Show i MARINE CHAR CHARGES ARE f ROVEN I State Insane Board Exonerates Officials of il Hospital j PATIENT UNRULY AT TIMES Y BRUISES FOUND ON HIS EI i I S SELF OT D 1 II The stale b nt ot l that at n time while a ta 1 Ute the h wu was Michael Micheel Karle cruelty Cruelly or a The Th of O tJ tb e emen men menti 1 are of t the e of or of the S Jt Lake man and ad be Ie Men alene I 1 blamed er the and aDd cuts which leh were fouad upon pon Me I person TIle The board finds that see e of the were in by Ute the who were weN to Wile Use ton torte e In d de defending tending fending themselves the patient wit when he was waz suffering t f man front one of ef bli frequent spells The report of die boa was maM public yesterday It w drafted at II a session d th the morning It Is signed 1 by y State Auditor AuditOr UK and Stat Tre Treasurer Dixon aM oo with the following wor worIn In the nt of t the e state mental hospital the board bonI deal desires aid courts the fUllest public Inquiry and andI Dei Investigation I Oruel Crusi Tr Treatment Was The alleged cruel cluel treatment of MarIne w ws brought to the at t of oC Ute the board by thO parents of man wO wito was of t hospital tor toI treatment for tor mental They charted that the at DC t only 17 Dee bea harsh and cruel with their son but had bad refused them permission permon to see him when they called at the ho hospital upon upon occasions The charges which WAIe wese 8 p in 18 inThe The Herald at t the time were brought i v to 0 the attention of Governor Wens Wells the thet 1 t chairman or of the board and he said anid i that tat they would be Investigated added t that t Jf if It were found that any aBY or of the or of the he hail bad been erode cruel with Marine 0 or any ny of the other patients they not toniy only be die c charged at o once t at their treat meat ment would be brought to the atten attention attention tion of f tJ dl district of Utah county The investigation was held belt at Provo The mem members er of the board made sev several eral trips to that city and nd e examined 8 a number of witnesses e The report WS was delayed In being made public through business and other matters keeping the various members away from m meetings at t which they were to have been formulated and aDd decided upon But yesterday the boari met and nd decided upon their report port which is r a folio follows Findings of the BOR d ne board Boar 0 of Insanity having finished the i tion of the chares es of cruet cruel of Michael Mad Marine while a pa patient patient tient at t tM the taM stain ments I fl findS as follows follow That the relating to ue the dlf between Gather Gath urn and Mr Marine shows that the violence u used BY was and aDd clearly la in That the restraint to which the patient Marine was was not a punish I inset t but w wee necessary to prevent him from Crom carrying Into effect his disordered fancies regarding the treatment e of the I eruptions n with which he was afflicted c That the cut ut on Marines head bead also the bruise OIl on his eye were caused by his hl aPing against IL a washstand while In ono one uC of the convulsions to he was sub subject That no weapons of offense e or 01 defense are kept or r permitted to be kept in anY of the wards of the hospital and no sticks or clubs were used upon Marine Karine In fa fathis Inthis this in instance tance or 01 at any anI other time That the attendants daily record rd Is al always ways waya subject to revision by the medical superintendent and whatever changes were made In the record rd relating to Ma Marine Marice rice rine were made fot fOl the solo Ie DU or of the record conform to the su ideas idea of record tIon That at no time while a patient In the hospital was Marine cruelly treated or ori abused I i As ban attended the charges Ja in this case the board bord deems It advisable to make public the rules and regulations adopted for the management and control of patients which read as aa follows In dealing with attendants remember that their first duty Is Isto isto to treat them with unvarying kindness re respect and attention addressing them In a mild nd d gentle genUe tORe tone of voice avoid avold avoiding ing aU alt violence and rud nick nicknames names name or disrespectful terms tOnas In man managing managing aging patients there must be absolutely no buses abuses no and no din gracee The board will not permit DO nor tolerate any kind or form of h cruet or abusive lve treatment of y patient br brany b bany any person employed at the and will excuse violence tow a patient Doll OR the clearest t of oC Its ab necessity In TIle The board has always insisted that pa p be treated gently kindly and con considerately and believes that each and ad every of the hospital hen has nfl obeyed the wishes of the board as Ia the rules and as q In the management of oC the ate men mental mental tal the board desires desire and courts 1 the tune fullest t public Inquiry 7 and aDd Investigation tion HEBER bt WELLS JOHN DIXON C S |