Show BRITISH REJECT MINE PROPOSAL i L Lloyd oyd George Quotes Fro From III Warns Wants Labor Government Heads London Fob 11 William William Brace J president of ot tho tho South South South- Wales Vales Miners Miners' Federation In tho bouso of ot commons In behalf of ot labor today moved an amendment to tho the reply to tho the speech from the throne delivered yesterday b by King George expressing regret for Cor the absence of oC any Rny proposal to lo nationalize tho the coal minors of the tho country along lines recommended b bythe by bytho tho the majority of ot tho tim members of oC tho the royal commission on tho the coal cOllI Industry which was appointed to advise tho the government o as to the best methods of oC reorganizing the Industry to Mr Brace declared thal that nationalization tion would not mean bureaucratic con con- Tho government go might dell delay nationalization na nn- na- na but bu t he predicted It could not nationalization from coming Fair Asked k d dHo Ho lie Insisted his plan w was s not one of or confiscation but bat of oC fair talI purchase The government go would give tho the shareholders share holders bonds for COl their present shares Ho lie asked that a tribunal bo be established to fix a fair price for such shares and said coal would be sold to exporters under the tho nationalization system as freely as at 1 present In replying to somo of or tho arguments advanced Premier Lloyd Georgo ar argued nr- nr rued gued that It would be bo Impossible to have 1130 nationalization without bureau bureau- cracy The Tho premier ridiculed Mr Braces Brace's idea that the tho miners would work harder for the state than for tor private vate yato interests Experiment I Mr Lloyd George created something I of or a a. scene by quoting from Crom Leon Leon to show that tho the Bolshevist experiment of ot nationalization in RusI Rus- Rus I sla sia had failed Called and that tho the had llad been obliged to resort to conscription conscription tion of at labor Vernon a. a member of ol the tho I national executive e committee of tho the miners miners' federation warned the government government government gov gov- that IC If tho motion was wag re rejected rejected re- re it would bo be the tho miners miners' business to decide whether to demand a big wage increase to get g-ct their share sharo of oC wages or take steps to compel tho the government to utilize the surplus profits profits prof pro its of ol tho miners to bu buy out tho the share share- holders Mr Braces Brace's amendment was defeated b by a a. vote of oC 29 29 to 64 |