Show REASONS GIVEN BY BYi i JUDGE C W Post Waited Too Long Before Asking a Restrain Restraining ing Order St Louis Levis Sept ept pt 6 The judgment of 0 I Judge Smith McPherson who yesterday denied the petition of er C W P lest st of oC Bat Battle n nUe Battie tie tle Creek Mich Mleh for an Injunction to tore restrain re the American Federation of oC Labor Lar and ami the Bucks Dude Stove Range flange company COni frets frem entering Into a closed snap shop agreement a was wan filed riled In la the th United States State district court Ourt here Judge Mc Ie en decided the ease case In chambers at t his hili home beme In a Red fled Oak la Is laThe The tentative agreement the ratification ratification cation t Uon of which Mr Post Pest opposed th the court rt says was reached some me six Ix weeks ago Judge Jude McPherson continues Complainant then knew of nC It He II 11 hot has ha remained silent until the last It few Cew days cia when he filed his bill of complaint asking for or the thC tb Injunction He lie Iras has I given notice of oC this thle hearing to MO no defendant defend nt Many Ian of ot them are Bre accessible and no doubt would have been present had I they been fen notified orders enters should not he l 1 Issued except el lpt on notice to the defend defendants I ants ami atwi then thea only fUlly whOa when wh Irreparable i harm hari will If Ir such restraining re order I Is net Issued I J utterly fall o osee osee see ee wherein the harm hum eon can come If this restraining order Is not Issued The court Ourt says M every employer of or labor has ha the right to determine for lor himself whether his shall hall be operated as all a closed dOlled shop or an aft open shop hoP adding Whether It IB Is for or the better to have haf a closed shop or an open shop men differ I |