Show REA BETTY TTY AVERS HE WILL TOP STOP OGDEN HEALTH BUREAU FUNDS Rather Rather Warm arm Session of City Dads and Dr Beatty DR BELNAP BELNAP TO GO GJ Commissioner Says ITe Stands Bark Back of Appointees A Dr T f B n Beatly Blatty secretary of th stale slate board of and anti members ot of the p city 1 this morn morn- morn log Ing in tn the matter ot of changes In III 1 the h i Uy ity h health all h depart- depart depart meni meat after r a l n legan eg mildly but de- de de developed eloped toward towal l the end In warm statements At th the end It was Indicated bY Dr Heally that thai on fl n the thc face of at things wit with Ih h a n o n m w ac tint raIned per per- per personnel in tat the hi li h nith lIh titi 1110 stale and th lit lit- national health Institute which spends approximately approximately approximately 2700 a year yal for tor health work in Vl W ber county would withdraw that financial la probably lately aloner Harman W V Peery indicated 1 h l lat hr at ouid make mak no ito s changra in I the tile until hIs har haI hn l bell been given a chance chanco to dhow that th they could not nol weld to to an in efficient health depart depart- dep department rt fluent ment In IX 1 iN TO It was also aim iliad tirade apparent at atthe atthe the meet ing that th the im resignation of at Dr Di H Earl Belnap health corn com missioner has holI been requested and that Dr Walter I lt I B Whalen former city physician tu Is to succeed Mm ThE resignation of Dr DI how how- however vcr how I ever er ho has baa not y t t been tendered it itI Iti was sal said l I To re this Dr Beatty Bently also strenuously I oust objected setting forth that Dr was an unusual man I highly trained In health work anti and with a sincere interest In the health of the community which h is is ob ot I from from but tow few men melt I I I agree that Dr Di- i is is fl fG- fG dent lent and a good Iuan Inan Commis loner I Ioner Peery answered but since Ince the appointments of ot new lIew iner mn 1110 he hhas has I not given riven the department hi his I support lIpport There here has ha hen been not ng but turmoil and the logical I thing hill now hOW Is to tel get a new Ulan man I have on one in mind who ha has conducted 1 this the department efficiently before TAKK TRE nT 1 Mayor Maor Glor George K B E Browning and I t Flygare ok li-ok h Into th the dl at times but Iho was sans l lc lc- e tween Commissioner Peel Peery and Dr Beatty May Mayor or Browning and Com Corn Commissioner missioner Fly care thought that the best thing to do was to permit this tho present department to operate un- un un until til ill a true gauge could conid be obtain ti d dof of the Ibe new men DI Dr Joseph U It Morrell a II mEm lt of at the III state at board of health nho who Is it Issued sued a statement Saturday in ira which wJ the health department was hold tid hl lacking In tn efficiency because of ot an entirely new personnel did notz not z p peat peal pear p-pear at I the he conference BI u Ill Ill- TTY Sl mv n L n Dr BeaU made the first lIRt state mont ment to th the board in itt which he ha said interest My visit here and anti the only in terest I have Is in the th desire to I the health h work of ot tho the administration 1 ra- ra ration tion accomplished efficiently I 1 not rested lull in tn personnel 01 or per pcr but a as we wo assist finin daily In the carrying on of or work worl in the county I would nal naturally I ally desire the work done as as liS possible Experience has hils shown that thai w we an cannot not obtain lIcy jf unless the hit 1113 full tull time service of or IS II given This has hai been heen made ap parent nt after long study of time half health work The international health board and the Rockefeller foundation ar spending large amounts in communities to carry on full Cull t- t ia 1 t health service If Jr th the state will still tIt out up certain amounts the e foundation will match these sums to any amount provided It goes goe to various counties for tor or financial as- as as assistance of at full time Work ONE OXE ISION There I IH is only on one pro t that hat is that the work must h lie ho eai ru rh on efficiently b by an force Corce This financial aid ha has been or of grit assistance in general halh orl and Weber county was tho th first in the stat stat to 10 len pt 11 it It iii IJ haI far I he work tt-ork ork in iii Weber clr county hi ha I n ii i l fin fin jh N- N Ni Health i In Institute has i n II argI l praised high highly l lily I the work In and Weber county In fn the practical out ot or h I fie c health program One Gnu 11 of th features I la ii th lii file s a rs of I Ii In Situ alth c ci In iii runt communities for tor tho pre pre- pres H s tWill 11 children expectant mothers and amid other health molten mailers The Th II officer goes sors thel there thero with th tin tinI II I u fl nur IJ U- U au lId arid thy they LiVy Y rn ri- ri n I u fl IJ U- U au LiVy Y ri- ri n dir Ir jn ama Th- Th Tb work In Weber county has no so la I n ii carried on 01 Industriously and andI andt I t I personnel lies lias ha been fine It ItI Itt t I I ill I I bull to ft gd gd trul nd men mn forI for rol I II I i work vork for COI th the SRI paid ld ow- ow o 0 the tint Iha go i o Wit nth I not no not her 11 Impo taut 1 I 15 is tia Ih In lion of oC i n u l nt 11 I cnn throUghout ll rou hout tl tin city amii JUnt which will eventually naomi that I th h hi ase Ill is ill In tn th the future rulure b he practically ii out ill i'll rii ii 1 J i o i the Ihl I is I ii i i P f not 1101 di I 11 I I I nine l I tiC y 1111 iii list itatI I I i of oC 1 I which LI tin pub pub- pub ill Ut 01 11 ii ii ii in Ut If The rho officer Oi Ot r a iTO 1 TWO vo V DR BEATTY REAlTY TO TU TUV V WITHDRAW I Continued from tro rage age One oae has lias the law behind him and his placing work especially In regard to ing of ot quarantines quarantine I Is highly Im- Im Important Im Important They must take cultures culture from the throats of ot children who may suchs maybe be in first stages stage of ot a disease such aa 55 and the tho manner In which they are handled may save th the life of ot a child Tho The question of ot organizing an efficient department Is for tor you to determine because It must be et- et ef efficient or It will wll be Impossible to function Trained men are necel- necel necessary sar sary Ii It la is hard to set get and keep men In many instances Inse-ancl because ot of political changes change and in appoint appoint- appointment ment for political purposes rather than from the standpoint ot of of- of ef efficiency Many services are re- re re reorganized organized because of ot politics and Consequently capable honest hon Bt men who bavo havo become Invaluable be- be because because be because cause of o their experience are changed for tor others othen BEST IS 1 DESIRED I dont don't believe the people ot of this thle community would be ao so dl- dl dis interested disinterested In the welfare of ot their city as not to demand the thO highest efficIency that could b be bo obtained Dr Belnap has hag proven a val val- val valuable tobe man He was a selected to be sent to California for special health work ork training in order to tomake tomake tomake make his administration efficient Dr Belnap has haa learned public health work and personally speak speak- speakIng speak Ing I have no mor more Interest In him than any other car capable man but he ha has attained a high h h degree ot of efficiency because of ot his train train- ing training It 1 Is Ie hard to get a a man really sincere incero In his hi ork FERRY lIERY Until this point Dr Beatty had the floor Commissioner Pecry broke bloke In declaring I appointed Dr Belnap when I came In office and I believe he ho Is fa a a a capable man But since that time lime lie has as been on the warpath He lie ha has ae not given elven the men and the department hie hi operation operation co-operation and I 1 feel leel the prop- prop er Cr proper thing to do I make a change I 1 have hae a man In mind who has handled the health before and he I Is highly efficient Dr Blatt Beatty asked naked Do you OU ou know your meat Inspector Yes TM Con vu Peery lie He has haa all the quaIl qualifications heIs hoIs to do the work ok and he Is doing It properly Mayor Browning then joined the discussion by saying While the health department comes dl- dl di directly under Commissioner Peer Peery we are vitally tally interested The meat Inspector came to us highly recommended and as to the n new w welly city elly milk Inspector we have hue bad many calls ails which commend upon this appointment We are per pu- per perfectly satisfied hes he 4 is s fair con con- conscientious con conscientious and capable BR REPLIES Commissioner Peery at al this point said Mid that everything was as be- be be thE InC being bethE done to make the department II a worthy orthy organization and he was as d of working with the state in Ia health matters matter Jt n Is II very Pry deplorable ble to change a staff taCt of ot this sort fort for purely political reasons reason Dr Beatty an answered Ma Browning Bro B r rown ln i ng then th An en said sa sawas id Iwas It U t was al very unfortunate that Corn Com mIssioner leery Peery and Dr Belnap had hed not gotten together and dis- dis discussed discussed discussed cussed th the matter of ot appointments before they were made He said sai 1 saihe he did not approve of changes for tor political reasons and had no doubt that politics were ere not considered In the appointments lie Ho said old he held Dr Belnap as a fine con con- conscientious man roan CONDEMNED ED IN TN HASTE STE youa Dr Beatty Inquired Have you ou l a good quarantine Inspector Mr fr Peery replied Yes Yea He lie Is capable and will learn My men all have been condemned before they have been given a II chance Dr Belnap should have come conic to tome tome time me it if he ho desired delred to retain his himen i men He lie did not ask uk to i them It If I were In his ls place In- In answered Dr Beatty I 1 would deep deep- deeply ly iy resent the changing of ot the per per- per pert lonnel I perI i I mal I le our ourthe the conduct of ot the department It happens that I am ant directly I tor for the showing made mad by the tha th department e Commissioner r Peery retorted and I t am ann trying to make It function properly It if Ionly given ven a chance I feel eel tha that t my ny men are fI fitted ted to the work wor and will Why W not give them a fair trial trill SPEND SPES-D IT j i I I x 1 didn't corn como hero In inV 8 V bellig bollig- bollig trent erent attitude Dr Br Beatty saId however hOwe we e can take our money mono and spend It elsewhere I 1 desire to operate co-operate with the state in all heal health h matters maUn which will benefit the tho public eloner Peery SAM said but hut I dont don't In- In InI In intend I tend nd to be run over I only want you to tn reel feel that you are arc doln doing Ih the best you ou can Dr hr Beatty Is remarked There is no one who has haa the th Of oc an ann wooer county more ut at heart than I have came camo Commissioner Peery's reply Mayor Browning apparently diplomatically tried to end the argument at this point when he said Well Dr Beatt Beatty wo we ape ap- your our coming here tere very ery much You You have given ri tv valuable Information Information- V I would like Ilka to meet the men ot of the health department Dr Beatty replied It would be de- de deplorable d It if we ha hail had 1 tl to withdraw our support after the health work here has developed 10 so Q success success- successfully lull fully DONT DON'T WitT T nUrTURE And we would not like to have Anything happen that would rup- rup rupture ture the tho fine tine results result the mayor may assure aure him Peery Pecry Peery reassured Dr BeaUy Beatty I tell feel eel that the men m mI menI I hav appointed ar are arc efficient and it if I am ant forced to make a change in the head o of the de- de d It is III I because f of his hie hi own on actions The men are arc cc doing their hebest best beat Dr Beatty got up to leave You Y cant can't taped laymen to Ito o In and have 1 a good organization I would resign s a head bead it if Inn given II o a new personnel and I still was W-LS responsible sible Ible for tor the department r lIe Ho is i going to 0 tans change or oram I Iam Iam am going to make a ch change nc Peery answered Dont do anything hasty huty Dr BeoUy Beatty said caid Dr Belnap Is I an unusually efficient man n Is II sIncere and baa ha an In his hla work ork My lily men are arc to save ave the city money In tn the nw garbage garbs contract er Peery y said and It if saving money arid and an d being efficient ix is not efficiency then what 1 Is It We want loyalty from fro the men me mein n In the department Mayor Maor Browning broko broke in POLITICS lU CS Dr Beatty Bratty replied You cant can't efficiency lency when ne new men are thrust upon him It Is la un Un- Un Unfortunate unfortunate fortunate that a community has haa hasto hato to suffer Bulter from politics Politics PolIties has hae ha nothing to do willIt with It said Commissioner Peer Peery but buI I must have loyal loal men In my de- de departments department It may bring brin a crisis which may Involve the future of ot the city warned w Dr Beatty Commissioner Far Flygare suggested that a longer time be given before the state makes any mote moC and the work ork o of the health men can he be hemore bemore more carefully gauged It If a change Is to be made mad In Ira the head hoa of th the health department he might make changes in the per per- personnel per personnel which ma may meet med with Ith your you our approval Dr Beatty Beatly replied The state will wUl absolutely not no offer financial aid ald to any depart depart- ment merit that I la Is not effIcient ut and the th tate department Is 1 the sole judge of ot efficiency for tor th the National Health Institute and the Rockefeller teller feller foundation The changes I feel 1111 are a slap In the tho ho face tace to t members of ot the state board of health and I 1 dont don't think the boar board would allow much time and might withdraw the aid ly It seems that you u arn arti a subject to politics politic If it you would not ghe men a 8 fair chance Commissioner Peery ld Id I believe that before belore the financial aid would be with with- withdrawn withdrawn drawn that the matter should be betaken betaken b taken up with the governor I dont don't believe that the gover- gover governor governor governor nor would give Ive It much consideration lien tion Dr Beatty answered Mayer Browning then suggested thata that a few tew wee weeks be allowed mn to mn pass paM before any action was taken take takeso so 50 the department would have a chance to ailie a regard to efficiency I will win stay by my men n m n because they are doing good work and a 1 change chanel should hould not b be asked so 10 sc quickly Commissioner Peery said That Is te not the point said Dr Beatty it Is a violation ot of the policy the whole thing Li based upon M My only here wa was to set let forth the policy polIy which the two contributing factors to the state slate in the health work have Idid I Idid did not come here hen to I After cheery Com Corn missioner are Flygare helped Dr Beatty on with his coat and the meeting adjourned |