Show MADHOUSE lOOMS UP HARRY Trial of Whites Slayer Stopped St and Question Q of Lunacy Commission Will Be Considered Climax Reached When Defense Put Dr Allen McLean Hamilton on the Stand as a Witness N which Th blow Wow IW l W York March larch ar ay arv Kendall l ThAW tam has s h i tn In terror 1 ner since inee his lite Jit trial for or the murder of frd fird White began n Ml fit Joday oday Dis Dl Jerome did not Dot make for 1 i fur for the appointment of ot a arnt ion In iii lunacy luna but In III an pas J 1 li he hf h appealed to the con conof cono conI I o of f th I tie declaring that as asH m H dt I daily dail In he is ai di ing hit his counsel roun 1 and is 18 l believed none who has h ha l watched and comes ii 1 i with iLl him lIim to be in i 1 asserted that his own On alien ahon r when hen they had con cond conti d ti ill lI 11 th lh fads facts in connection conn tion with rj f i thil IhaL Thaw was of unsound mind J Jr i iwo us dramatically accused the thel 1 l Ir the ht defense of concealing tes m III h if presented to the court i 1 i mike make th tb the continuance of the trial II Judge Won Over by Jerome carl II did pl ad that Jus Just t i IZI aid dismissed ae the Jury Jur until 1 Ur by I morning and adjourned court until jock dod Ioe tomorrow afternoon when he heT hei T i i conIer ider the evIdence which either i i j bM hal to offer r and to decide whether r r trial trail shall shIt go on or whether a com corn comMon Mon IJ m hl II lunacy shall be ha appointed to toi toa i a Thaw s mental ment 1 condition today It nes attending the adjournment I art urt shortly after 1 were dra dran n and ind Thaws counsel ir Yr md d 1 taken utterly utter by surprise This is to I be the last day da of or the I O opt for the summing up no before In r Soun oun after the io I among am ng Justice Fitzgerald Die Dis Attorney Attorn Jerome Jeroue and Mr Ir Delmas Delmasi i 1 Thaws haws 1 five fie other attorneys gath guth J ii 11 b by l one around the Judges desk deski i I T ryo r A time seemed intent upon deny denyS den S v hat itt the court had termed the theor theof h of or unprofessional conduct Olit It ht against them by b the prosecuting pro r f Thaw Utterly Dejected w V sat at dieted dejected pale jade and antI dispirited s counsel i table He lie flushed crim on bv b one onto his hiI attorneys a left him ally rath to t the support of Mr 11 Delmas howle cl in the midst of the pro J J g S was Wa ed by b Attorney Att It II I t oll H Than T aw bit his nails J oj 1 11 hl U loii his hands hand nervously nal down don in his hie chair In an en anul enI ul d I of utter itter dejection In an adjoin iro m In where hr h r they could hear th the ex exand J Ii and iiI uplifted notified voices of counsel lin III one Oil fl with the other stood stO d Mrs In m 10 Thaw the mother and Evelyn Eveln Evelyni I i Thaw Than The a the I he wife who had bared A It r ts T if f her soul in the effort to toW W It II husband from tl the e electric chair I 1 f C om i the th lh fate which he declares he hemore hern more rn r a madhouse hel Climax Came With Hamilton Hamilto I hiti x of f the nine weeks trial was WitS I I f in hy Ip the action altlan of the defense ti t the stand Dr Allen Alien lIen McLean cLean I I 1 to Io r the th t i alienist who was as first ii into nt tin II I case aC a Ole by Thaws original i ir r N Black lUik Olcott OI Ott Grubor Gruber Bon Boa I I h t who u up was dismissed dl d together then rn when h ru he In h reported that Thaw if I iii from a form of or h 0 i might neer he cured It was the i inn ji of f Mr Delmas to interrogate with reference to four fourr r h 11 v m in md ule 1 to to Thaw in June and Mr Ir J 1 rome promptly objected say sa I 4 i liat idt It if it Dr hamilton was wa to te testify I i hr he h must t 1111 H ll everything he knew I n fl i with wilh ith the th cas l easeS RI including the I i taut s history The arguti I wh h ti n l became so pertinent I 0 iK 1 tin of or the present sanity or orn orf i n 11 f r the thi defendant that Justice Erald d te ted l the jury to retire from I room r nm m Then the tle th discussion took on road ing which resulted In the thedr thed I dt dr d ru i it jAil before proceeding ti h Ian l presented to him the thes s J Wi the tIl tI district attorney asserted a I on n withheld W from the Jury by b the theard thes thep s p and ard CT d he had been unable to toI f i the th 1 i urt rt in strictly legal Igal form torm Jerome Attacks Counsel f V 5 10 IM 1 fits fats were known de deil ra il d M Ir J r ni I have hae HO no Jt right to tot trying t g this man for his Ida life But ButI I have hae cannot be put in Int form l t ri th the jury jUI t is mostly fr a u Itt But if f I could get the facts yOU iI tl V would shock and horrify T o l l n I of f th court and 11 a t be lie stopped So deeply 1 I I Wn i impressed with this that I Ird rd notice on counsel of record 1 ii this trial is 18 concluded I find ind j w re e i in possession of ef facts 1 I Ul 1 Ii i r to t l i h e in th their ir possession I tall all i e matter to the attention wi o di of the supreme I I A f I erv r bitterly bitted about this r F re r is is i not a mali who hn has I tl I th u fondant sitting lucre here at lit atS S iaMo 01 tint liat l t does not know that as aa I 15 t to ir if j incapable of advising L THUS Ti under inder r the statutes it be beof j Jt of f the C court coort l to St stop P the Suppressed y the Defense J l Dm inu lm ought ight to have hac Mr Ir Jerome nims ini if t II record as formally ap for Ur i cy but the thea t a N would only onh repeat that t I a cal ailing sr r tile the th attention of the court might appeal to his hits 11 lZ Mr oIT Jerome J rome said that Drs b aIT two of the Thaw ua lans had told him facts con coni 7 ilo iS i on both sides eWes of the pris to I It tn i Iut Iiii ut the defense had hat failed n 1 out tin t he Ii e matters in the l I 1 to t the summoned t Mat fl d t the he facts fact in hi my posses aw 1 r Jerome and nd they one and S IJ that lint t the defendant ta s sc sI c I fr rm in disease sease called calle paranoia H i A f of which are in m ini i la under these t 1 J p I s hf hr killed Stanford hittl I I the legal definition of in inre sanity he ho knew kne the nature and quality of of his act and knew the act to be bc wrong Alienists In Delicate Position Justine Justice Fitzgerald wanted to know if it the alienists had informed the tho district at attorney attorney attorney torney of their opinions before answering the long hypothetical question in court Mr Jerome admitted that they the had lied The evidence he submitted to them had not boon been adduced R In court ourt however and ho could not put it in the thc hypothetical tion Opportunity Now cow ow that they thE thie Irn have e put Mr 11 Hamil Hamilton Hamilton ton on the th stand explained Mr 11 Je Jerome Jerome rome I t have Ita my first opportunity of laying before beCore the court sworn testimony t of a character which may ma demand tho the at nt attention attention of the tue court For the first time we have hare the real evidence before beCore us tie and anti andI antiI I want it all to go in Your honor will support me in the claim that ever vel since the trial began b gan I have struggled to have havethe havethe the doors opened wide that all the facts might be brought out But I hare hac been met with objections and legal restrictions everywhere eer Mr Ir Delmas replied that it was strange if the district attorney had so long hong pos poe possessed the information he was stating to the court that he had persisted so long in prosecuting to his death a man who he believed was insane in the eyes ees of the I law because he lie could not communicate intelligently with whit counsel As s to the charge chare of unprofessional conduct he lie had lind heard it for or the first time today Mr Ir Delmas continued He lie further sakI that the defense had called to the stand Dr Hamilton the thi man whom the district at attorney attorney torney torne believed to know more about the case than anybody an else ciPe e and was proceed proceeding ing to Interrogate him when the district attorney objected I Gleason Takes Charge Here Mr Ir Gleason took up the discus discussion don sion lie He rejected the district attorneys s sa assertion a that Thaw was as unable to fa ad advise adIse j vise ite Ise his counsel and declared it was as the duty of the court to submit that ques question question question tion to the jury The court will determine its Il duty duh for itself replied Justice Ju Fitzgerald Mr 1 Gleason next demanded before the I I I I I I I I I I I proceedings pro went further that Dr Ham Hamilton HamIlton ilton be interrogated as to whether or not he hI thought Thaw capable of or advising his counsel Justice Fitzgerald allowed tho the question and the witness replied that he heI did not think Thaw was capable pable ca of or ad advising advising his counsel at present I Wants All the Evidence I Justice Fitzgerald demanded that coun counsel counsel I sel eel on both sides submit to him tomorrow I all al the evidence they possessed touching I upon the sanity or insanity of the defend defendant ant nt If the defense did not desire to do this he said he lie could not compel it and would have to proceed without such evi evidence dence denee from them to combat that to be bo offered by b the district attorney Justice Justine Fitzgerald even een went so far as asto ts tsI s sto to discuss the personnel of a possible commission in He lie said he did dill not wish to appoint any an alienist who had been consulted in the case by b either side Ride and desired to be given ghen the names of ev every e eer cry ery er doctor for consideration It was wasa agreed a eed that both sides should submit af at affidavits tomorrow Claims of f the Lawyers When hen the court adjourned Hart Hartridge HartI Hartridge ridge and OReilly of Thaws s counsel professed d the greatest pleasure over oer the turn M f affairs The Th district attorney has acknowledged acknowledged edged ed ed himself beaten said Hr Hart Hartridge Hartridge ridge We Ve w can combat the lunacy lunac com corn mission ml slon In the meantime the district at attorney torney torne has acknowledged that he be believes es Thaw was insane when hen he ho shot Stanford White hite That Thal ought to give gIe us usan usan usan an acquittal District Attorney Jerome was as manifestly manifest pleased with the Idea of a commission He immediately Imm set to work preparations for affidavits He lie will be able to place before Justice Fitzgerald tomorrow all the testimony he has been unable to get before the jury jUr Mr Delmas declined to make any an definite nile nite statement He merely said that it lied llad been agreed that when the case reached the stage stag which developed today toda Mr Ir Gleason should take charge He Il said of or course he be would still be connected with the case cas Mrs Irs William Thaw and Evelyn Even Thaw left the court house together after they the had had a brief chat with the pris prisoner prisoner prisoner oner and told him that victory was as in insight Insight sight When hen Thaw reached his cell in the Tombs he Jle began to write at a furious pace paC saying It would be bo his hi statement to tobe tobe tobe be submitted to the court tomorrow a |