 19 ra M for tor the state In the hearing hering yes i t He toW told t K a 1 straightforward tr for fo the t most m part although the thed thelo I lo d ie u e record rn introduced as as evidence eldene I t I Iu tight ht forth tork a discrepancy d In the tM 1 1 t I ft r at t which he be alleged a the holdup t I K it I place plaN H kl Ht that on o the night of oC Sept 21 j it I 1130 13 oco h lie wan wU wa held he up and andr r ti o u by the th at att atthe the corner I c a i ath South Sout and a Fifth Fth TVa West t streets i I Ic If 1 w Wi WO x n as to the t time lime limet 11 t I 1 l ur 1 he 1 that f bf J t I f X it I took to he be had haa looked loke at ati i l 3 r watch and ad pe it waa m sis then tle 1 o l li i H v stated tte that he had bad had noticed notee the themes men mn tOH him Mn hm from tram Fifth Fitt South Sout street stet and that when he got to place where he was robbed one of them called caned to I him asking If I he be had a 0 a match match He and was answered In the affirmative ad turning to give them one on when the tallest one pointed a revolver at him and ordered him to throw up his hands hands The man with Jh the gun he said was six feet fet away AWa from him and had bad his hie hat hot pulled pule down over his eyes The Th nearest electric light was about twenty ty rive feet teet away When he complIed compiled with wih the request he said seid the shorter one went wont through his pockets taking a watch tah and Jl t 1 In money and then directed him to tc hike up the street He did BO so 10 until he reached the power powerhouse powerhouse house where whre he told the engineer in charge of ot the te robbery ry and afterwards I telephoned to the police I Time of the Robbery On he be admitted i that It 1 took him five minutes to reach reah the he power house and that possibly a aW afew I W tew more minutes passed pa se during the tUne time he was telling the engineer his story Il telephone message mege was was re d at the pollee plC station at nt 1120 oco tan tp minutes mInute according to his hi time before the took place Although Crockett was ws able to give a a description d of ot the complexion of ot the themen themen men and the color ot of their hair with their heir ther hats hat pulled pull down over their eyes h he ie was WRE usable unable ulab to tell tel what hat color their clothes clothe were were but hut described the hats bats which they tey wore When called caled to Identify the men at the police station he said Mil both men had their hats and coats on He admitted visiting the the tb city Jail jai on Wednesday two days after aler the Identification with a a friend frIed He was shown s own over ovar OV r the Jail jai and saw sw dine Cline Clie but tut did not see McGuire who was At lit t that hat tat time Incarcerated In the dungeon below elow the police station staton which Is not open to public Inspection Officer Parry Earry who made the arrests was as the next witness wine for the state He told old of or arresting the men In the Com Corn Comstock stock stoK saloon about 4 Monday morning dine CUm told him he had been at Liberty park prk seeing some Bore friends and md McGuire did not say 18 where he ho had been The prisoners had 5 I cents In tn money and three letters leters on them the when arrested The state stat rested at the con eon conclusion elusIon of ot Barrys Parrys testimony mine Cline on the Stand Stad Frank Frnk dime Cline one of oC the defendants de was then placed pl eed on op the stand He I commenced his hi story stor by saying that on oti m Saturday night he ke he and a man named i Redmond had met the Hayes sisters at Calders Caldera park prk and had arranged to I meet them on Sunday night nigh at S 8 at Second South and Main streets He and his companion were I there at the time but the girls were not there so they tey started toward the house douse on West Vest est Third South street On I the way they met McGuire Continuing their walk the te three met Mable Mahle Hayes and Lena Lna Smith who were coming In search searh of ot him As A I engagement was with the other Hayes slater sIster Redmond and McGuire went off ott with the two girls dIne Cline walked around arund the streets for tor a awhile a while ana anS an then I met McGuire McQuire near ner the Lace Lac Lc House The two went over on Commercial street street and walked down It I when dine Cline tore his trousers In striking a match and McGuire suggested that they go up to the rooming house adjoining the Star gambling house on Commercial street and borrow needle and thread with Ith which to repair the rent This he said was sometime after aCer 11 1 When they got to the foot of or the stairs tune eUne met a man named Shel Sheldon Sheldon Sheldon don with wih whom he talked until 1145 r I I McGuire MeGuire In the meantime had i gone upstairs and dine Cline followed him I and mended his hl clothes A card game gme was In progress when he arrived at the I rooming house but not feeling well he went out and walked around a awhile awhile i while after which he returned to th the I rooming house and the card eard party pat staying there until after ater 2 when the couple cuple went to the Comstock und and sometime afterwards were arrested Sticks SUcks to His Kis Hs Story Stor At this juncture Assistant County Attorney Loofbourow who conducted conduct the prosecution suddenly changed his tactics He lie picked up a n copy of Qt yes yesterdays yesterdays yesterdays edition editon of ot The Herald Herld and be began began began gan reding reading It I pr paragraph ph by paragraph to the prisoner asking the witness it if ithe I he could controvert certain state statements statements ments attributed to him bim In a n published Interview He strenuously endeavored to have haw the defendant say sa that the pot por portions pr tons of ot the Interview which related to his treatment while In jail jai were false but in tn this thi he was wa unsuccessful dine Cline would not say s that he had used the Uie exact words which hleb appeared In the Interview he h persisted In his state statement statement ment mont made therein that he had been ben denied the means of ot communication with wih his hla friends tren in Victor VIetor and that he had been denied an attorney He said Mi that Jailer Sol Kimball Kimbal told him that the chief had ordered that no telegraph blanks writing paper or pencils should be given the prisoner and that he should not be permitted to see an attorney An attempt was made by b Attorney Loofbourow L to have h havethe vc the defendant deny that when he told his story sty in the chiefs chiers chiefs office Detec Detective tive Gl spIe had told him he lied led and that he h t was wa a celebrated eastern crook tk Cline 1 In again agin affirmed arme that these were words and added that Gillespie told to him he was wanted la th t the east eat Tot Tor tO highway robbery and andt that t he had hd been b furnished his description tion U and a told to to look lok out for tor him Sneered at nt By y Police He also al said s that Ut when he had fin finished fn l e his kIa JI story the tIe persons present in inthe InU Inthe the U chiefs office oice o sneered ler and that tbt when asked ake tt that he h be H allowed to send saud se for Jor or friends he was told No Xo you are Ir in I here M and an see M friends fonds Attorney Loofbourow Lor then asked him himI if I it I MS not flOt Bt true t that tt the police pollee JUe had brought b t three friend tle to t see se him in the person parSOn prOn of e f th the Wilson girls Cline said sad they te bad but he had not nt asked aske to see se them as he bad hd sot not Rt seen n them on the night of e the robbery and they could do him no good Several other state statements meats ments Immaterial in character which were attributed to him in the newspaper making per pr le Interview I Clime Cie did not remember At the th conclusion of ot Clines crose the heating hearing was adjourned until 4 at which time It wee was Wl again agla continued until this morning |