Show November o when de debate alc on the reservation reserva tion ion was begun The vice president said that such would bo be his Ms ruling SIne Nine Ien I n Vote Yote NoOn Xo No On tho the roll call can on Senator Lod Lodges Lodge's es e's motion to suspend the rules nine s en- en senators sen- sen voted no as follows Borah Dorali Brandegee France lorance Knox MCCormick lie lie- I Cormick Norris Poindexter Gronna and ami Sherman Senator Fernald was the thc only one ono of ur the thc to switch on this vote ote th tho others being either cither absent or paired When hen Senator L Lodge moved to re reconsider reconsider reconsider re- re consider the vote ote b by which the treaty treat was voled voted down Senator Norris orris made madea a 3 point of or order on three grounds First Senator Lodge was ineligible to make malce such a motion because he did not vote with tho the prevailing prevailing- side second sec see ond because e the matter sought to be reconsidered had already alread been reconsidered reconsidered reconsidered recon recon- and third because it was fInall fi finally finally fI- fI nall nally di disposed ot or in a preceding session session ses ses- sion slon of or Congress Upon roll call the rulin ruling was sustained sus sus- tamed G 62 to 10 Senator Lodges Lodge's motion to send end the resolution back to his committee was adopted unanimously unanimous without a roll call after Senator Hitchcock had made mado madean madonn an nn ineffectual effort to have o the tho resolution reso lution read that the treaty treal should b bo reported to the without an any a reservations lions |