| Show I t f NOW RESTING i IN JURYS HANDS Case of Thomas Vance Turned Over to Panel of Judges Late at Night ARGUMENTS PRESENTED n Sent to Hotel for Night and May Ripen te to Court This Kendal Honing If Ready Roady the second time within two r rr Pr r years the h question Of Og B pDt guilt lUt or inno lane innot o of t Thomas Tho charged Keel with the e of ot his hi Iaia wife wU In tit 11 7 ra rests t th with wilh h twelve men mn to delis deoM fter trier u a wk week wf k spent in to the Ute giving or of against and on OR a behalf s ot or it the thel all alleged g ed n murderer in la the second trial trW of ot the IiiI man once convicted and td i to the Ilie death d th penalty the tho I raa aae te was wall ua completed with the In Instruction true tion of ot the ourt given givens at t a ath night th t see j lion dun y Beginning Aela i g IH la Ute the art aft afternoon I the argument I of ot the coun I gel f pet r re tut nu J concluded until close to ton tOI I n it clock last 1 night and it tt WM was al alBun almust must Bun midnight ht before fo the Jury retired to 10 the jury JUM room to tu begin its tw delibera deliberate I pots te He liu e ur or the lateness of ot the hour the Jury did not ot attempt consideration of ut the case a End and d WP alter organ sing by hy j wl ting a trman retired to the K Kuon on hotI quarters receive elve verdict to In III 1 n order to a or pr ode further instructions the court will II remain n in continuous g noil an oft un until until until I til the th jury returns its It verdict and the judge ju w Hill iII H appear at 11 10 this I morning lorning to receive any communication tion tieL tt s 2 Lens Lena Vance Vanee the th daughter apter Itter of at too tint defendant charged chare with the Ule death th of i the M e wits wit and mother WM WU again sUD the 1 principal in a dramatic seen Beene at the close dose or of the trial yesterday ye Startled Court Sitting Bitting patiently patient and a betraying but l quiet Interest in the closing argument ment b by the states tate a prosecutor Assistant t District Attorney E K O 0 Leatherwood t I the girl wh who at the tint trial gave damaging evidence against t her fath father fathi t i er n and during the past week has baa de do defended dot deI t I fended him startled the court room anti an the jurors by leaping to her har feet as a Mr Mt Leatherwood concluded his hie ap heal for fa Justice crying out in sobbing lObbing twice i one 1 I thought you had a heart but hot 1 j you vou after what you hats han said tonight So sudden and startling was waa the Interruption In Ift that few In th tile the court room taught caught the words of the Ute girl I rJ A Banc B Vance anc tn e brother of the defendant ant and anda I stated a next to the girl 1111 caught her bel by hy bythe bythe I the tilt arm and dragged her back into h hr her r stat seat As A she sp spoke oke ke the last word the th girl gin broke down dO in I a paroxysm of grist grief and burying her head in her army Ium itS as she sat fait t down clown gave gaye vent to her hr overwrought o feelings For Por a few minutes minute the proceedings were stilled the th attorney jurors Juron and aDd court all allbIne bring being startled at the sudden udden interruption Lion tion Th h sight of the court e urt was given Kilen KM en over ever to the flu arguments of the theand and the rhe Jw In one of the court eurt to the Jury With the closing at the case dd dit day afternoon Mr made madea a It brief opening argument and was followed d by Attorney AU John Jolla F P Tobin t i the defendant Mr Tobin talk talking ing hig before and after atter the recess of ot the Ute I hurt court taken takeD for tor dinner reviewed in I detail the evidence ide presented d in the cask case He was wu followed hy lity a S A Ma fa and A J Weber made the i losing closing appeal tor for the defendant During the closing of ot the case Vane Vance allt sat In the court room lounging I in his hi chair and yawning awning from time timeto ti to t tm time He seemed the least eon con concerned and most mat indifferent spectator ur f t the proceedings and even as a the thet thease t ase Woe was given to the twelve men me who will Mil ill decide dedde his guilt or 01 innocence hardly hard gave caw them theta a glands glance During the th hearing of ot the arguments I Vances three th e children Lena Le and Florence who teho testified for tor him at this trial and aBd the boy sat at t beside him Girl Florence Yae the daughter of Thomas and aad the deceased Lary XU Vance Yance was Wall the important and aDd oti principal I he Vanes witness WIlD In Ia the dosing dlag day da of the tre Vance trial In her ber childish h w way wa she he answered U in I straightforward atral manner all an tile the th questions put pat to t her by both uth the attorneys or of f the tile defense tenae and till the prosecution and aM the but of ot the tile eU tion failed to shake her positive po lUy statements state statement I ment ments Corroborating the testimony liven Kren by her ber elder sister Ister Lena Leaa Vanes Va nee to on n Friday the little girl proved a sat in favor ot f her tether father charged with the murder of ot her ber bern moth n er T Tn There r was however a close r sem V between bet the testimony of ot the str iri tr sad and the slater sister Lena L T direct ft urn I nation Florence re recalled recalled called the occasion the date being No o r JC fi C 1311 when wit her Iter father had bad mine orne hone hOIl for lunch and aDd a quarrel had Relating the Incident the lit Ut t tle said Papa came home for tor his dinner and when nn he he had bad drunk one OM cup af of settee h he asked for another Bother Dont flU It iii full I he said Mamma might not have bave heerd him and when wh she brought the thet t 1 to him he hf said mid I tell you nl ni i t to fill Mi the t h cup hall full Mamma said lin about not hearing him haa and then n papa p ra w aid DO yon yea yo moan mean a to say eay that t yoU ou did not Rot hear and aad then he It threw the th t off at her 1181 i man After Ir th that t he ht picked UR a and M sa sat d Tom dont t you hit me mew w ith b hat hal t nd then thea she he ran out doors doon 1 It t he hP h was nas as out oat papa locked the dour i tut tur ui n same In la through antI an tI IT doer io r When she e ame e In papa pap i fit fI hi i ter fr down dOWD and she got up and aDd ht n h t u her down again They Tb said saida a t r A word to o one oae another and then theft Dabs ilta w went nt hack back to work TI want Has wY A positive ht that her Ki 1 Id ed d i tot not ot struck or kicked her herr herat III at u I r 81 SL r said that she had been III 11 b In fi tur fr r it lh PUt past two years ye ra with Mr B I sirs Mrs v I i B 11 Vance the brother and 1st tT in t of Thomas Thom Vance but de del d dd d l that hd 1 n II one had told toW her to testify y ta anth hue but the th truth to In n the case cae asin int t j r father futher Yrs Krs r 4 t u as a recalled sr id the on end l time by t the tho ii defense to Watt f i identification of ot the color st ti the tLE t lt supposed tt t have eon con r laett t r savle and found In th the Dr Lr l I ctt ett was the Iv lest st witness tr lit Ih ih ji ing expert tHe tHey y 1 a the t I characteristics of ot poi put putI pois s I 1 d v t as a l his hili opinion that from frOlD fromi the i 1 I symptoms Mary arr Vanc Vano Vanoi bee not nH n i the Ii victim vl of ot mercurial 0 n Th Tb 1 in n rebuttal r rt but tal recalled recall Wil Wilt Willied t lied Il H t i Ii former county c attorney the tn i ur ut of f imi th the te tej V j u t Vance anc nc to the effect t ti win i 1 t i 1 not nut to him how her r t t n r a 31 i aien and kicked her heron on an 6 ISO I PaI I r nJ nd Mr J Jo Jon p P F LIr L lr ia r re r rued a 1111 el i t i e stare taLe tai to tea tes J my t tb tP F Heter ar of or Mr Mra t 1 U t onci aDIf Ward nard t this testimony t R t ase for fu t r the Purpose et st o offsetting oU the made bs b the Ule defense defence against ti i f of or the woman regarded tt a s 8 most important witness u i |
