Show MURPHY discharged evidence brought out at hearing monday to hold him arthur murphy accuse 1 of being tl e man who dangerously stabbed sullivan in alie fracas at die half ay bouie on the night of december allt i wag brought up from the county jail monday anil arranged arram ged before ity justice bockl art on a charge of assault with a deadly weapon glenry shield acting as allton ey t r defendant murphy entered a plea of not guilty and I 1 ugene sullivan slept en addy I 1 dnard craze chaa and james I 1 cliette nere in as witnesses showed that murphy had been maltreated mal treated by other boarders at the half ay house and 1 ad anin jt I 1 alien tl e occurred on tl e night of tl e aith mur came down town with a companion and upon return ii g foai d that someone bad been in his room and disturb d if belongings lie went to bed however but was 1 shortly afterwards ly tt e into bis room of dark toole and sullivan and a dispute ensued ab jut a mirror which bad beau broken during a absence iu ton n slur phy room fantl 1 to ale they retired but returned in a short time arm ed with clubs and mailing defendants life they drove bibi out ot alg room not evdo him a to dress he went to hia corn room jonne I 1 a borrowed suit of clothes and came doa toaia fur tie sheriff wl 0 with deputy aiex rt right went immediately tu tl e scene of tl e trouble them ash rt distance how ever and entered the bouse first sheriff alair testifying thai when I 1 e lot tl ere 1 e 1 eard a cry ur 1 elp va ii asked vil y lie VM BO to let back replied tl at I 1 biad belt 35 in 01 e f tb pockets of a air of trousers be had in his room and that 1 0 wanted to see that it ft is all right vlen be reached the trousers 1 is money was gone and goit g to he asked him about it and aard hat if be 1 ad it in had better dig up I 1 quick 1 houi tins point tl 0 mony differs it bein true that a etrig gle ensued in which sullivan was stab bed dr 0 ard testified that he had been gammo ned to dress the injured man B wounds which he found to of a bad scalp wound behind the left air and a etab wound just abaye the left nipple the weapon 1 abing en ered the pleural cavity he considered tl e wound dan berous he also found cuta on 8 right hand sheriff mair testified that murphy had no knife when he reached him and the complaining witness could not lively affirm that he had teen a knife in lelen lanta band after 1 canne tl e evidence judge lockhart LocK bart the case and dia charged the pr H e supposition is that while murphy and sullivan aira in tl e room which was but dimly lighted one 0 the other men meant to attack murphy but iol the wrong man |