Show UNITED U STATES TATES SUPREME COURT ii Mandate in Northern Securities Case Issued Iss ed MISSOURI BEER LAW VALID I NEW YORK LAW UN UNCONSTITUTIONAL UNk k CONSTITUTIONAL 4 J Washington Aunt April 17 liIn In accord accordance accordAnce ance with the tho previous announcement by y Chief Justice Fuller the mandate of ot I the supreme court of or the United States In th the Northern S SecurIties case cane way walt te le IB sued Hued today It was directed to W VT V P Plough Clough lough chief counsel for tor the securities company and the ci essential part vart of at It Itis is js as 85 follows t lI a Where in th ti the present term the aus came to be heard before the su prem court and nd was waa argued by coun counsel eel sel el It It is tt now hOW and here ordered ad adjudged adjudged adJudged 1 judged and decreed by this court that the decree de ree of the United StateS Stated circuit ourt court of appeals appe l in this cause be and the is hereby affirmed with costs and md that the said appellant Northern Securities Sf CurlU company recover against the time aid taid appellees 20 O for Its costs herein expended and have execution and it is further ordered that this cause be and the same is hereby re remanded to th the circuit court for the time States for Cor the district of New Jersey Jr ey eyThe The opinion was handed down in the thease thease ase case of Lockner vs the State of New NewYork NewYork NewYork York and waa was based on the ground round that the law Jaw Interferes with the free tree exercise e of oC the rights right of contract be between bet between tween t individuals The Th court of 01 appeals of or the state tte upheld the law nd and at nl the judgment nt pf the trial court holding Lockner guilty gunt Judge Parker wrote the opinion of or the tile New NewYork NewYork NewYork York court cout of o app appeals Us supporting the Jaw a aw w and the court divided four to three thre on 01 tl tle question of validity it |