Show Will DECIDE f AS TO TOI I INCOME TAX to Senate Joint House H 0 use Agrees Resolution by an a Over Overwhelming ver whelming Majority NEGATIVE VOTES ALL CAST BY REPUBLICANS PAYNE FEARS WE CHAIRMAN AI c SHALL HALL BECOME A NATION NATIO N OF LIARS July ii By the decisive Ive Ivet H 14 more than the 31 37 10 O e ot t ed hnis the house hoWle hoU today pu tT tr tW resolution resolution providing for Jo int ff nat of the income tax tX Jb 1 the tati tat The n negatIVe B votes tes test t t i to st t by Republican Republica The reS reSo re o al I fl fn goes to o ike the president nt for fot his hison on 11 f I atu tasted lasted shOUt about four hours hoars bourse d bate e payne of u the committee on rma means voiced the sentiment Bt t Ii U a h a ux tax wo would uW make a nation n If the th Democratic d of iteal simply a cue case t it t was thunder although h some r marks on that side incidentally te f A d upon n i the tariff and the corpo with no IItti amount of cas CIUI ui laX th the for falling as asaH of 0 tn n aH gd I to keep party t pledge it tEr r grUns ng to take a vote rote today at loo ock on ln the joint resolution pre pro fan on 00 the resolution re 1 E I ring r an the levying of ot an Income tax rii 5 o 0 apportionment among the VI rl raI the house hOUM proceeded to tois is the th proposition Payne Against It r Ii it tends to make a nation liar ar declared Chairman Payne Pyne in nation with th a statement that he be was riy opposed to such ucb a tax in times it the most ne d re He believed was tilt uit of enforcement and nd the hardest Jt It is i in a word words he said jr iz upon UP the incomes of honest not men m n 4 di aa x to some extent to the 4 it would never liever be invoked w r welcome the conversion of the Re Rean Rejan jan an party to another Democratic ciple the comment of Mr Clark the minority leader who got tag e from his side J de of or the nr for his hi utterance An income lucerne T h was a Democratic ml oie One by one the roses rosee ro eM fall fallS dd id addressing the Republican side aide ci 1 on b by one you adopt our plat platHe platH He H concluded by expressing him in n favor of or Increasing the amount above 00 TP In led ed him Into a colloquy with Mr Yr rk rl r of or Ivania How far above and why Mr olt to ell i 1 would fix fiz whatever figure e I did t lor tor the public good aa answered Clark P n being hing pressed to be De more mMe specific ark said he would want to think t I matter pr Would Exempt Poor Man daring that if the question q on had been t 11 him Mr fr Clay Cla Cayton ton tOft Ala said Mid he be hed id d rl mI t the poor Kan uan n who was wast t able to 0 br br r the burdens borde of gov 11 nl an nd l Would tax tX the i l s sand and thereto th hy make the idle rich pay to the support of the federal would oud he claimed amid mid Democratic u get your lour Willie WHile Waldorf As C who have haie millions of income and anda a in m the light I would get LaIrd of or Skibo or o kebo or what r YOU vou can call it Hobo a on the HI Republican side h berd ard to 88 scorn said aid Mr James of Ken Kenn n Y m In favoring the re a gov tnt nt hose taxing power provides Lazarus shall shaH a 1 share his hill crumbs but butr DIns must mast not give up his riches r J Jams m b quoted from an as II h in m which Mr Taft favored u income e tax ta and expressed that at perhaps a change chaap in the thet n i of the he United ted States supreme q t HH m g ht ef a reversal eversal of its It for holding ng th the income tax un tin c au d Blan an for tor r that he hehe he tl Republican T side aide You ty of 18 thO Bailing assailing autin the honor and in ini supreme court yet the thi thih 01 0 i te to the ta h e nation tot statIe aon y repeated the very Words ds that at for or twelve y th the te r tI red party part art m in every platform had Fear of Defeat I IP r rc ra a the c amendment T Mr y t Suffer x ed the fear that It It Ur del e if luu litUre to the ther r f e d 8 red to Jw ha have ve e th the e prop t 0 coo con conle Mr r B I le Bartlett Barte Ga Oa shred shared Id Ida h ha a fiert fien tax ta r h I In n ot of an In 0 Inson Ark arral I ans for as he pepe b f fore ore the last He H at an th e efe William J 3 frs ers a he atoj head ani above tOday Oday an Y oth other 0 met maR In public Iere re arp men h he Owe William 1111 Y Bryan an apol rs sun N the resolution re were L r k Kiefer 0 Hull HuH holdt to n Sims StIne Tenn TennAla c Ala sui fla Richard Tie De A m n r Y N i I Sha Shap oY 0 oR Ma Ala Cox 11 Coh 01 0 j ticker Mo Dies n Ala Als and It Conn and by PI c k ett Ia Speaker Sustained IT T 1 vainly sought Ought to of on of tI nent providing for the sub subal fal al COD ons but through the speaker Continued on o Page Pa 2 i k f STATES WILL DECIDE I H AS TO INCOME TAX Il i Continued from Page 1 I ruled that at t under the agreement fer for a vote I B He amendment dt was in order From Prom that e e JIT Mr Mi Henry appealed and one BUC needed In forcing a rolL rell call can The vote vete I I It resulted Yeas W i na nays IU sustaining fj the E speaker ker The vote on th the resolution resulted hi In yeas to li 14 nays nal The Democrats voted t sulkily solidly ii for tor the resolution but the I Hewing Republicans voted against It Allen Hf e K r Md McCreary I awl Wheeler Pa Pa Fordney Mica Itch I Gardner U McCall and Weeks Veen M Mass aa Hm H and ad Henry Hery Conn Coon Olcott and nd South j iI wk N K Y T and nd K Knit TN The house at b Po p m at adjourned until |