Show WILLIAM VILLIAM D. D HAYWOOD AGAIN i A BREATHES THE AIR OF LIBERTY I t. t i TWELVE Tl HONEST MEN fI SAY HE IS INNOCENT I. I Verdict in Famous Case Conj ConI Considered Con Con- j I Signal Triumph for Organized Labor SCENES IN COURTROOM Accused Secretary First st to Carry Home the News of His Acquittal y BY llY J J. J S S. DU NIG DUNNIGAN iL l Ida 28 Not Not n Jul July guilty guilt William D D. is with his family free tree acquitted by b twelve c Idah farmers o of the chur charge e of or conspiring conspiring t ti to murder former Governor Frank Steu Steu- men of or the s fOIl ll I gave the s-cc s cc rotary of oC the miners miners' miner Ce federation th th'S the S 'S I square deal he asked for Cor The Thes twelve men mon deny the states state's accusation tion toll the confession of or Orchard and the th evidence o of the that hay Ilay Ia- Ia oo wood was wa the chief hl r o of a conspiracy I tho the tenets of or which were I There was waH no Independent evl- evl nc to connect the defendant ant with wih crime for Cor which he was vas h men who hO yc f L ko co the conspiracy charge of oi W tn t were veLo neighbors or and mal many of ot of jt V t tb n W s of the mu murdered i p x ro c i One of ot the men tr f f o d' d I Innocence i f l' l n Inc Irie wa A A. Robert Robert- RobertY r Y j son t o de t ma i map mayi the of-the at Wh Whose sc h J lU rs I ed l foj- foj fo fono or two o 1 Wh lw he was wa lef leC lIet executive F I. I of or ln 1 H Robertson l Males i tb 1111 i C cd bf the e t J 3 r ten t c A-c ti c I Thus r us the thc JT toi trl i l f dk to 10 an- an at end und r r nd lt 1 1 have hay le f u cl nr t Nd ld Jn In any I in Ift Ii f i tu J Qs u nOn t four hour the Jury ur de de- t lor our te- te Not N t a sign or ora Ola a sQUad i by by X T their nd s 1 nc CI t u Y Il r bYk co 1 1 y n f IV J p Ic wouly 1 f Ut of hf lf r mtr 1 after These men b 11 p through the UH Jury stood J 1 ten tn for tor murder In the first degree and two for second degree that the ther r I Vote vole WItS was cleon eleven to one for or I und that one une ob obdurate Juror alone aloner r r tool stood out l keeping 1 a trout from the thc gallows guhlow During this time state lale I Irl correspondents c rl cl else expected Uv result r c everybody e 1 would bt lr br a dl nt But nut at al T j o'clock this morning wien Judge o I Wood re received l cl th tho m m e the jury jur a to t r ort every evOry nt lost man of tJ S bul th thin verdict would that he ho ho lH I tho titu d defendant and AS Cither bo 1 condemned to the thc ll lo tU on for lf lif Hay Hay- Ia-I Ia I this Ibis belief b 1 le l r r. r f c uld not Hot bo be pm pos vc e C all r. r f ci t U tight ht th that t lw Jur Jun would stU stay nhi with only hilly r man mall 4 4 lj and n i bring brin g In I vother than guilty guity Am in 4 Otto OUo Peterson ul I ul t i Not ot e cr every P I 1 3 11 of his voice t t- t 1 t Jurors n f i course were 1 lr Not Nol one re recovered If- If covered tU tUl iu- Juge Wood directing tic the ct d rk k to tu enter an anord ord r l I f from cus cus- tody tol We the Jury jua mid tho defendant William llam D. D Hay lay ni and Azil i here the thc clerk po paused used r 50 o Millie ever cel celI nerve on In tension every vr ver breath breth held helf held held- hel- hel I we waited for rOl the 1 syllable Hay f wood who had been prepared by I Dar Dar- f AV row fur forthe furte worst that could como cono coo t tt tc t him stu f led hm dC for tOI tho shock D Darrow Darrow- o was to so o nervous lie he could no nOI I alt l IC still He lie had hal been ke keeping vigil al alJe Je night outside tw the ULC Iron fence that surl sur L.- L. l rounded the thu court yard and dispiriting reports report from I I f bailiffs Richardson pale a agitated i controlled himself Haywood Laywood t r the tho arms of or the chair In which he sa sai a ar for COL three months hearing accusation r i r Y und rund and denials not guilty popped poppel ou out t c U I f f Clerk Petersons Peterson's mouth I 1 on tins thc Haywood Jumped ur up uT grabbed his L c lint hut m t. t one way ay ay and aud then thenan an nn- 1 1 J. J other r RI ha d 1 c equally 71 I was going to lo address a dress the court and tat rat at down clown Danow 11 nerve r e went weaL He lie le wept I Inc 3 and embraced Haywood a 0 Chief eJ e- e 1 nc 01 J hawley who vho like Ice c everybody i elle else another kind of or a a. a ver- ver i 1 pr tr from Ills his chair looked g nor nOor left bolted past nelU neither Or to right Ilat i V-f V the jur jury r past h Haywood L and into wj v the Judge chamber r where Go Governor TV Gooding sat silt w at as he lie thought for a a verdict ul if guilty an and f tIe the governor hastened nc from the room 1 By this time Judge had hal told the the i jurors l that tho dl James A. A n jH old man mun who to b o nearly tottered loitered from the jUI Jury box weeping and graL grabbed ed Darrow saying yg r r Darrow Darr v. Darro w I 1 want vant ant to shake r r not guilty 1 your hand was JuU 4 Samuel A. A nu tC I. I next In ago age to Robertson stood waiting Availing lUng for Cor Darrow from his hi eyes his lips tears almost to lo speak he placed buth both hands handl upon the thc attorneys attorney's brol brokenly I It shoulders und and sobbed t 4 was with you ou always t t v WiS e old man al then tottered to Hay Hay- w siM ba grabbed him hini by bV the thc hand reo re- re o r the big Ii s and Ond to him nUI dl sl r. r 4 Tou ott oum ai are e It I and I 1 i I. I io come to tomy I nd d your om Boise yoU my holu homo home before beCore yo U In iii u Court hoO I G court room Joon scenes In Lii which was involved such uch vast importance ever cr c r thil Sab- Sab that compared 1 j with wih f IC La f wn exactly S furni- furni L L tU lui Hi about In r. r h floOr 1 91 L of r maga- maga pap p 11 Uttered littered with scraps scra s I r l C r 3 zhi co Ia 1 cigar CUl butts evidences I. I I V if t I q qI I of the long Jon vigil 11 from hom yesterday at 11 o'clock till tl last night at 10 10 when the newspaper men and anc others sal salIn ai at atIn In the court room walling action acton b bj by bythe the jur Jury Judg Wood was the thc only man who had hul Judg lu had rest reel ret during the nl night ht He was cear eyed clear rud ruddy strong the perfect perfect per per- man he has been leel during this trial trial The others had hal gone sleepless Heavy eyed and haggard they the scanned canned tho the faces of or the wear weary jurors Juror juror a as the they tiled Hied In from rom tho the adjoining room And of the these c twelve men th the older were ere tottering the younger staggering stag stab gering every e cr every last one showed he had been through a a terrific ordeal Robertson and nu Russell el who vho came caine r t were strong active e has lusty men when thc they took tool the oath three months ago This rids morning they thc were bowed with fatigue their steps tcP faltered Big D Finley McBean a giant u w u man of 01 middle years seemed devoid o of strength sufficient to car carry him him to hi his icat s seat and and so 50 wIh all al of them No o spectators were ther there other than the f few W correspondents of ot the big dailies half a n dozen bailiffs the thc deputies and the J lawyers All 4 1 li were within vI Ii I n the rail al 1 l I the th newspapermen nC U h counsel C table talie when the rTh mo was j h by Chief ChIc u VL WJ randi a dl District At- At t rn L rn Jt fronY rm Canyon CaJon COU lt S 'S r lt a J Sg S- S ag C tt wo lt to hot g t. t nt m tJ FM I l f was Jas able tl l JJ U Nunc W f J here His UtI 1 wh ho w al 1 akun alcen to a a. lw l a was no lot notified that tl Jury j was to o 0 report report- No Nu word sits s sent to nl to Un Hay Hay- s home hi his wife wie ind two tw children w wr were waiting r. r waiting wn It I anc ivas sas H H line luck luck- luck that gave hl i the outs y privilege gc l of breaking the glud glad 11 i ws to 10 t those hose v. t IC him best bt J Ho lie rushed to to the lo Uie no in Judge Ju ge Vo Woods Wood's ds d's chamber r calc called up UI his home and said aId lo Jils elder dau c be with them In lii cv a- afew few that h c le r. r ie moments u iA There Thole W was r rejoicing l 11 home hom Out of or the door l o i I Ia a across n th lawn law lawi 1 tho gate with he went vent up UI f U the c hu hust ll ng lie He wa bound url l r t He lie le walked waliN nt Into At f J oom nom They were t I t had told lold her mother I would come conic conice e flu CiU au this morning he lie said sil h f at ut him Inquiringly I r alone ahone arp Then the mother knew After r that Haywood had hal a 0 day tiny tiny- tH first In eighteen months months ti to go go goI al aid conic come as he be pleased and he ho I hal hastened nc home anti and ant Oice once more sat rt at al table with hl his r cO courageous suffer suffering brer t lag ing wife and his two daughters i Later Laler on on Haywood went wen to se c his Jil loyal steadfast friend and counsellor John II H Murphy the Denver attorney whose c hours hOUS hOU'S arc numbered Thc hc last ll Jove l ben P tl to Mur- Mur and nd though Cn he hopes hoites hOles qc to lo re- re Hurn Hurn to p er 1 with I he hc heI I has tl mt t hope When he Tie came h here r the he hand bf be t kas on him and he hc ho ho can o to take Bill BUI Ha Haywood him wood home home home ln will wi tal e The GO GOl Governor Governor- iO enter l O Ol Will l See c Governor Gooding and amI lu lue Hawley e are arc solely dl UI at thc UH result o of the trial Naturally friends share their sentiment The he verdict ver cr diet dict this morning moring in the judgment o ol 01 e everybody here annihilates es the tho a co con charge laid lUlU against me we leaders lead ers p pf pC Ute tile Western Federation of or Min lu- lu ers Oj Orchards Orchard's chard's confession has brought no ro result roul ul other than Ulan to compel It would seem the au authorities of Idaho to lo give him a a quick trial lilai and the thc punishment meted muted by y the thc Jury JUl We Ve dont don't know yet how Orchard feels I have asked permission to Interview him but it I is more than likely the tho request will wi be refused The governor governor- says ho will wm see I 1 think the world worl would like to if ho is prepared as a he said sM he was on the witness winess stand to lo KO go JO to lo the scaffold an and pa pathe pathe pay the penalty for cruelly wantonly and I wickedly d destroying Frank Steu non non- berg A b to lo I There j is Otto one character now that tho the case co Is over I feel Ceel that Something should be said raid l about is hs Detective James Self gloried self self- boastful egotistical blundering blundering blun blun- dering he has ha boosted day dar day and nl night ht that that these men would woul be convicted con that In the man many many man many years ears ho has ha gone into C court times Innumerable merable he ha has t a case nc When the tho Idaho are arc FO 50 o situated that thai they the l l on themselves themselves them theta selves it I will wi t that thai Governor Gu Gooding Gooding and ld Pro br I hawley lawle were deceived by f cP td I ha have haNc haC C been told toM by those aru the thc confidence of or these officers that promIs promised prom prom- Is evidence e promised witnesses es up to 1 the day a the lJ t began and then he told 1 the tie that these who ho had reported were the most Important li In the case re refused re- re fused to come como to Idaho and testify Darrow Moyer Haywood Richard Richard- son on crone C everyone connected with de- de cf c- c f terse make maize no rio 10 word of or t Governor Gooding Th The s rf y all ns-all must sa say h ho did dd his dul duty CIl II l Page Two T T o i t- t S T I j JL NILLIA WILLAM o. o II HAYWOOD BREATHES TilE THE TiE AI AIR OF LIBERTY I Continued from toni rum lI Our Hut there thore ho 10 fin any fault found with Governor GO Gov Gooding It Jt can only be Le that limit ho trusted McFarland I loit Pour I In ii That rhut this case cae was vas WIS watched l in ill the tho four limit IU corners of the earth Is emphasized em em- by y the toc loud flood oo of oC l telegrams le Ia has received e l since this hits morning ng From FIor minin mining iOng cain camps ps I In it northern California prospectors Jn In n the Much Hills lUlls an and Cripple Creek exiles In Death Vale Valley coal miners In Penn Penn- sylvania sympathizers rs In otti orth Car Carolina Caro Caro- o him lina friends and supporters In New York 11 Boston Doston Chicago San Francisco tc wishers well I I I- I wishers I in n Texas Texas everywhere a few hours homs men an and l women nave sent telegrams of or congratulations to tu the tho vindicated miner l of or Orchard Here e CIC is a good place fr the he estimate esti esH- j mate placed by y tj toe c jurors upon the lie ci Ce edibility of Orchard Under tho the law lawS lawand S 5 and the Instructions of oC the he court court tho the Jurors were compelled to 0 disregard t the thc 1 testimony of Orchard until unU theyon they thoy found on n d I independent t testimony o ny tha Um tided tended to Lo establish the ti-ic defendants defendant's defend defend- anUs ants ants guilt That Is statutory Hut BUl these Jurors whom Prosecutor Prose Prose- Hawley complimented upon having hay hav oa lug ing a largo large share hare of horse hoise sense agree agreed l that Oi Orchard chard while he told Lold some things that were true was sas not hot to bo Lo believed cd bele in er e everything e We agreed among ourselves said Juror Russell that Orchard told the thc about his Ills crimes in ill most in In- In L- L stances We e 0 did not all ni agree fully asto as asto asto to tho the rest of ot his statements T r bc- bc that he lie was tc testifying to savo O his hison own on n neck ck I Some Seine of oC the Limo other jurors were in inclined in- in In-I In dined l to believe c much of his story but hUl the they wore were unanimous on tho the proposition prop prop- that no 10 was wa not nol corroborated Here ar are arc brief details of what transpired In the jur jury room told me nic meby meby by a Juror Juror- In lit Their Retirement At Al 11 1130 30 yesterday lay Thomas B. B l. l Gess was chosen foreman and anti a ballot balot was taken alwn Eight m men n vote voted l for Cot 01 acquittal J two for 01 mur murder el in the degree an and amid two blanks Oilman Gilman Giman and Powell Powel voted for fOI conviction Gess an and Burns vote voted l blank In au an hour or so another ballot ballot ballot bal bal- lot was wa tal taken en which stood nine lot for acquittal two Co for I conviction con one blank Gess ha had l changed c l Just after supper the third thir l ballot was taken and Juror Burns lUns went with wih the lie majority making the vote ten to two Oilman Gilman Giman an and l Po el Powell stan standing out The rime fourth ballot was taken talen at midnight It I was wasten wasten as asten ten to t two At a a. a in m. Powell Powel went over O on the he fifth baJot ballot Gilmar alone stood out out Oilman Giman informed his fellow jurors that It I was no use he lie could not agree with wih them an and l they argue argued l anti and talked talked talk talk- ed an and l sou sought ht to convince him Finally Fin Fin- all ally he said ho would think it i over o that he lie would woul l try ry to sleep sheep a little while an and afterwards ls would talk talt with wih them again At 5 G o'clock they hey awakened Oilman told Lold him lOin the they wanted ranted l him to take lake another ballot All Al right said sail Oilman Giman I wont won't stand out against you OU boys an any lon longer er I will vilI wi vote to acqui acquit t Then thc they rested reste l until 7 o'clock when they hey took the he mat final bal ballot which t Ir fn r lna I I I J 1 I ani and Now OW what of or Moyer an and l Pettibone The rho state officials a assert ser tonight these two defendants will wi be prosecuted l vigorously The attorneys s 's for Cor the he defense deren de do- ren e sa say that the |