Show HILLS SCHEME DEFEATED GREAT NORTHERN CANNOT THE N P judge fudge kelly says it would be con arary to the states policy and violate the law st paul minn nov ag 16 judge ke kely I 1 today filed his big decision in the important case of the state ot of minnesota against the groat great northern and Jor or thein rk pacina companies the state ins ina the great northern and north rn Paci pacina may not lot enter into their ti allic arrangement and judge kelly grants the writ of injunction as aa prayed while the case case stands on oil what appears to be a preliminary motion that for an injunction the decision vi ritually y le the lilt whole subject since it TOPS thoroughly into the matter it la 19 remarkable that judge kelly ari ived at a conclusion exactly opposed I 1 to io judge sanborn who passed upon the very same question in the united states circuit court where the if ie case wati heard on oil the motion of pearsall tor tit an injunction against the road the points of dech decision vion are the proposed traffic arrangement Is a consolidation under the laws of the he I 1 aate of minnesota the great north cin arid and northern pacific roads are parallel arid and competing lines the traffic arrangement Is therefore contrary to the public policy of tile the state and ami the general laws of 1874 and ISSI the defendants charter does not contain either in express terms or by implication the right to make such agreement or consolidation that it if any such power was waa ever given the charter charier was subject to to amendment by the legislature and the laws referred to |