Show HIGHLY ARBITRARY And Without Justice is What Judfre Barrett Called a Detention at Castle Garden Special to THE HERALD Examiner Dispatch NEW Yom Jan tWhilc Judge Bar rett in the supreme court chambers yesterday yes-terday afternoon was in the most emphatic tones pronouncing the detention of a young n utrlan tlor Johann Ranmer who wishes to join his uncle in San Francisco as highly arbitrary and without justice a different and more animated scene was being enacted in the old board room at Castle Garden At the same hour that the judge rendered his decision and Ranmers release Commissioner Stephenson was orating to his fellowcommissioners and defending his action in detaining the young immigrant The majority of the commissioners present sustained Stephen sont action and a resolution was adopted I many ordering the return of Raumer to Ger Ranmer is a graduate of a tailoring es tablishment in Dresden Germany He arrived at Castle Garden January 15 He gave his ultimate destination as San Francisco Fran-cisco He has with him lOU in cash and baggage valued at S50 Early in childhood Ranmer broke his leg and owing to a bungling operation one of his limbs is UbU l uuner Luan tne He otler lmps somewhat but as he is a competent tailor competnt taior his lameness does not interfere with him earning a livelihood Excepting his short leg Ranmer is ablebodied and is a manly intelligent looking young man Mr Stephenson Ste-phenson thought that because of his short leg Ranmer should be detained but the immigrant tells another story Today he identified two clerks in Castle Garden whom he says told him that i he bought I his ticket in Castle Garden for San Fran cisco ne wouia oe given his nis uuerty The clerks deny this accusation Notwithstanding Notwith-standing Judge Barretts decision Ranmer is still a prisoner in Castle Garden and the commissioners say that i the judge wants him he will have to use physical force to get him before the steamer sails |