Show REFUSES TO SU SH ASIDE ENT Verdict Entered by Default Against Donald Donaldson son Will Stand JUDGE REBUKES DEFENSE CONTROVERSIES BE BENEATH BENEATH BENEATH NEATH COURTS COURTIS ATTENTION Judge Ritchie yesterday esterday refused to tott tit tt aside the Judgment for 1080 entered en cn entered tred by him some time ago in favor fator of William McWhirter and against James Donaldson i Tho The case has been in to the courts over since the famous poker sunie gunie in to the t e Antler rooming house on Sept 10 W i in which the McWhirter wore i beaten out of by a gang of I i rooks McWhirter sued SUM Donaldson row riou IO under tinder a ten year sentence sentence in the I i for his share of the tho ii r il d 1 judgment jud was entered by b default months ago Donaldson protested alleging that hi hiJ d J not appear because he had not v Tn reliably informed as ail to the tJ x of his time to answer In IiI this thle connection the court says SO It is essential to setting netting aside sid a default Judgment that the party soak seak ins mg m relief show that he ho has a lous sous defense The defendants answer answer tendered sets up that he won the mon moni i involved as tile result of a gaming b 1 t wager The supreme me court has stab established in cases eases pf this class that when whan Ic it is made to appear appear app ar that a claim grows rows out of a transaction which is illegal il illegal illegal legal immoral or against public policy a n court will leave the parties where it finds them I 1 The assertion of the defendant that the other was equally in the wrong I II I does dOe 5 not avail to to take his case out of the operation OP ration of the rule The law lar deems such matters unworthy to oc occupy occupy occupy cupy the time of a court of Justice j |