Show BUTLERS BILL the vote in the seriate senate r 32 to 25 MEND amendments RIENTS VOTED DOWN strong opposition to the bill by senators cullom allison All lson aldrich mid and burrows barrows the latter cally declared he would rather his country should have gone down in the stol storm of war than to vote for it gorrills morrills moi Mor rills speech on the tariff is nn an anti silver speech Wits hington D C juno 2 tile the senile at I 1 today bortay in anthel PR ala of tho the closing struggle and final lote on oil the duller bill to prohibit the issue sua of bonds in reporting the militia yon bill mr hawley raid eald it 11 would not bo be called up until nel next nelt t session gorrills SPEECH mr morrall was recognized tor for a epoch on the tariff ills earnest manner and strong voice gave no indication of 0 his advanced ago age lie ile referred to the emergency tariff bill passed by tho the llo house ulle and paid fald taft democrats have lave broken away from tile the leadership of oc their Prell dent and still marching to tile hie ilium and life of a north carolina captain ure aro in such dread lost lest tile iho populists lists should vt oo 00 control trot ot of their party that they teem seem to to bo be in it a huary to 10 become lists the senator the republican party never would trade its on the money question in order to 0 secure sod sed higher tariff duties ile ho predicted d the platform of the republican panty of 1856 would place every dollar ot of our money in circulation on a with tte the best dollar in the world and declared the political ground under the democratic party appears dangerously volcanic inic continuing he eald bald xo no doubt had our country been by a sound bound krotec protective ties tariff during the hopeless years ot of the present democratic administration much business bul ns distress and won tit of unemployed labor might male have been averted aloyed but ut another adverse anddore and sore bewitchery of 0 all busund affairs in the united states state hardly less potent thana than a free tee trade tariff has been tho the unceasing nt of 0 tree free coinage of balver on oil a ratio mile that would not fall fail to reduce uie the value of our money as well as the whole fabric of public and p private rl credit to halt its 11 present value an invitation from the na da lions to join in a operative cooperative co agreement for or a larger money use of silver would by accepted by asp a republican adelaia administration tr tra tion but it would bo more desirable that tho the united states should receive rather amther than offer the invitation as aa the american production of silver Is so large that any initiatory stop step on our part might subject us to a charge ot of bring being inspired by the purpose so of securing a better market for our a annual domo domst stio lo product were it us as certain as tome rome extreme diver advocates advocat ado adio cat cates represent that no cooperative mont among tile tho leading nations tor for a larger us use of silver ran can be obtained that fact alone would lie 0 o EL a cogent and sufficient reason why the alie united states should decline to stultify itself by embarking in an experiment so and so 60 distrusted HS As to t be chunn shunned e d and coldly rejected by the state soil n of nt eve evey every y eil enlightened lightened nation but tills hopeless representation of tho the sliver diver question in europe rura Is untrue VIP ti tron i nf t public opinion in germany and and rest britain favors tolerance tolt rance of the question TRE THE BOND DEBATE at I 1 p m the butler bond bill was waa aken up the indian conference conf crenco ire report port going over sir air aldrich offered the following kmen amendment dment as an ail additional so section action to follow that prohibiting the issue of bonila bonds Vil gilless less in case of emergency it la Is necessary in the opinion of 0 the president of the united states and the secretary of the treasury to issue sue such bonds in with the pro proal vi alons lon of existing laws to preserve the hie public lublic credit or to meet obligations of the h united states created by such ex cc law cannot other otherwise wIge be met and all such bonds v nhen hen so I 1 aud shall first lle ba offered at ille a le bufore the debate proceeded mr III I 1 Fugg suggested ested that a vote on the brown solution resolution declaring I sues of future bonds Ill eiraj should fo follow llor the vote oto on the butler prohibitory bill mr me brown assented and mr butler imad 6 p ni tomorrow fixed as ail th the e time tor for the be vote on the brown ies lesolo alu thin hon sir mr hill Insist insisted kA however that the nt ft hole bond business should bo ba elred el red from tile floor today objections were made and no agreement was waa affected sir mr bronn then re fumed his spent df yesterday discussing jsang bonds and free free liver coinage II 11 mr r P brown rowa was waa followed by his hia utah ml league ll cague mr air cannon they had bad oc idled different positions on the dingley cy tariff bill the f former ormer having voted for and tho the latter against the consider alon mr cannon replied to strictures tode made on the five republican senators ollnie against the dingley bill lie he re rented the charge of insincerity ile he characterized charack razed the tariff bill 1112 as 04 an ln in equity ind and monstrosity of legislation sectional wt ional and unjust he bad been acquitted by ills his conscience and by his ants the live republican senara 14 who voted against the tariff bill h eald id have a all 11 the consol consolation stion they n ned d each having received the indorse ent t ot of hla his people at home borne ALLISON ON 01 4 tj 0 BOND BILL mr allason rp R p iowa ioa spore briefly TO on the bond bill ile he said raid it was well known loira that the bill could not lin bo ina IL aita laile it was va a agreed ee d he said that the borro bowing wowing lying of monay livy tor for tile hie goar govern n haftl tit was wa robely a 1 legislative I pa power e apt TO lit as m the he statutes statute conferred conf elred th that a i pier ler on tile axce autive branch under the ine thi of the llin croan rf rc boull be a of th 0 only uw law allowing jhc thc executive to 10 ito ra TOW money on oil bandh b dh ir ar aluli TI XII on d tin tile biad d in wf t to 10 tile ami bond law aw ot of 18 I 1 arrn alla jc h 1413 intended inton ded to ove overcome ine the instability la 11 alad panic anlo follow folio geog ine the war jin ile the ali aaser assert llon lo n made during tle tie debate ars bate that t the bo bonds ds under tile the law of s wiro were for or the go eolo I 1 purpose of re rc ina irmon back arld and then cancil hit f them n atter which which the bond power 1 sd I on the contrary he said it a aa to 0 be o IL a continuous power to give liability to values va no part of the garle it could ix be benefited benefit ed by a u S 0 ng 0 instable uns bable depreciated mono metal currency no experiment should be n SS I 1 ought in stability repealing the th vry very uw law which A il As 11 to the s from silver 11 clr r 0 a showed that could B t 1111 art until atter the silver was wag anel VIs vasi vas 1 that the pr pst Ps besent t mint ant capacity restricted i to t f orty fy or fifty y millions a elat that on 1 that amount the or ort ea would b le a limited cited to twelve fifteen tot lots 11 million so lie he sald said peni fena averi playing horse elih lit the QUen ou great quention of the sa pallor pap Y the were running the hazard of K gol bis ba K ir bar r in thit ty days dayn to it a paper not convertible into coin I 1 nr r A it i colloquy nuy with mr butler allison BM declared decla 6 hie opposition to walcy alch lit oney the and to ta th indirection by pending bill sought fought to tak 1 I a step lot toward free sliver silver coinage without batting for legislative action 1 I belleve believe that the united states cannot 0 open pl n I 1 hit lill s n ly I 1 the j ic free coinage of silver ve r without ou becoming ll 11 it a aello nation that ll it cannot take this up ehll OUt an agreement with mothr no t ions said raid mr avinon lson and I 1 will cot continue to vote against the free coln coin apo ap o of sliver at 10 16 to 1 by this countie alone mr air chandler deprecated the sahit and manner of tile the author of the bill butler iho ho had made threats and had bad tallied talked of nn AND BLOODSHED mr butler rialto to such utterances te rances mr chandler insisted that tile the S senators ina language had conveyed indirect t and had ten lel to revolution and bloo bloodshed dAled I ile he le hold up a newspaper which he raid wait tile hie published bv mr butler in north korth catoline nad aad m aich contained extreme violent attacks on oil senators and sherman Sher nian and ethels mith alln whom sir jr butler was lit in daily Inter intercom couise se As I 1 to the boud bond issues lesu eff mr chandler declared declared that tho the president and the secretary 0 of f the treasury were men of 8 terling lins personal persona integrity standing ai a re iffe senta tives of cf tile the credit of the government no one charges a llon lion or embezzlement or oc the funds which had been raised by the sale BAIO of bonds 1 I am thankful that two third s of the senators on this side of tile chamber eald bald sir mr chandler will voto vote against this bill and I 1 ask senators who participated in the election of president cleveland and in who he are of the patty of john G Cai lible to joll join with I 1 us a in at least one patric patriotic tie vote to protect our lionor honor and credit sir mr pettigrew Pett lerew rep S D rose to chilk a published hd statement that although an advocate of 0 free silver coina coinage geIbe he had agreed to support mckinley and sound money in order to become a delegate to the national convention ven tion mr pettigrew declared thit that the report revor was false houth kiiko ta convention had i referred the financial question to the Nati national onit convention and no vote was taken on silver NO connection WITH SILVER mr teller pointed out that the pending bill had no connection with tile the free coinage of sliver lie denied alto al 10 the right of mr chandler to speak tor for the Ite Publican party pally in favoring a continuance of bond issues I 1 mr teller referred contemptuously to those self satisfied pharisees Pharis ees who declaimed that th they ey were the only ones willing to protect the honor and credit of the country the senator declared that the sliver silver question whose death and burial has heen been pred predicted acted was a most lively corpse state after suits state had declared in convention Veli tion for silver the great dern democratic 0 party was ready to inscribe on 0 n its banner free silver coinage what the republican party will do at A t st SL louis I 1 do not know said mr teller but I 1 believe I 1 know eno enough u gh ot of the sentiments of the west and ot of the I plain lain people ot of th the a country to say that the party that inscribes on its banner tile gold stan standard lard Is doomed to defeat mr burrows rep mien mich opposed the bill on the ground that it was a virtual repeat repeal of the resumption act which act sustained the paper money of the government before I 1 would vote for a bill carrying tal buch ch dishonor exclaimed mr jr Burro burros Hu vs I 1 1 I 1 had rather a n thou thousand and times that the country I 1 had ad gone down in the awful storm of war I 1 will never raise my hand to remove the last prop that sustains tho the credit of my country applause I 1 TUB THE VOTING BEGINS it was when the voting began tho the presiding officer mr faulkner directed the reading of the amend tonit of mr Ald Aid ilch introduced early in the day allowing bond issues in an to sustain public credit mr air allen alien moved to tabla the amend men arnt t it I 1 was LL a test ot of tho ile twid tiro opposing elements le ments the amendment was tabled years 32 3 nays 25 the individual I 1 vote being identical with that on the final passage mr aldrich offered another amendment providing that nothing in the act shall be construed to impair the obligation of 0 the united states to redeem in coin outstanding united states legal tender notes and treasury notes tor nor to restrict retract the authority of the secretary ot of the treasury to secure coin for their redemption mr fr mills dem tex move moved d to table the amendment which motion prevailed prevO lecy yeas 31 nays naya 25 B an amendment by mr hill that the united states stales treasury notes when once redeemed hall not be relayed rel sued was tahe mad on motion of mr mills 43 to 12 the negative vote was cast by senators lodge platt plait quay wetmore merub 1 I erub leans and balce caffery Cal tery faulkner hill mitchell Ml if 0 wisconsin palmer smith and democrats an amendment by mr quay tor for the redemption and cancellation of treasury notes and tor for the issue afi 0 notes payable in gold and receivable for all debts public and private w was as laid on the table without alt hout dhillon dh 11 islon mr hill moved to postpone the further consideration of tile the bill until december next defeated 24 to sa M this cleared the way tor for the binl vote on oil which the bill was passed beas 1 ens 32 22 noys 25 3 as follows rel lows yeas teas republicans cown C own cannon duborg lians brough mitchell Ml or pettigrew pritchard teller warren wolcott if 11 democrats bacon bati bate berry chilton daniel george harris jones aik mills morgan organ pasco tillman turnip vet walthall WRItha 11 White 17 allen alien butler jones N nov nev ev reffer Stev stewart vart 5 total 32 nays republicans leans aldrich alleion All lion burrows burrous chandler cullom davis gal linger male hale hawley lodge mcbrian McBri ae nelson platt quay Q U Y wetmore allion wit ag democrats brice catic ry faulk nor ncr hill lindsay mitchell fw WK palmer smith vilas 3 9 total 23 25 the filled cheepo mil bill wag as taken ui lip and made tile the unfinished busl neA at 7 M mr r hill moved to ad journ and BS as the motion was carried mr hill exclaim exclaimed med and may cloi save the country |