Show r PANAMA MA OCCUPIES CC Sf Tt TIO Mr Ir Carm cli in a l Set Sel Speech Criticised Course At Length MR MB SPOONER DEFENDED IT War Var of Waged aged Senator Inevitably Being It Washing ton Jan 13 again today was WIS the principal subject of or con consideration In the senate and nu ns on yen r the thu detente debate wits win spirited Mr Ca Carmack mack opened ol ened the proceedings with n nitch net itch speech leech In criticism of or time the th presidents course COurM find was followed by Mr 1 Spoon Spooner er or I the only other speaker sneaker of oC the day da In defense of ot the Die presidents action as law abiding In defense of oC the president himself OH aa a patriotic brave and true trueman trueman man Mr Ir frequently Interrupted Mr Spooner and there were wore H II number of oC sharp encounters encounter between them When tho rho senate adjourned the Par Pan Panama Parama ama arM question was still before the sets sen senate 11 ate and IIII It 1 was announced the discus slot would woul tI he bo resumed tomorrow utter after the disposition of the depart department ment Inquiry resolutions Mr II r moved to strike out of the tho Groman resolution on un Panama the fifth firth section which provides And also to 10 Inform the senate senat which words wit ids If It f any nn In thus tho treaty tiC or orl m l authorized tho the United in I tho limo opinion of or the president to In enter by hy military force and uninvited Into the territorial jurisdiction of New Ne or Colombia In III order to pre prevent prevent vent the Interruption or embarrass embarrassment meat ment of ot tree free radio across the tho Isthmus S S T Mr Me O contended that lint President I dent lent had hrad not contented him himself Mf self with recognition of oC Panama Tanana but had Intervened Ills His acts were not simply offensive not simply II pi a i can cause no for tor war but hut they ero war ho aid aidI I As AM a n matter milter of fact act t tany there hero never asset was s any Insurrection on the Iho Isthmus l salt said Mr bin They The speak of the tM ris rit rising fug ing he Bald OB as the Iho net act of one ono man manVery manVery Very Vrr true trul and 1111 that one man was the tho president of oC the United States Discussing 1 the act of or Col ol Black of the United States Staten army In iii raising the first flair flag In the Panama republic the senator criticised him I 1 do lID donot donot not bellove l that Col Cob Black would have havo engaged In this thin plot If It ho had not ot Lo be boo Moved that ho was doing tho the will of or the Mr Carnack wald said the Iho president had denied that he be hlll hail encouraged tho the Panama j Insurrection but bul no greater ler encouragement could bo he shown than by giving Mr Ur and a n few tow other choice spirits a n hint that If It a u revolution was seas started It would receive recel the support of or the tho United States 11 In 1011 Pros Pres Pr s Ident ho he said loses tho the pow ow cr ar r of oC reasoning rell and his hie moral senses when ho becomes Involved In lit noton net nn end exclaimed Into Inlo what d di Is h Ismay may we IVe not bo be led lerl by Ihli r r Plan He ne makes history nt nn n d II dorder dorder order n IL tin sue that Hint the th star performer Is uil 1110 H 5 in m the tho confer coaler of the stage atnee ly h for Cor u n 1 file tho Ife le went on to ny say that tho the prod dents course coarse In this matter was not lIot merely m nn net act but a IL policy rand Indi call of DC his lilt character It was not meant for Cor Colombia alone LIane but was the beginning of or a system of or med with the of the tho countries of or central and South Houth America such n a policy must Inevitably involve us liS In hI war not flat only with the South American nation themselves but hut with In III conclusion Mr Ir that he was fur for the tho he canal ranul he could not vote vole for Cor the treaty bo be because cause he could auld not endorse tho the lawless nets acts of ot which It Is the fruit ASKS When Mr Sir Ir took look his hili seat sent Mr Aldrich liked wham practical system Mr had hael to otter offer Defeat the tho treaty treats responded Mr Th Then n what 1 Build the Nicaragua canal Ah All responded Mr Aldrich that Ihal In iii tho the milk In ht the cocoanut Mr Ir Aldrich proceeded to ny say that lie he was wan In III favor of oC building the Iho nna nUll and building G It now no Mr II replied to Mr Ir lint ho he had hal felt regret at hear har ing IlIg the lie criticising of at the president who had hall registered nn tut Ill oath In III heaven henell to discharge lily huts duties ditties Mr Carmack had hlll made mado n a sinister find IntI unsupported statement when he hr mild Bald that this coun COUll country try hud hail hi begun I a IL uncut en on tin the Ih rights of ut tho the South Houth Ameri American can dill republics No snot man had ii ad stood morn mom for tor those hone republics than had hlll 10 lent nt and Mr M 1 tint the course courso of ot tho the president In III tho the Venezuelan No president In our history had haul stood more staunchly for Cor the Iho Monroe due doc doctrine trine Mr Ir r also alma gore gave attention lion to tho the charges of Ot disobedience dl of or law I IV by hy the tho president re An As 14 the author r of ot tho Uio Spooner net act the inn spanker soul said ho lie wished to 10 express the tho opinion 01 II I Ifill that that bunt law hail had not been violated by h what saint lint the president hind hail done The Tho low law he lie until mold recognized the ml su of ot tim tho Panama route because O OIt It 11 short horl nail and O It woe mums mix ble of or being made n a sen level mast Not only the but bul the tho th defense of nt ho the country might put Jut n II canal through which our worships could coil ld pries pass without going through locks lochs QUESTION STION TO MAN After A tho time events to 10 the 1111 ennui negotiations Mr Ir II noted whether any Rny senator would under un 1111 dor der tho Ilm have hlo turned his bark baric on Panama so 10 long as 18 there thero was vas wase n e 1 Jill bill pending In lima Colombian cot con congre all gre Ir gress and ind he put pal lilt Ilia Iho question especial especially to la Mr who was 1111 on his hl troll Tito latter said Mid he lime would have entered Into Ulo negotiations with ss Nicaragua and rind would reported cock Jilek to Congress further Instructions He inc would then have n maid hl to 10 Colombia You Vou ou arc mangy 11 It lot i get off ort the Iho face of or the tho earth take mike tho the country and build ennui This Thle remark caused canned an outburst o of oC t laughter both bolls on Oil the floor Moor of oC the senate and In tim tho galleries After a minutes pause Mr 1 Spooner said that while he could not accept tho the senators senator language he congratulated con 1 him on coming to the Iho presidents pre peel position I I tion Mr called l attention to Mr Spooners hesitation and tho the latter hatter re replied 0 plied that It was wall because use he lie was think thinking ing how thankful we tee should be that wo we hav have hae not a H president who would use to 10 any nation such language as nil the tho senator from South Carolina had used used Replying to 10 the man and not to the senator Mr Ir inked asked Mr Ir Spooner whether he would not prefer it u president who says In plain words word get out of ot the Iho way rather than to have hMO one mixed up In the bastard bas lard birth of or the republic of at Panama Continuing Mr Ir Spooner warned the tha Democrat that a 1 platform which Im Ira Imputes puke dishonor to time the administration and I nt to 10 the brave true man In the Ih White WhiteHouse House will wit flail find no sympathy with time thu people of ot the United States State north or south to a 1 question from Mr r Newlands Mr Ir Spooner said Hull that Co Colombia o lombia had sought the treaty but he did not consider that the failure of ot that government to ratify thee the treaty was a n trench breach of or International law IN ASKS AlmS QUESTIONS Mr Tillman nuked asked if Jt n a discreet man would not idad have hae waited on Con on grese before hetor warning Colombia oft off her hor own awn preserves pre erell at Panama to and tI Mr Spooner answered r In the negative say saying sayIng ing Jog that the safety the Iho honor the tho Interests 18 of ot the Ihl United States required that a II president should do Just what Theodore Roosevelt hail had done dono Mr urged that Mr Ir had evaded time the real reHI question What he ho w wanted 11 to 10 know was Willi whether the tho president dent teed had hn the right ID to t use uso tho rho army anny u and nd navy ns as he ho hud hilt done Oh Ix Lord rd exclaimed Mr Sir Spooner You Yoh will hove to call on Oil the tho Lord frequently In this matter retorted Mr Ir Tillman I did not nol address the Iho senator from Smith South Carolina my remark lemark was wall not personal sold said Mr lIt Spooner Mr bir Ir Spooner declared that the tho president pre l dost dent hail had acted within the tho and rind the law In all nil that he ho had I done Ilone In Panama J He Ito said paid that he hI for forone one resented n th time Imputation that l tho time president tend had been unscrupulous In ht his hl dealing with this question This lost last w nude made after Mr Ir Till man had expressed the opinion that tho the American consul had bribed tho the Co eo Colombian o forces lo to withdraw from the Isthmus l fhe The lust consideration of ot tho time Spooner net much was that the tho right to build h a I canal should lie he secured and that end curl unit had been Ileen accomplished by b not with Colombia but hut with Panama Pamma J Colom buns bias successor This woo Just lust n a its legit legitimate I trial e ho ha s mil ri as RM the transaction tits e I would have havo been boen If It It hall hail been between Individuals IIo Jo Invited the opposition apposition to t o test tho time question by nn early curly vote ote and rind closed with n 11 defense of oC the this president 1 Id e mi t ns liS asa n a 1 brave and frank crunk man aunt who tries to 10 do what the tho law The senate nt et adjourned uThe with the understanding that the sub nub subject would be Le resumed tomorrow |