Show TILLMAN FLAYED i BY PRESIDENT Speaking peaking Through Senator Lodge Roosevelt Denounces Denounces De De- flounces Falsehood f WAS SE SENSATION IN SENATE I r A Denies ell fh Tim l He JIt Oil OfT JUa lih on Oil I Hull Kail- i Har Hate Mill Bill I Washington ton ray May fH 1 12 Upon tIon Upon th the IL floor of the tile senate sellMe this afternoon dur dur- ii Ing consideration o of oC the railway rate f the the President nt of the United Unite United States tat acting through Senator Lodge j of ut Massachusetts 1 as an a d dc r i. i 4 liberate and unqualified falsehood ll the thel l' l charge that he had hall characterized Son Son- Ii f atom atoJ Spoon Spooner l Knox and Foraker a as senatorial lawyers and und that he lie ha had broken bulen with them on the rate ques- ques lion The he Incident lame came as a aL L climax to the tho implied charge by b M Mr h Tillman of oe South Carolina nominally j in charge of or the rate bill that th the Pr President had hall been treacherous t thim to 5 him and to Mr Ir Bailey DaJley Attorney General Gen Gen- l oral eral Moody and former om r Senator Chandler of ot Ne' Ne Hampshire now a ac c member lomber of the Spanish trent treaty claIms claim commission lon all of whom had been unlisted by tho the President l he said t to defeat the time senatorial con conservatives er Mr Ir Tiliman read ead from and U ho apolo apologized for or this b by saying that he wished to be entirely accurate ate The rime paper contained what he saIl said was wu a chronological recital of oC the conf conferences of or himself and Mr Mi Bailey Balle with the time President through former Senator Chandler and later with the S. S attorney general The Tho nece necessity for foi foran an Intermediary was due to the personal per per- differences of ot long standing between be be- tween Mr Tillmon and und the President The Th President PIe In- In 11 explained had sought the Interviews through the thc former rom for mer senator with a Il view of ot t ICho If IC ho could not unite the Democratic senators with th the friends of oC If the Hepburn Hepburn Hep Hop burn bill and thus defeat those who were endeavoring to Incorporate a broad broad Judicial review rc o of time the bill blU t GI C Gives jives s Chandlers Com citation I In telling of ot how liow he burled his pernal per per- nal differences and In giving the Presidents President's ident re reasons om for tor desiring conference con- con forencE ference with hl his personal en enemy em Mr MI Tillman said Mr 1 Chandler handlei said rold the President named various Republican f na oJo Yo w why I he thought were true rl QU a t tt 1 n t t-ald t that the Prest Prest- tn d tl that he hail haG come to disagreement wIth the th senatorial sen sea lawyers rs who wore were trying to defeat lefeat tho the bill bUt or Injure It by Ingenious constitutional amendments naming Senator Knox In tn addition to Senators Spooner and Foraker A A. laugh went around the chamber chamberas as he said this The senators referred to U were In their seats and they reddened red red- as the they shook their heads In dissent J odge od e Challenge l' l Attention It was some time lime later when Mr 11 Lodge the Presidents President's warm personal person person- r al friend entered tho chamber II H Ih was wn apparently laboring under emotIon emo emo- lIeu tIon as he secured ed recognition and amI be- be beun gait fran un speaking Ills His first sentence challenged attention Il He lie said I 1 was unfortunately out of uC this chamber and did not have th felicity f of or hearing the statement thu was as read rend In the tho senate by the tho senator senator senator sena sena- tor from rota South Carolina When 1 I returned returned re re- turned to the senate I was told about the time statement and there was repented repeated repeat repent ed to me some Komo of the statements that were contained in It One of ot the statements attributed to Mr 11 Chandler In regard to tu the senator from rom Ohio Mr dr 01 r Foraker In regard to the senator from Wisconsin Air Mr Spooner and In regard Ics to tho the senator from Pennsylvania Pennsyl Pennsyl- vania Mr Ir Knox struck me rae as us so 80 extraordinary ex extraordinary and seemed emed to me mu on It face fuce so tO unlikely to be c correct on and 1 s unjust to three senators Involved that I took It IL upon myself to go t tl tho office of or tho the stenographer and g se ge sethe the sentence accurately copied out The rime sentence to which I refer from this Mr MI the stenographers stenographer's notes notcH In Is Chandler said Eald the tho President had stated stated stat stat- ed cd that ho had hod come comae to a disagreement with the El senatorial lawyers lawyers law law- cn who were trying to defeat th tin the bill or ot Injure It by h- ingenious constitutional constitutional arguments argument naming Senator Knox In addition to Senators Spooner and Foraker Make Make- c I 1 then took the liberty II 11 rt of ot calling on Oil the telephone White hite house the of 01 rapid way which Wl was the thc more President and amI I took reach In the I uTe the statement which 1 lie he made lomo tomile to lo down low which I will over 1 Cl the telephone mo tIlO read rend to the senate t because I i now Important that it Ie that it I is think thIn I. I aile alle- the with to the c country should go salt sale He lIe read just jUHl that I 1 hae have fn Ration gallon on statement 1 I lm had rca rca- In reply that the him attributed It to him ln h by n ir h to deliberate and un un- wu i n a Foraker's For fol Senator fal falsehood choo that rail r- r akers aker's name wats va never l enato all ail all in that Wa WOK only name cordial a him him to S b by a of Senator l noX I said suld tha I 1 did no 10 LU o portion of hl his pm I agree with Il a but that I. I thought that oUt a vcr elj strong trong ho had made malIc el tIn meat munt jurisdiction fIm 01 or 01 the K authoritY of ot time the theco co court u rt It I Ia Is Isa I 1 think Mm 11 president alloW this a mere act o of JU Justice out With U tu 10 i th that which statement to go attributed o y to th the was read and DU Hampshire Mr oIl Hann New cw from senator 0 Chandler and the dl disCuSsion disCuS reply There WU no lon Ion continued Billie i ix Carter and over what Time The question of veracity not the said W was I th the President hud had Vie of 0 the w se lon Incident only exciting and ancl 11 Balle Montana of per per- Carter Cartel Mi 11 t minority leader became t th the that thal at times V onCil C I 1 bitter The flu Montana senator defended I tIme the President PI from froni charges char lR of oC cow coward coward- rd- rd ic tc cp and amid characterized d Mr Mm- Huncl who I had hail made them an u the critic from fm j Maryland He Hc ridiculed the public I I I career of Mr 11 Kayner Rayner in the advocacy rul of f legislation that would relieve ve the tilt I I I public from Crom existing railroad evIls lIs and pointed out that his single Ingle act had hatlI I boon ben confined to an amendment to a n abill bill relating to the sale of oC mileage J tickets ticket I II And what whal has the superb Intellect I of or the senator from lom Tex Texas I done In his devotion to the people Mr 11 Cutlet Cutlet- sarcastically asked ed Mr 11 Bailey answered this elue question b by stating that an un Inspection of oC th Ow record showed the th introduction of uC a bill hili prohibiting scalpers ri-em ri from selling tickets And that was by re Mr 11 Carter exclaimed Ho He said id tho tito two senators should remember their own records before they attempted to criticize such a a. courageous man as us the time President In concluding his criticism of the President Mrs Mr Bailey exclaimed Let Lct Letus us have hu no more talk In this Ken senate enate- and In this country about this Iron ott man lie He Is Ig clay and er very common cia clay at that I Texan un An 11 l 1 A All soon on as Mr Ia Cartel Carler was recognized recognized he lie went at the Texas senator rough shod saying that he preferred pi an Inconspicuous position to the tho lofty pretensions of th the senator from rom Tex Tex- as who ho was wrapped In a a. mantle manne of or egotism and strutted about In an at atmosphere atmosphere at- at o of vanity considering ing all other men as aK puny pigmies Mr 1 Bailey Jumped to his feet He 11 charged that his words had hod been misstated and said he h thought that the senator from Montana ought to be accurate ac- ac accurate ac ac- curate In Iii a u while II He lie declared ei h he would not permit the senators senator's language lan Ian guage to offend him because time the senate senito sen fen ate ito chamber was not miot the place to lo anaver answer answer an an- aver Ui e feelings The senate nate chamber he lie ald said will wm never level be the scene of oC a dl disorderly between me inc and any ony other sen sea ator atol er Defend President Mr 1 in a warm defense of or orthe the time President brought a shout hout from rom the chamber chambel when he spoke of the retirement of oC the rival Ihal senatorial Ial de- de lt of oC the law who had been bean guarding the constitution all the win intel in tel ter 1 He Ic characterized t the he PI Presidents President's ts t's attitude an UM the most superb moral mond leadership the lie nation ha has ever cr known Mr Mi Clapp Ciapi thought that when the h hysteria terla of time the moment had pa passed ed away the tho people will rf recognize cog the Iho great eat work th the lie President ann and the Republican He- He publican senators had hall done and anil would see clearly that there thele had been ben nn nfl surrender ender to the lie railway Interests interess i Minority IaIN to In mite Amend The entire ion was ivan spent In lii unsuccessful un un- successful Cul attempts by br the tho minority to lo nm amend the Allison amendments amend amend- ments relating elating to venue of tho the cult cit courts and giving them time the power to lO suspend the commissions commission's deem decree b by u a temporary Injunction alter Utez tel a five du days days' 1 notice Time The final linal vote wa was taken taJ late lute J this afternoon when the amendment wits WIL C. C tl n Vote ote of ot 73 to 3 i. i I R mi ite f L r that hat no Injunction Interlocutory Inter intel tier order or ur decree c P or ot n dor or of on ff W hJ h l fl cd ed except on hearing after not l less ss than fl five lays days notice to the t sion Hion An appeal may be taken from can any tk r or HI 1 decree I granting 01 or continuing Injunction In nn any suit but shall He lie only emily in iii the so- so su supreme m I preme court o of the United States Provided further that the appeal must be e taken within thirty days from i ithe the entry of or such uch order or ci- decree and It shall take prece precedence In the appellate appellate appellate appel appel- late court over ovet all other cases except causes of or like character and anel criminal causes |