Show CAUSED MUCH AMUSEMENT Brilliant Retiring Senator Led Fili Fill Filibuster Filibuster buster Against the Bill Washington March 3 Never before has the senate appeared to relish so much an attempt to kill legislation by filibustering filibustering methods Mr Carmack director of ot the minority movement against the bill at no time tried to hide the fact tact that that his effort was a filibuster pure and simple He came into the open by ad addressing addressing addressing dressing himself principally to the term filibusters which Mr Gallinger only yesterday applied to the Democratic sen senators senators atom who have undertaken to defeat the measure First Mr Carmack devoted himself to toan toan toan an indorsement of ot Websters dictionary as an authority on orthography and den del definition I and said if it the senate had any an doubt that this work worl was an authority he would bring It in and ask that passages from it be read at the desk Description Des of Filibuster After Atter reading Websters definition of filibuster with Its varying uses and synonyms Mr lIr Carmack said that the re sc remark mark of ot Mr Gallinger had branded him himas as a marauder a pillager a buccaneer a sea robber a free tree booter hooter and a pirate upon the seas sens in fact he said I 1 have been ben accused of ot almost everything except appendicitis So 5 branded I am to be re is retired retired tired from this body and sent to my ome for tor I cannot defend myself by at attacking attacking attaching tacking taching the character or the credibility of the New Hampshire I cannot discredit him truthfully and there therefore fore bra cannot t discredit him at atall all When 1 he h had spoken for about forty tes with the th obvious purpose of killing kUling time Iliac Mr Carmack looked at rU athis his remarked Well I see r I must mus along At this time the senators on the floor shouted their amusement Dubois Assisted To give Mr Carmack a rest Mr Du Dubois Dubois Dubois bois asked to be permitted to read from froma a very interesting document on the sub subject subject subject of ot ship subsidy and Mr Spooner protested that as Mr Carmack was in so great a hurry to conclude it would not be beaIr fair aIr to Interrupt him The Tennessee senator sen tor however said sald he lie was sure that any contribution from Mr Dubois would woul be valuable and he should be glad clad to permit It to be read and Incorporated in inthe Inthe inthe the body of ot his remarks Mr Dubois then read at length and when he had concluded ed a very technical paragraph to which few senators paid any attention Mr Ir Car Carmack Carmack Carmack mack asked that the last paragraph be repeated as he regarded It of ot great im importance importance 1 Laughter followed and as Mr Dubois Dubols sat down Mr Gallinger inter interrupted Interrupted interrupted to reply he said to what he thought had been een as unwarranted attack upon him himAt himAt himAt At this Juncture a colloquy occurred between Mr Gallinger and Mr Carmack over oer the definition of ot the word filibuster as given by b different dictionaries and the latter charged that Mr Gallinger had simply been trying to filibuster ac according according according cording to isis his own definition of ot the word Charging that the pending measure was for lor the purpose of ot looting the treasury Mr Carmack referred to the bill as vot votIng Ing lug b k subvention and Mr Ir McLaurin asked the difference between beta eon subsidy and subvention Mr Carmack an answered answered answered Subsidy by any other name smells as WI bad Mr Carter Cart r added to the spirit dt df levity by interrupting the reading of or letters from ship builders by Mr Ur Overman who was giving Mr Carmack a respite I want to fo know said Mr Carter what if It any dictionary Is in Ten Tel Tennessee Tc and that It if any Standard rf of ot spelling exists and if It it is uniformly ap applied applied applied plied This gave Mr Carmack an opening which he be took advantage of ot to taunt Sen Senators Senators Carter and Gallinger with being parties to a filibuster Observing that my question embar ember embarrasses embarrasses names the senator interjected Mn Mi Car Carter Carter Carter ter inasmuch nellie probably is not Will Willing willIng ing lag to admit that the lbs dictionary is un we unknown unknown known in that thaI state I will withdraw the question If the senator wants a direct answer said Mr Carmack Tennessee stands by bythe b bythe the constitution and Websters diction dictionary dictionary dictionary ary After Senator Tillman had hac asked how much steal there was wu in ship subsidy Senator Frye of Maine rebuked the whole proceeding as undignified For the sen senate senate senate ate to hold a session en on the Sabbath day dayh he h remarked for the sole purpose of ot frivolous olous lous debate deb te for the amusement of ot the galleries was about the most unseemly proceeding he had ever witnessed While he ho spoke Mr Frye turned so 10 as to face Senator Carmack who was seated He Heat Heat Heat at once arose and replied Continued on Page 2 NO HOPE FOR THE SHIP SUBSIDY Continued from Page 1 hI If the senator refers to 10 me I will say sa that I am not responsible to him for tor my conduct and I shall conduct myself ac according according according cording to my m own notions of tory tOI If Jt the senator s from Maine does not like my mv manner lie Jie has my m permission lon to leave the chamber chal and go where he can attend church If It he would prefer preter I 1 would much rather be b In church retorted Mr r Frye Fre FreIt If jf the senator wishes to take a are re recess reces cess ess until tomorrow I shall not Interfere with It n suggested Mr Ir Carmack The senator knows I cannot was the reply Well continued Mr Ir Carmack the senator Is evidently much more con concerned concerned concerned about the defeat of this bill than anything else Mr Carsick Ca lck then de dc declined dined to yield further to Mr aIr Ir Pre Frye al although although a though the latter attempted att to interrupt pt Shortly after alter this the incident was closed by bv the tile restoration of amity Sen Senator Senator Senator ator Carmack expressed e regret that the incident had occurred He had spoken he lie said on the impulse of the moment and withdrew what hat had been said Sen Senator Senator Senator ator Frye Fre too expressed the same sen sentiment sentiment and explained that he hn had not meant to address the senator from Ten Tea Tennessee Tennessee personally in his criticism At 53 50 p m in the senate took a recess until S o clock Night Session The filibuster against the ship subsidy bill was nas continued when the senate re resumed resumed its session at tonight Senators Dubois and Carmack made an appeal to Senator Gallinger to withdraw the bill but he did not Comply The debate was interrupted by the pass passage passage passage age of a resolution for tor the printing of ot a n document kin on horses which brought out from Senator Carter the remark a horse hone on the Democratic side This sally aroused the venerable Senator Pet Pettus Pettus Pettus of ot Alabama who remarked We 0 ac accept accePt accept the rebuke from the senator from Montana because be ause of ot his wisdom and long experience and do not fail tall to recall that he has haA the record for speaking for more than twenty hours to kill a river and har bar harbor harbor barbor bor bill r |