Show DENOUNCE MOTHER MOTHER DENOUNCE SON Senator Hoar Thus Describes the Requirements of the Sedition Laws of the Philippines f i lillan Calls Them Th m Damnable Doctrine D e and Says Sass They Would Apply to Tillman Tillmar n J t I HI Fob S The lL I la fit 1 fo orce In tile PhilI Phil Ii rf were rere laid before beCore They T Th had 1 been sent to 10 the Ox tv t by b the Of war 1 lj 19 Ye Yena e ei i na to a ar resolution offered by b Mr M r lir 1 f t r tah h several days ago ap The Ther iff r were ware read r ad in ill full by br b the clerk iJ tho Ihl th of the rending reading Mr r editor tnt nt to W t the clerks clerk and M Md r a ad ft Ions tIona to Inclusive lve tf f th hc revised rf statutes of the United s dealing with the same ame of Hl S SM M I Hoar Hoa r then spoke briefly upon 1 th t law la enacted by the th tb Phil I saying Haying he be was wa Jar sor sorry i ir ry rr r that the ih commission ion had by its ac al fn fl 1 adopted tho th only harsh and cruel provisions that were werF n to be found tn In statute 1 nf f the thc United States Un Vu Under dr der this cruel provision in the Philip Philippine pine i f mother he hi h vine Ing knowledge of raan of her bf f son sn on must inform the au su twit its upon him the BOH on must In Inh h fm m upon the mother the brother 1 ib r brother r the daughters upon I tP father and aud so fit on He Ite aid eald id the tbt th laws ro ni tho lit United SaS were tre applied only n of If this thie country citizens by nativity or adoption ad Says They Are Cru l ln ln in n nc he h case ale ae of this implication application of oC h arts in the ae h he ahl they hl were wr put into execution by byI byal I alien al n authority responsible sOn only onty to an or command 1 M 1 Patterson interrupted Mr MI Hoar Hoarn in III n uy I that thet en ni r of t tM members s II of oC ih UI Philippine MPA ought ou bt to be d l from any Iny odium attaching attach in to toP P enactment of or the Philippine sedi sedition tion lav laws ov Taft he hl said Mid had bad informed tv tip Philippines committee that he lie va val 8 11 l when hn these f act acts were ere enacted by t 1 commission and that had bad he be been pr there probably p would have haven n t the I Hm sm quite ready eady said Mr fIr Hoar to tn what the senator has hR said of ni 90 so able and humane a man as Gov Gos Governor Taft Mr Mt r said he never r had heard tho th Philippines act ad arts reed read until now that the H fo was liB surprised however hoever lor from eU Mr Ir Hoar I heuM be mentally and morally dis disturbed by hy such provisions M Nt a heen bew b n h rd When Mr Mn Ir Hoar Soar had bal desired dP fred to koo be hI added Ad w that the ten tes AM td urh JUh he hf had iid sent hO h united tailed St statutes and lead batt hari ad md r the r ts upon up n treason and against t the country Countr Nut Nt nt are the provisions the Mn im mf hf hc f declared dt as those contained d in l th Ih Philippines acts but the word wordIn I In nj n in both hoO is practically Identical l The Philippines adopted the tte of the re i ed statute add adding ms int f matters matt rs as M would make the JI ill S applicable to the Philippine Ind K Calls CAlIs Them Damnable Mr Ir Tillman Interrupted Mr lr Foraker tn In ce cp f the th sedition laws las enacted by In il Philippines commiSsIon as doctrine It might be In order ord said Mr r For ak x arn annl ly to in inquire of the t th senator from Nm Soui Sou OI arolina on en which side of or tho th h struggle in th tb the Philippines are his sympathies II My Mv sympathies mp are with the Pili FiU pil Mr tr Tillman pound pounding In ing his desk d k emphatically they are retorted Mr lr Foraker and such a flatfooted and I declaration as u the Uie senator ha baa made render the revised statutes statute applicable to him if he were not protected by Ity his hl position us iS s sea len senator ator lit Mr again aln Interrupted For Jeer m r and directly the attention to the declaration In the senate chamber of Thomas Corwin of Ohio during a a de do debate debate bate on the Mexican war var that if f he were a Mexican lie would welcome the with bloody hands to hos gnies inquired if sr the people of oC Ohio did not Hot reverence leveren c the name and memory of of Gor ln Says It Was Corwins Error Mr Ir Foraker replied that the people of oC Ohio did love to recall the memory of or Thomas but they th y realized he said that tb at In that great rent emergency he had made a profound mistake In response e to a question from Crom Mr Patterson of Colorado Io Mr Ir Foraker said that there was not a single word wordin wordIn wordIn in th sedition laws In ws adopted by the Philippines commission which would enable the authorities U to touch any man who wh was loyal to the United States ai lit h Tillman said sai 1 that he had seen a statement st ement from General Chaffee that thu t practically lI the entire Philippine population was vas imbued with a hatred of or ofin In view of this statement said he h hwe we must continue this Infamous ty British South African then hesitating he a few seconds he con continued 1111 Ill stop right there because I I cannOt And flud a word wOId hot enough to apply to th situation I I 1 want to the tile senator and to tosa sa say retort Mr fr Foraker with great vehemence that our army will wUl never come back buck from front the Philippines s until it comes back victorious That may mayas mayas mayas as well wen be b understood now as at any future U Mr r Hoar concluded the debate of or orthe the afternoon aft and in the course of his Na remarks paid a brilliant tribute to who In the face of oC a hostile senate tonte fI ate b h uttered the senti senU sentiment ment meat which he lie had earlier In Inthe the day He dec de t that Corwins I name and anA memOl jad ad Jacome one of ot the treasures of O f the republic and that he had been placed among the Immortals Immor Immortals tats of this government Loyal h he reet qu s ns now before the he said could be discussed I a gr t tl l s o h ful Ulft cruSh c out of a re republic republic republic public modeled alter after our bur own govern government government ment meat it tt was a great question how the slaughter of both Filipinos and Amer Americans Americans leans was to be stopped sto ped Men as a good as I am men inca wiser than I am said he differ from me meI upon these questions I do not believe I the distinguished senator from Ohio wants to do Injustice to anyone Some men however show their love ove of the flag fing by protecting it against violence and some sope show their love loe for the flag by keeping it pure and a symbol s of justice The one is an honorable thing and am tae tte othor other is an honorable thing Those Thoe who are resisting the present policy of our QUI government in the Phil Philippines s are quite as loyal as those who are supporting it The difference of which had bad risen among the th people he said in con conclusion elusion was tas the legitimate result of this miserable Philippines business At 6 the senate went weFt into ex cx executive I session and at adjourned until tomorrow |