Show no OLLINS i J INS D L AS 1 1 J La L J g NOW NOV NOT V ANTED I New York Player Would Not Add Strength to the Phil Philadelphia adelphia Te Team m When hen lile Donlin release was ns wanted by br the PhIladelphia club It was thought that all the Quaker City Imp papers ls would the s with much JO Joy But on the tho contrary some somo o of the tho writers were disposed to think that Philadelphia got the worst of oC the bargain One Oue writer as blows upon the trade singing i I Assuming that Donlin I Ic 4 I good bood a as eol can set got Into condition and strikes cia J last year with Ith Now New there thoro Is no doubt that ho be would bo be a valuable man manor or any club The Donlin of old was wasa a ballplayer He mn may lie be Just Justas as good today as ever oer Wo o hope ho hoIs hoIs Is chief chlof faUle name as a player rests his him abIlity as a batsman lie He Is n a slugger of the tho Magee t type pe As Asa a thrower and he ranks little higher than the tho average and his limitations In these respects make him a loss less desirable able man to R a team than the tho man for whom he was exchanged Denim Donlin has hns spurs to win as n a manager It Is this phase of th deal deni that Is open to con conjecture jecture although it would bo be almost impossible for him to demonstrate less ability In this direction than the man he succeeds But lila his nat natural ural as aggressiveness Donlin has never exhibited any pronounced managerial traits HIs ungovernable temper has hns brought him Into disrepute moro more than I and it seems an unwise move moe to I place a man In charge of n a baseball 1 team who 1 e eera era ern himself This is the view ot oC the past n I S must he said that since his to Mabel he hIlS been a different Donlin and with the responsibility of placed upon his shoulders ders he mn may prove n a surprise to his I closer friends Wo We sincerely hope SO and wish hIm unmeasured success In Inthis inthis this elt city Donlin Is In no condition to play ball now It will take Ue the better hetter part of 01 a month for him to strike his true ronn even oen assuming that thal ho he is the Donlin of former years There are arc grave grao doubts ns as to 10 sound phys physical physical ical condItion DIrect reports have hao been received from the west vest that dur durIng Ing his sojourn there thero ho was wa attacked t 1 co with o of the lungs if th thee I aru truo Irue It Is 51 safe to tomy say my that the great hitter hiller will never again he himself |