Show A TELLS OF MAGNATES MAGNATES' WAR AR FOR IRON lANDS Carnegie Company Mulcted by byI byr I r Rockefeller Violation of Agreement it KT L TEV EW YORK K Feb 28 John S.-John John D. D FN N NEW N Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie Cl each other In the late to the I-ako I Superior ore oreil il ind Mf M. r. r caught Mr tr Carnegie's Carnegles company violating an agreed agree nent ment and ton forced ed It to Rive glye I e up ore ort properties containing containing- tons tone to testimony at the thc hearing dissolve the ole United Unitt Stat States s Steel cor- cor I to un under er the Sherman antitrust i Flaw resumed here toda today toda Jamel Gayley GaJc former vice president ot oC and director an a tit tho Ste Steel 1 company previous the In b the corporAtion acquisition to Its the While MI Gatey Gai- Gai was ho be had to memorY tey jeys minute min min- to tho b references by freQuently company compan he told Carnegie tho i ute te of ot pavIng been plc- plc Rockefeller Of lr Ir scareCrOW or of th tiie Industry In- In as a ot of vast ast astron control hI his or of because In the su- su iron r ore properties district district dIetrIct He lie testified also to ef- ef or of the Carnegie com company pan to ob- ob In the district as properties t neW neVo aln that representations of or the result tho o join hart had proposed to Mr lr the Steel comp companY n Federal Iut tho control the tho rival rhal to big ot of steel the same sam as ic does oes oil l property j 11 if Mr r. r Ga Gayley le described acquired ore oro by br th the Car Car- after oro property when the In the period negle company between the t iw tWi wo ed compe competition alleged The fhe Lake lec hu Su- Su keen hie Interests was wae comy corn com Consolidated Iron Mines Mr r. Rockefeller b by controlled an any y control controlled cd iron Hon Company h the Minnesota which In hi tb 6 the Federal St Steel el company compan Oil tio late H. H H. H Roberts Standard the Ol r had an t anti and man nian th the theL control controlled ed by br companY of or the owned Carnegie lo compan L dis- dis lands In the I lal Superior rc From according to the witness thc minutes or of of the Carne Carnegie le companY compan company Into evidence c b by cou counsel for the thc the the Con Con- that t. t it appeared agreement as Mae company made an a the Minnesota compan whereby hereby fl was to purchase latter company compan tha j n 1 n nV in c its mines n from rom the consolidated A A similar was ml miu math P between time the Con- Con carnegie Carnele co company compan and th tho Mi Mr h according to jit It then developed C Carnegie le t testimony that the Carne company In 1900 violated It Its Iti agreement agree agree- containing con- con ment and auti purchased properties taming tons o of ore I This l 5 said the witness resulted In a meeting in New ew York between him- him elf and another o official III of or th the thA Carr Car- Car r company compan and John D. D Rocks Rocks- Fre Frederick T. T I feller Jr Tr and the R Rev I Gates r Mr Rockefellers Rockefeller's Ir ore agen agent tOre t- t I Ore Demanded I hT T Gales Galen Did Dill Mr Gates demand of the time Oliver I that there thero should hould be Mining MInin com company pAn turn turned d over to the tho Consolidated company com com- tons lons pan pany without condition of ot ore arc acquired b by the Oliver Iron company compan In contravention of or the agreement agree agree- meat ment between tho two companies asked I Jacob M M. Dickinson attorney for forthe time the government Jo Mr Ir Gates Oates did m make ke- ke such a demand at at the time lime but hut wo explained that tin tinder under tin un- der the agreement ment Mr r. r Rockefeller was not J supplying us with all the ore lands we f needed your contention pr prevail Vell Vell wo we turned tho time properties over overto overto to then them which mr may b be construed d as an admission that their claim was wa correct cor cor- smiled Mr II They a agreed to make a new deal ical however o un under cr which we wo were wen to receive larger ton- ton 1 |