Show J J frH fIGURES p ES ESIN IN NEAR SCRAP I in Industrial Indus rial School Sc ool attorneys AU Investigation Reach Point Where Blow Is Aimed w WI th first day for the de deJ deIn tt State Stat industrial school hives taves In InTI J In n th Ih The TI rda between Harry S Sami St t ph awl ami h attorneys att became so ao a a most to lead 14 to at t the theof th thc of ot th morning moll nc session From Froming c the t hf witnesses for the pro ecu ing ha jumped to the J taking S Of po witness Wit Itne for fOl the defense e ab b WIn wing He lie shows boWil re reble rebe ng jr ble be his l for the welfare elf and aDd of ot th Thomas witnesses Aside tort the he at the close c of the thein session the features of ME the dX daX da in B Evans tile of Thomas Thoma reI had furnished groceries that t ha t he hI s all the th time he lIB was wall trus truse to it t is III alleged of the theIa In h e and the espousal ot of the th Ih stat gut open Ia law Dale teacher of the larger boys boym bo b wre and general corporal 0 of than the school has baa yet was made on testimony in behalf I tilt th accused Kd and before the noon DOOD re 1 0 of witnesses had bad been examined tOUT 5 T D Johnson at ator ud cross w for fo or Superintendent Thomas an tamer that hT hI he hoped to complete his hise h e of the e evidence by U h tonight tap SIp Wa Was W heal al Kind John A Hinson ln of Salt Lake City in instructor m rn th tI carpenter shop bop from April last year was the first He s id d when he entered the witness i the th in fit the earp Than hOp w wa a poor VOr and the boys boy poorly poor taught u H described de Thomas Thomaa treatment of the thetYS Mil tYS O as SS real kind One boy stole tole a mom or two tW of butter hutter and the t d it 1 1 him it was not a nice way ii tI art act The other officers as a ruts rule were good god and kind kindOn On n said aid he be had bid never seen punishment administered He H saw nw one hot boy In n a cell ceiL He lie saw aw Kr ler lerI I m tit the Ih Orgon boot II lie He wore It j 4 II detail but hul lid dill not work he wore it Itin II m in th the dining room in the play room and andi i downstairs On Bacons Bacon back baek when he heit saw it lie said was Wall a circle discolored t t he ht still insisted insi that the skin in was not broken Mar lIr ry Dale Dalp teacher taher of the higher grades radea department since last lut Sep Sop September nr tIT r the bo boys bors s said she he h taught ta ht for six stoc years yean In hi Inthe hithe the th Whittier State school near Los Loll An AD AnKH KH 5 one of ot the Ih reform schools In Call Cali California fornia forni where whre there were boys She the th punishment in the Whittier school as much more severe ere than in the 1 tub nab tali school and along alone the same general HDM In whipping the paddle was Wall used but hut not DOt the thC strap The Oregon boot hoot Was wag won u high as six months I sometimes it Itu wai Cu u worn om in m the cell where the offender wu was kept as high as four week on bread i ij j and oter J HUE Ilia Mm Dale Dile siders on the punishment In Int Inthe t tilt the I nh tab school much too light and the j mm muli h too lax She said Id severe ra t Is absolutely necessary in a 1 of this thi kind kindOn kindOn On cm ros x Miss MIl Dale said I she had bd never seen MeR severe vere punishment punt ad administered administered ministered Edward Bischel 1 manager of th the Utah Pickle A Vinegar works testified that he had bad furnished the school with ith syrup since January 1 I INS some ome six barrels barrela at W jO cents oen a gallon on contract This Th ThIs Is I made of glucose 10 per cent sugar and the balance water It teethe the same as aa is I supplied upp ed the trade It te Is now selling for 6 G cents because of the high price of corn It might turn tarn sour but buthe buthe buthe he had no trouble since January 1 I Ills His Ht factory was w not condemned and closed by bythe bythE bythe the state te food Inspector Hy Olson a II bo boy of nineteen from Salt Lake City who had been in Ia the school from fr m November 3 2 2 1907 to June 22 1908 who is III now out on parole working in the carpenter ter shop of John Joltn A Ivinson Ivl said sah while wh in the school he se did what he was told to dp d and as a a was made one of the best beet trusties in the school after he lie had bad been there three days day He waited on Superintends Thomas In his h dining room and always sat t at his hi table taMe although there twe ere other boys in the school Just as asgood a asgood good as all he be was wu There never was ws any partiality shown bown all boys boll who did their duty were treated trel all right by everybody Hollingsworth Swings at Agee The incident of the day came carne near the end of the session Mr lr Gideon asked young Olson why he was sent to the school This brought a roaT from Harry Joseph He reminded the lawyer that this was wa a reformed boy and he did not propose to have his past raked up He read the attorneys a severe lecture along this line Judge Agee took exceptions thins tio to the words and manner of Mr Joseph Jo eph and wondered why he be did not re remember remember remember member this rule in the case ca e of King and other boys boya Much heat bet was shown on op both sides side Mr Gideon withdrew withdraw the question when he could make himself heard beaM in the uproar After adjournment Judge Agee tackled Mr Joseph agate again as 88 the men were passing from the building Joseph repeated what he be had bad said ald Judge Jud Agee told him he be might intimidate the t women on the committee but he be could not Intimidate him and he proposed pr to have his hi rights He lie shook his bla flat fist under Josephs Joeeph nOH and became beeam much excited Charles Charlea R It HolUn worth broke in be between between between tween the men and insisted that Judge Ag AS Agee e be a gentleman He lie H was told by bythe bythe the Judge that it was W not his buttIn and andas andas andas as the tw t tue were pulled apart Hollings Hollingsworth HollingSworth worth aimed a blow Mow at the Judge After this the excitement subsided Heber Robot was the first finK witness of the afternoon session seMion Ills His HI testimony was WAIl brie He said the quality of the goods bought from his firm at wholesale wan was above the average of that tbt furnished to railroad contract 3 d s The coffee was supplied in barrels and was a grade 3 cents cent a pound above the lowest As A to currants he be said they were bound to be become become become come wormy unless the dirt upon which the worms feed were removed George H Shorten the sanitary leaper Inspector tor said Id he had often visited the build buildings buIldIngs ings and found them sanitary and nd in first class c condition He ordered OI the casket of Robert Turner sealed and not Super Superintendent SuperIntendent Thomas and he would not permit permit per permit mit Mrs Crosby the boys grandmother to see lee Vim RIm Im because the boy had bad died of ofa ofa ofa a malignant case of scarlet fever He heard Superintendent Thomas Thoma speak very kindly to Mrs Irs Crosby on th this occasion Teacher for Thomas Lulu Edith Mitchell who is i now matron and lid music teacher in the girls depart department department ment mont said Aid she had taught In the public schools of Reno and Ogden fourth and fifth grades She had no trouble at t the industrial indu tri l school never nver has bas to resort re ort to t corporal punishment pur She Is opposed op to it She treats treat the girls as a her equals equal and nd finds tImIe It H to work wort well She heard hean Mrs M MD D T Tracy the former matron say ay that if It she he lost loat her position po tUon she he would see to it that Superintendent Thomas lust lost his She always heard he superintendent speak peak to the girls in an uplifting way y he was ws always gentlemanly and they were always glad d to s see e him come Mrs T D Harris Harrill testified that she was wa c cook x k at the school in hi 1993 10 and again last lastar year car ar from April to October She cooked for Hid Jh boys buys and and members of their families She had the help of two or more boys boy Supplies were kept in a storeroom and lind nd issued to her on requisitions made s af night Meats Mea were kept in an ice box and Issued by Mrs Ir Thomas or herself Plenty of food was prepared she said and It was good For breakfast the boys boy had fried tried potatoes hot bread coffee meat moat and hot cakes iu at t times There was w always meat for dinner The bill of tare fare was waa put into the theT record S ST T B Evans on the Stand Thomas Thoma B Evans vans was the rest r witness He was wag for four years He was treasurer of the board the first tIr t two years yean and president the last two Un Under Under der dec his first fim term the superintendent t bought supplies as be he felt disposed and aJ nl reported with his bills to the trustees tru He said ald that he had been ig supplies to the school during his bis whole term as trustee He said that the superintendent asked the board for permission to have J H Scott wok work on his house and he gaY gave his bla consent with th un uti understanding that the tate ate was wa not lIot to pay for this work Sold Supplies to School On Mr Ii Evans saW said that before he became trustee Ute the cot cor corporation co of ot which he is i the head fur furnished fished nl hed the school with m IS to WO worth of supplies a month After Alter he became trustee he furnished all the way from s 60 i to sr 2 worth woth a month an n average a tt f from 90 00 O to HOC a groceries tea coffee Hour flour butter eggs These supplies were not furnished on contract and Mr Evans never put in a bid He furnished all ali the flour used at the Institution until untila a Contract was wa re let to Peery Brothers In I n regard to the Oregon boot he said aid it was WIUS at the school when he be first became a trustee He recommended that it be dispensed ed with as improper and its use was prohibited prot He did not know that it had been used after this prohibition huH tion Mr Evans said he sold currants to the institution in pound p und cartons He remembered remembered bored complaints about eggs eus and these were always made good He often ate with Mr Thomas family at t the school but never with the boys At this point Judge Agee was w cut off by the commit committee tee from inquiring further into the fur of supplies to the school by Mr Evans Evan |