Show IT WAS A MISTAKE MILD WAY OF PUTTING NIS not only oaly were charges charge IS lut but they were completely ills disproved noble lord loid speechless now new york jan 31 tho the new york tork yacht clubs hoino on madison avenue was crowded tonight with members who ho were anxious to hear the ibo report of tho the investigating committee which was a op P pointed months ago to hear tho the charges preferred by lord Dun Dua ravon raven against agal tho the on oa norn nom ot of the th Ictor victorious ious van tart keo kee craft defender the th report was vms rend read by mr ir J 11 corenn tho the findings tho the charge of tho the earl of dunraven Dun raven that thai after being measured tho the acht Def defender endee was loaded so co as an to sink her lour four inches deeper in the th water so that she ho sidled in that condition tho lite first day that after tho the raco race tho ballast was secretly removed so 90 that vohen ft hen measured tho the next day no discrepancy Y was found to exist bencen the two man tho the conclusion readied Is upon a careful consideration of the whole case uio the committee lii is unanimously outly of abo opinion that tho the charko charge mud in ad by lord hal haj ith ila brigia irk in a mistake that it la is not only not sustained ly by nc but la is disproved and that al all th alio llio el indicated by him Us hit giving EMU rise to its his suspicion aro are entire entirely y and d 0 rily explained r thoy they L deem co n there for but just junt to mr iselin und and th tho ita gentlemen connected with him as ivell au am to tho the officers and crew of tile ibo defender I that lat the should prema emphatically their coti le lotion thai hat g A w latevor occurred I 1 in D connection walh vi tin the raco race in question t hat c casta is the iho loard suspicion upon tho the in top rity or propriety of their conduct ud thu the committee la in not to doubt that if lord had present on t throughout hout tho the wo PO 03 43 to 10 havo have heard beard all tho the evid evidence enco that was introduced lio ito bould of I 1 its his pen onn motion havo ft U it a chargo charge that was ma bo clairdy founded on mistake and t that hat has haa uen can no BO unfortunate lit in tho the publicity it has it tried and tho the feeling to u m holcli it haus haj given iven riso rise darlne aurini tho the reading mailing ot of the report every point elicited chacra and applause when mr morgan had finished tho the report was accepted and adopted it was wad dadd d that tho the consideration of tho the committe VId report be ba postponed until tho the general of tho the club hah london press comments london fob feb I 1 tho the chronicle con tho the dunraven Dun raven committee apen upen its in studied courtesy court ety and consider allo lr when the complete com demolition ot at loia Dunin vens monstrous ions charges might have Ju stIlled tho the severest censure taft th only course open to him DAYS aye tho the chronicle la is an instant and completo apology the 1 I line in in an editorial expresses the tha gr greatest patent respect tor for the tha committee the th only blo objection to the composition govel of W which left la Is that tho the legal and bun inep element sernau hat outweighed the iho expert element clement 1 I it t Is id not quit obvious the iho times continues cont t in aes ues athy by they declined to investigate other charges then than tho the immersion charge while some grounds ff round a 0 the iho committe bs do decision cllon aro are strong and pertinent nent others appear n r to bo be of a less coget nature aih tho T language adopted by the committee continues tho the times will seem beem unduly 90 cre tt ahen hen it Is in remembered that tho the charge ai not mado made public by lord denmen until it had already boon been pub by tho cup committee in now I 1 i ork bab it in to lo bw also alao that tho the corn com w were er unable to take lako a ulder tew lew of their functions and to 10 judge tho the weola cato cao on OK hi fig merits ohp lh result of tho the in u Is to acquit mr kelln iselin and his ar friend crews J of a chargo charge which waa not dot brought broucht against them but it can hardly bo be sa paid 14 to have cleared in a Mila factory mannor the iho real matter at al for a wonder wont taut talk london jan inn 31 cople copies of tho the decision of tile iho committee on investigation of the now new york yacht yach t club were delivered to the ibo press and to lord Dun ravon nt io 10 lit by mr bums buma lord bunra dunraven Dun raven apont t tho the evening et at tho the bladl boroug baroukh en c dun 1 u pvn an and d arr arrived ed at ac hla his reid deco juat t in time to receive the th document an in ule linw was wan sought tonight with lord liun raven but tie ho refused to express on aji opinion a or r to speak for publication on oa tho the decision |