Show Insurance Monopoly Voted Down bot n in Senat Senate ADOPTS MOTION TO TO i CUT THAT FEATURE FROM OLSON BILL Question ton l Regarding Platform Pledges Is Uppermost Upper Upper- most in iii Debate Republican l Press ress Is Charged With rUh Swaying Democrats S h D B By Y A VOTE YOJI of 10 to 8 8 the Utah the Utah State Senate yesterday ester s- s afternoon decided to take the tile exclusive vc state insurance feature out of or the tile Olson bill bi to amend the time present workmen's compensation n J Jaw w. w The flue law lw was almost identical l with wih that taken a n few days ago for the time insertion insert on of oC the w words not t to exceed before the time multiple of three in the time mine tax measure Y Voting otin for the motion moton by Senator Chez which was to strike from tU Olson bill bi one nc of the sections involving nol monopolistic state insurance were wee Senators Bevan Bradley Chez Clyde CIde H Kimball Kimbal Knight Lamph Parker and Voting to retain the time section were Senators rs Bern Dern J Jon Jones on s McKinney Olson Sanford South Southwick wick and am and Stevens and President Funk unk One the tIme nine mine tax bill bi Senator Chea CheB had voted wih with the other crowd while Senator Dern In the present instance instance- decided us as he said to stand hitched to the Democratic platform l Favor nor Parker BUI Dil TIme The he vote of ot yesterday fg is i believed ed bele to have ha killed time the th chances kled of ot the Olson Olson Ol 01 son measure becoming a a law Several sena rs after the time session were study tudy lug ing Ing the rival measure on oms the Senate calendar which was Introduced b by Son Son- Sn- Sn ator V. W J. J Parker of or Ogden The They eX expressed 1 pressed the opinion that In all al probability probability ability it i would be an easier casler task to amend the Parker measure measure which Is he h. ultraconservative into what the tho Senate Senate Sen Sets ate wants trants than It would be bo to amend out of o the Olson bill bIl the monopolistic features It I Is quite probable that either cither a motion moton to substitute the Parker Park Park- er Cr r bill bi for tor the tho Olson measure or else to strike out the enacting clause oC of the Olson bill bi will wI be bo presented t to the Se Seriate Senate ate when it meets tills this morn morn-i morn Ing li Ing To Today a will wi be the fourth entire day day devoted by bv the thc Senate to the consideration consider consider- atlon aton 0 of the workmen's compensation I question queston At the close of or yesterday afternoon four tour entire sessions of or tho th lit Senate had been given iven over to the on one on question queston of oC whether the bill should provide for Cor exclusive state insurance Insurance The Theote vote ote was ws the last act of the Senate for Cor the day a- a with wih the exception of re receiving re- re cei some communications from the governor concerning the tho signing of ot some some bJ bills and the reception also of ot the supplementary budget om Ds D's Votes Yote ot In the afternoon Mrs Irs Elizabeth I Hay a. a 0 ward opened the debate with a statement state state- state state- mont ment of oC her position with regard to the time platform pledge It I was that after aler all al it i was not workmen's compensation ion tion ton that had elected the Democrat part party Three years ago It had bad been the slogan logan He k kept Pt U us out of ot war Last year car It I was the slogan Stand b bhe by bythe the he President And In each case Mr Mrs Hayward thought that it was th time the women's vote that had carried tho the Democrats into power She would vote te according according- to her own convictions con con- state h ton insurance on the question queston of ot exclusive Senator Archibald Bevan Beran presented some of ot tho ho arguments for the Cues moton motion In a speech the principal feature feature fea lea ture of which was his colloquy with wih Senator C. C L L. Olson with wih regard to th the nature of oC a document from which th the speaker was reading Speaker Rend Head Lines Line J What are are you OU reading from In In the Salt Lakers Then he hc realized realized real real- that in asking a direct question he was trans transgressing the Senate rules rule When these had compile comphie with tho those thosa e emore more formally Senator Bevan refused to answer and he lie never did tell tel what I he had been reading from frons Later In Inthe Inthe the lie day Senator Joseph Chez read read- read from from froma a similar document upholding a as he sal said the ideas presented there Before Before Be Be- Ee fore tore the thc debate had closed Senator Ol Olson 01 son soil on waved wa another copy cop of or what ap at to be lie tho time same document in the theair theair theair air and called caled It a brief of ot Insurance company compau misrepresentation Many Maimy lal 0 Q oC Its Is statements he declared are arc false Senator Olsons Olson's final speech was wa largely lanely a declaration of what he h had h d meant b by the insurance lobby In It Ithe itlie I he lie included the newspapers commercial commercial commercial commer commer- cial organization ann and the Influence which had persuaded f the governor to use the time words freak legislation In his hi biennial address address' and which caused that wor word to be bo taken up and directed against t such uch bills as that being belim con eon He lIe said the same ame int influence had dominated the workmen's ts compensation compels compels- n. n commission named b by Governor Spry four years ars ago That hat commission commis sion had brought in a report he said that planned to place a u tax tu on hindus Indu- try try- and to turn insurance graft loose loos Ho lie s said ald Republican editors of ot I lican Ican newspapers were s swaying the th Democrat party Senator Chez In closing the time debate devoted his attention largely to the tho question Il of or monopoly and the ar arguments l- l ments queston th that t had lal been blen advanced In th lie morning by b President J. J 1 W. W Funk Senator J. J W. W V. V had acer Go Governor Gornor er am from rota hIm lm an au interview In which the governor as asserted that lint he lie had hal not ha lund had the present present present pres pres- ent bill In mind when whelm he wrote about freak Creak bil legislation Senator J J. J W. W Knight replied to this reading again from rein the time governors governor's o address but this tIme the sentence enten e referring time h he left out the to o freak le legislation Senator S Richard e ex explained cx- cx his liis vote b by saying that he did didlot not lot think the present the proper time timeo timeto to o enact exclusive e state Insurance though hough h he lie did think that it would come come- como two wo or possibly four tour years ears he heme o. o U T He said suid that tos compensation insurance rates rate sai In n regard to his Industry at least were far ar too hl high h. h Senator Is a 4 canner Senator U U. T. T said he would vote ole ote for the party larth platform pledge althou although al- al thou though though- he thought t tho Ito pr present pent law law hould should h be tried out for a while longer When hien the debate closet closed the time only senators sen- sen tora who h had hl l not spoken on the time ques ques- Ion before them were Senators Bradle Brad- Brad le Icy lon ey Ch Clyde e. e L and ni-md Stevens Threw Three or of f these voted for tho the motion moton and ono one t against It it I. I |